Andrija Artuković was the interior minister of the Independent State of Croatia, the Ustasha state set up in Zagreb in April 1941 in collaboration with Germany and Italy. He answered for its police, and Yugoslav officials said his ministry ran its camps. When that state fell in May 1945 he left the country, and in 1948 he entered the United States under a false name on a 60-day tourist visa. Yugoslavia first asked for him in 1951. The fight over his return passed through immigration boards, the federal courts and the Supreme Court of the United States, and it ended on February 12, 1986, when federal marshals flew him to Zagreb.
On May 14, 1986, the Zagreb District Court found him guilty on four counts, convicting him of the mass murder of civilians and prisoners of war, and sentenced him to death. He was 86, legally blind and ill. His appeals failed in Zagreb and in Belgrade, and in May 1987 a court in Zagreb postponed the sentence indefinitely because of his poor health. He died in custody in a prison hospital in that city on January 16, 1988, with the sentence never carried out. He was the first Nazi war-crimes suspect extradited from the United States after the Justice Department created its Office of Special Investigations in 1979.
He was born on November 29, 1899, in Klobuk, near Ljubuški in Herzegovina, then part of Austria-Hungary. He went to the Franciscan classical school at Široki Brijeg and spent time in the Franciscan order, which recorded in 1920 that he had left it. He finished secondary school in Mostar and studied law in Zagreb, where he worked as a court trainee from 1924. That year he met Ante Pavelić and joined Pavelić's Croatian Party of Rights. He practiced law in Gospić from 1926 to 1932, joined Pavelić's Ustasha organization in 1929, and left Yugoslavia in 1932.
The Ustasha proclaimed the Independent State of Croatia in April 1941. On April 12 Artuković was named to the provisional government, and when Pavelić reached Zagreb he became Minister of Internal Affairs. On May 13, 1941, he signed the order that created the Directorate for Public Order and Security. He became Minister of Justice and Religion on October 10, 1942, went back to the interior ministry from April 29 to October 1, 1943, and served as a state secretary from October 11, 1943, until the state fell on May 8, 1945.
Yugoslav officials said that more than 700,000 people were killed in the camps his ministry ran. The Office of Special Investigations accused him of the wartime persecution or murder of about 700,000 Serbs, 40,000 Roma and 28,000 Jews. No court ever convicted him of any of those totals.
What a court did prove were four specific crimes, each traced to his orders. The first concerned Ješa Vidić, a former official deported to a concentration camp in 1941; a federal magistrate in Los Angeles certified that count as murder in 1985. The second was the killing of the villagers of Vrgin Most and the surrounding settlements in 1942. The third was the killing of about 450 people at the Kerestinec camp, near Zagreb. The fourth was the killing of several hundred captured partisans in 1943.
On May 6, 1945, he left Zagreb with Pavelić and other members of the government and crossed into Austria, where the British held him for a time and then let him go. In July 1945 the Yugoslav State Commission for war crimes declared him a war criminal. He reached Geneva in November 1946 under the name Alojzije Anić, was told by the Swiss authorities to leave, and spent about a year in Dublin before he reached the United States. He obtained permanent residence in 1949 but never became a citizen. He settled in Seal Beach, south of Los Angeles, and worked as a bookkeeper.
In 1951 he was arrested and ordered deported, and Yugoslavia asked for his extradition on 22 counts of murder. The federal district court in Los Angeles first held that the 1902 extradition treaty between the United States and Serbia no longer applied; the Court of Appeals reversed it in 1954, and that October the Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal. In January 1959 a United States commissioner refused the extradition, finding the evidence of guilt insufficient, and in May 1959 immigration authorities stayed his deportation on the ground that he would face persecution in Yugoslavia. For almost two decades he lived openly in Seal Beach.
The government reopened deportation proceedings in 1977. After Congress barred persecution-based stays in 1978 for people accused of taking part in Nazi atrocities, the Board of Immigration Appeals revoked his stay in 1981, but on December 1, 1982, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the board could not do so without first giving him an evidentiary hearing. Yugoslavia then filed a fresh extradition request, and on November 14, 1984, federal marshals and local police arrested him in the Los Angeles area. He was 84 and was held on a prison ward at a medical center in Orange County.
In March 1985 a federal magistrate found probable cause on the 1941 count and gave the government time to gather more evidence from Zagreb; the four counts on which he was later tried were all certified for his extradition. The deputy secretary of state signed the surrender warrant on June 3, 1985. His last appeals ran out in February 1986, when the district court, the Ninth Circuit and a justice of the Supreme Court each refused to stop his removal, and on February 12 he was flown from Los Angeles to Zagreb.
The trial opened at the Zagreb District Court on April 14, 1986. He had been declared legally blind in the United States and suffered from heart disease and high blood pressure, and doctors examined him every day of the hearings. He denied every charge. On May 14, 1986, the court found him guilty on all four counts and sentenced him to death, setting no date for the sentence to be carried out. Under Yugoslav law the sentence was appealed automatically, and the courts in Zagreb and Belgrade rejected every appeal. In May 1987 a court in Zagreb postponed the sentence indefinitely because of his health. He died in the Zagreb jail hospital on January 16, 1988. The Yugoslav news agency Tanjug said he had died of an illness, which it did not name.
Artuković denied every charge, in the American hearings and in Zagreb, and never admitted any part in the killings. Throughout the American proceedings he argued that he could not receive a fair trial in a communist country.
The totals attached to his name in the American proceedings ran into the hundreds of thousands, and they were accusations, never verdicts. The only crimes proved against him in a court were the four counts of May 14, 1986, and the tolls in three of them were stated in round numbers. The American magistrate who first heard the 1984 request found that the Yugoslav indictment did not tie him to particular killings, and at first he certified a single count.
Accounts of the verdict differ on where two of the counts took place: American wire reports placed the third at the Kerestinec camp and gave no place for the fourth, while a Belgrade press account set the third in a Zagreb square in late 1941 and the fourth at Samobor.
His fitness for trial was contested. The defense said he was too old and ill to be tried; the court relied on the daily medical examinations and found him fit, and the same health later led a court in Zagreb to postpone the sentence without date.
November 29, 1899: Andrija Artuković is born in Klobuk, near Ljubuški, Herzegovina.
1924: He begins work as a court trainee in Zagreb and joins the Croatian Party of Rights.
1929: He joins the Ustasha.
1932: He leaves Yugoslavia.
April 12, 1941: He is named to the provisional government of the Independent State of Croatia and becomes Minister of Internal Affairs.
May 13, 1941: He signs the order creating the Directorate for Public Order and Security.
1941: The deportation that forms the first count of conviction.
1942: The killings at Vrgin Most that form the second count.
October 10, 1942: He becomes Minister of Justice and Religion.
April 29 to October 1, 1943: He serves again as interior minister.
1943: The killings of captured partisans that form the fourth count.
May 6, 1945: He leaves Zagreb for Austria.
July 1945: The Yugoslav State Commission declares him a war criminal.
November 1946: He reaches Geneva under the name Alojzije Anić.
1948: He enters the United States under a false name on a tourist visa.
1951: He is arrested and ordered deported; Yugoslavia requests his extradition on 22 counts of murder.
1954: The Court of Appeals upholds the 1902 treaty, and the Supreme Court declines his appeal in October.
January 1959: A United States commissioner refuses the extradition request.
May 1959: His deportation is stayed on persecution grounds.
1977: Deportation proceedings reopen.
1981: The Board of Immigration Appeals revokes the 1959 stay.
December 1, 1982: The Ninth Circuit requires an evidentiary hearing before the stay can be withdrawn.
November 14, 1984: He is arrested in the Los Angeles area on a new Yugoslav extradition request.
March 1985: A federal magistrate finds probable cause on the 1941 count.
June 3, 1985: The deputy secretary of state signs the surrender warrant.
February 12, 1986: He is flown from Los Angeles to Zagreb.
April 14, 1986: His trial opens at the Zagreb District Court.
May 14, 1986: He is convicted on four counts and sentenced to death.
May 1987: A court in Zagreb postpones the sentence indefinitely because of his health.
January 16, 1988: He dies in custody in a prison hospital in Zagreb.