Annie Walters was a midwife in her fifties who worked with Amelia Sach, the younger woman who ran a lying-in home in East Finchley, London. Sach took fees from unmarried mothers, promised that their babies would be adopted into good homes, and sent for Walters when a child was born. In November 1902 a detective followed Walters across London and found her holding a dead boy four days old. She admitted giving him chlorodyne, a narcotic. Walters and Sach were convicted of murdering that one child, though they were suspected of killing many more, and on the morning of February 3, 1903, they were hanged side by side at Holloway Prison. They were the first women executed at Holloway, and the last two women hanged together in Britain.
The writer Laura Thompson, describing the execution in her 2018 book on the case of Edith Thompson, says Walters was in her fifties in 1903 and that Sach was about twenty years younger. The novelist and historian Caitlin Davies, who researched the case for a fictional account and for an Islington Museum exhibition on crime and punishment, describes Walters as a midwife who worked for Sach's home and who appeared elderly in 1902.
In 1902 Walters rented lodgings in Islington. She told her landlady that she was a midwife and that she was expecting a baby that was to be adopted, according to Davies. Davies writes that Walters may herself have been addicted to chlorodyne, the drug she later admitted giving to the child.
Amelia Sach, who was 29 in the summer of 1902, ran one in East Finchley, Davies writes. Her advert offered "Accouchement, before and during. Skilled nursing," and added that the "baby can remain": a mother could give birth there and leave the child behind to be adopted.
The arrangement had a price. In the case that came to trial, Sach persuaded the mother, a young servant, to give up her baby for twenty-five pounds, and promised that the child would be brought up by a titled lady. Walters's part, Davies writes, was to collect the babies, and she was to receive ten shillings for it.
The practice of taking in unwanted children for money was known as baby farming. Laura Thompson describes Walters and Sach as baby farmers who took in unwanted children for a fee and then killed them with chlorodyne. That description covers more than the single death for which they were tried; it is the writer's summary of what the two women were believed to have done, not a finding of the court.
Davies traces the weeks before the arrest. On November 12, 1902, Walters received a telegram from Sach's home and brought a baby back to her lodgings in Islington that day. Two days later that baby was no longer there. No charge concerned that child.
The landlady was married to a police constable, and she had grown suspicious. She asked her son to follow Walters, and he did. On November 15 Walters received a second telegram. That night she met a stylishly dressed woman who had arrived by hansom cab, and she brought another baby home. The woman, Davies writes, had asked for a baby to be fetched from the lying-in home and brought to Kensington the following week, for delivery to a coastguard's wife in Eastbourne.
The second baby was a boy, born at Sach's home on November 15, 1902, to the young servant. He was healthy when he was born.
Three days after Walters brought the boy home, she left her lodgings carrying a bundle. A detective followed her and found that she was holding the four-day-old boy, who was dead. Walters admitted that she had given the child chlorodyne. She was arrested for murder, Davies writes, and Amelia Sach was arrested too and charged as an accessory.
The landlady's suspicions, and her son's watch on Walters's movements, were what brought the police in, according to Davies.
Walters and Sach were tried together for the death of the boy. Both were convicted of murdering one child, Davies writes, although they were suspected of killing many more. The historian Daniel Grey, writing in 2009 about baby farming prosecutions in England and Wales, refers to the "joint conviction and execution" of Amelia Sach and Annie Walters in early 1903.
Walters and Sach were hanged together at Holloway Prison, London, on the morning of February 3, 1903. Laura Thompson writes that the two women had acted together and died together, in the same moments, and that by one minute past nine that morning the executions were over. Davies notes that they were the first women hanged at Holloway and the last two women to be hanged together in Britain.
Thompson describes the hangman, Henry Pierrepoint, calling them baby farmers "of the worst kind." She writes that the two women met their deaths very differently. Walters was calm. She is reported to have called out "Goodbye Sach," Thompson writes, as if she were seeing off a friend. Sach, much younger, could not control her emotions and collapsed.
Thompson also observes that poverty, which sometimes helped condemned women win a reprieve, did not save either of them.
Historians differ on what the case changed. Davies, writing in 2009, says the execution helped lead to the Children Act of 1908, and that baby farming had almost disappeared by the 1920s. Daniel Grey, in his study of baby farming trials after that Act, takes a different view: he writes that earlier high-profile cases, including the conviction and execution of Sach and Walters, had not led to any change in the law. Grey traces the 1908 reform to evidence given to a committee in 1908, including testimony that cited the execution of another baby farmer, Leslie James, the year before.
The Children Act 1908 extended the system of infant life protection to homes caring for only one child, which earlier law had left out. It raised the age of the children covered from five to seven, and it required anyone keeping a child for more than 24 hours to register with the local authority and accept inspection by an infant life protection visitor. Grey argues that closing that gap sharply reduced both public fear of baby farming and the number of prosecutions.
The number of infants who died in the care of Walters and Sach has never been established. The court convicted them of one death. Davies writes that they were suspected of killing many more, and Laura Thompson describes them as baby farmers who killed the children they took in; neither gives a figure, and no other child is named or dated. The first baby Walters took home in November 1902 was gone from her lodgings after two days, and no charge was brought over that child.
1902: Amelia Sach, 29 that summer, runs a lying-in home in East Finchley; Annie Walters lodges in Islington and works with her.
November 12, 1902: Walters receives a telegram from Sach's home and brings a baby to her lodgings; two days later the baby is gone.
November 15, 1902: a boy is born to a young servant at Sach's home; Walters receives a second telegram and takes the baby to her lodgings that night.
November 1902, three days later: a detective follows Walters and finds the boy dead in her arms; she admits giving him chlorodyne and is arrested for murder. Sach is charged as an accessory.
Early 1903: Walters and Sach are convicted together of the boy's murder.
February 3, 1903: Walters and Sach are hanged together at Holloway Prison, the first women executed there.
1908: the Children Act extends infant life protection to homes caring for a single child.