On July 4, 1956, an infant boy was kidnapped in Westbury, on Long Island, and a note left behind demanded $2,000 for his return. The boy did not survive. Seven weeks later, after federal agents had compared the ransom notes against nearly two million samples of handwriting, the trail ended at a probation file in a Brooklyn courthouse and at the name of Angelo John LaMarca, a 31-year-old man who lived in nearby Plainview. He confessed within hours of his arrest. A Nassau County jury convicted him of murder in the first degree and kidnapping, declined to recommend leniency, and he was sentenced to death. After the New York Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment, the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear the case, and the federal courts refused to disturb it, the State of New York executed him on August 7, 1958.
LaMarca was a working man who moved between jobs. At various times he had worked as a mechanic and as a cab driver, and at the time of the kidnapping he was a taxi dispatcher and truck driver. He had recently taken on a house he could not afford. Bills had piled up, he was broke, and a loan shark was threatening him. The sum he wanted was $2,000.
He already had a criminal record. About two years earlier he had been arrested in a federal bootlegging case and placed on federal probation. The papers from that case, filed with the probation office of the federal court in Brooklyn, would decide the investigation that followed.
The note promised the child's safe return if the money was paid. Both attempts at the payment failed. Crowds of reporters and onlookers gathered where the note had told the family to leave the money, and no one came to collect it. On July 10 the kidnapper telephoned twice with fresh instructions and again failed to appear, and a second handwritten note was recovered that experts concluded had come from the same hand.
Under the federal kidnapping law of the day, the Federal Bureau of Investigation had to wait seven days before entering the case. It came in on July 11. The two notes were the only real evidence, and for six weeks agents trained by handwriting examiners from the FBI Laboratory worked through public and official records of every kind, eliminating close to two million samples. The match came on August 22, 1956, at the United States Probation Office in Brooklyn, in a file that belonged to LaMarca.
On August 23, 1956, FBI agents and Nassau County police arrested LaMarca in Plainview. He denied any part in the kidnapping. When he was shown the handwriting comparisons, he confessed. He told the officers that the crowds around the payment point had frightened him off the day after the kidnapping, and his statement led investigators to confirm that the child had died.
Because LaMarca had never crossed a state line, he had not violated the federal kidnapping statute, and the FBI turned him over to the Nassau County authorities for prosecution under New York law.
A Nassau County grand jury indicted LaMarca for murder in the first degree and kidnapping. He pleaded not guilty and filed a specification of insanity, putting his mental state at the time of the kidnapping in issue. A request to move the trial out of the county because of the press coverage was denied, and the case was tried in the Nassau County Court that November.
The jury rejected the insanity specification. It found LaMarca guilty of murder in the first degree and of kidnapping, and it returned its verdict without a recommendation of leniency. On December 14, 1956, he was sentenced to die.
The New York Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction in 1957, in People v. LaMarca, 3 N.Y.2d 452, and on January 6, 1958, the Supreme Court of the United States denied certiorari. LaMarca then sought a writ of habeas corpus in federal court, arguing that publicity in Nassau County had tainted the choice of jurors and denied him a fair trial. A state hearing ordered to test that claim found no unfairness in the jury selection, the federal district court denied the writ in June 1958, and judges of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit twice refused to let him appeal, the second time on August 6, 1958.
Angelo LaMarca was executed by the State of New York on August 7, 1958, the day after the Second Circuit's final ruling, a little more than two years after the kidnapping in Westbury.
LaMarca admitted the kidnapping, and his guilt of the taking itself was not in dispute at trial. What he contested was his responsibility and the fairness of the proceedings. The jury rejected his specification of insanity. His claim that publicity had tainted the choice of jurors was rejected before trial, abandoned on direct appeal, and then rejected again in the state and federal courts.
July 4, 1956: An infant boy is kidnapped in Westbury, New York; a ransom note demands $2,000.
July 11, 1956: The FBI enters the case after the seven-day waiting period.
August 22, 1956: Agents match the ransom notes to handwriting in LaMarca's file at the U.S. Probation Office in Brooklyn.
August 23, 1956: FBI agents and Nassau County police arrest LaMarca in Plainview; he confesses.
August 29, 1956: Indicted for murder in the first degree and kidnapping.
December 1956: The jury convicts him of murder in the first degree and kidnapping, without a recommendation of leniency.
December 14, 1956: Sentenced to death.
1957: The New York Court of Appeals affirms the conviction (3 N.Y.2d 452).
January 6, 1958: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari (355 U.S. 920).
June 1958: The federal district court denies his habeas petition.
August 6, 1958: A Second Circuit judge refuses a final certificate to appeal.
August 7, 1958: Executed by the State of New York.