Andrew George Scott was executed in Sydney on January 20, 1880, for the murder of a New South Wales police officer. Two months earlier he and five young men had held the people of Wantabadgery Station, a property in the country between Wagga Wagga and Gundagai, for two days and nights. When police finally cornered the group on a farm nearby, Senior Constable Edward Mostyn Webb-Bowen of the Gundagai station received the injury from which he died on November 23, 1879. Two of Scott's companions died in the same exchange. A Sydney jury found Scott and the three surviving members of the group guilty of murder on December 11, and he went to his death beside one of them, Thomas Rogan.
By then Scott was well known in two colonies. He was the son of an Anglican clergyman. He had studied engineering in London, served in New Zealand and preached in country Victoria, and he had spent most of the 1870s in a Victorian prison for a bank robbery he insisted, to the end, that he had not committed. One of the young men who rode with him in 1879 had met him in that prison.
Scott was born in Rathfriland, County Down, in the north of Ireland, in the 1840s. His family was respected, and his father was a clergyman of the Anglican church. He was well educated, and as a teenager he went to London to study engineering. In 1861 the family moved to Auckland.
In New Zealand he joined the military during the New Zealand Wars, but he did not rise far. In 1867 he was refused a promotion because of a scandal whose nature is unknown, and he left for Australia.
In Victoria Scott took up his father's calling, preaching in the country districts west of Melbourne. By 1869 he was in Mount Egerton, a gold-mining town, where the London Chartered Bank of Australia was robbed on May 8, 1869.
Scott was soon gone. He went to Fiji, and on his return to Sydney he served a year in New South Wales over the theft of a boat.
He was released in 1872 and was extradited to Victoria to answer for the Mount Egerton robbery. While he waited for trial in Ballarat he escaped, and he was retaken. He was convicted in Ballarat that year and sentenced to ten years for the robbery, with a further year for escaping while on remand. He served about seven years of the term.
The conviction never sat easily with him. He maintained until his death that he had had no part in the Mount Egerton robbery.
In the Victorian prison system in the second half of the 1870s, Scott met James Nesbitt, a young man who would follow him for the rest of his life. They came to know each other at some point between 1875 and 1877.
Scott was released early in 1879 and took lodgings in Fitzroy, in Melbourne, with Nesbitt, who was then 21. He tried to speak in public on prison reform, drawing on what he had seen inside, but the authorities blocked the attempt. His name now went ahead of him, and work and lodgings were hard to come by.
Later that year Scott left Victoria for New South Wales with Nesbitt and four other young men. The group was poor and young. The youngest, Gus Wernicke, was 15. The others were Thomas Williams, Graham Bennett and Rogan.
In mid-November 1879 the six held the people of Wantabadgery Station, about 25 miles from Wagga Wagga, for two days and nights, and then more people at a hotel nearby.
Police from Wagga Wagga reached the district and withdrew to wait for reinforcements.
Police from Gundagai and Adelong then found the group on a farm nearby. In the exchange that followed, Wernicke and Nesbitt died and the senior constable who led the police received a fatal injury.
Senior Constable Webb-Bowen was stationed at Gundagai. He died of his injury on Sunday, November 23, 1879, a few days after the confrontation.
Scott was taken at the farm, and Williams and Bennett surrendered there. Rogan was found and arrested the next day. The four were held first at Gundagai and were then moved to Sydney to stand trial for the murder of the constable.
The four men were brought into the dock in Sydney on December 3, 1879. An application to postpone the trial was refused.
Scott conducted his own defense and denied the murder.
On December 11, 1879, the jury found all four men guilty of murder, and all four were sentenced to death.
Between the verdict and his execution Scott wrote more than 60 letters and two longer statements in the condemned cell in Sydney. The authorities did not send them.
Scott and Rogan were executed together in Sydney on January 20, 1880. Williams and Bennett were not executed.
Two convictions stand behind Scott's name, and he contested both. Of the Mount Egerton robbery he said to the end that he was not involved. That conviction, entered in Ballarat in 1872, was never set aside.
On the murder charge in Sydney the verdict went against all four men alike, and it was the verdict on which Scott and Rogan were executed. Scott denied the murder at trial and argued his own case.
Nesbitt and Wernicke died in the same confrontation with police. Neither death was ever charged to Scott or to any surviving member of the gang.
Later stories credited Scott with service in Italy's second war of independence and in the American Civil War. One of his biographers has doubted both, and the years before he reached Victoria are the least documented of his life.
1840s: Born in Rathfriland, County Down, Ireland.
1861: Family moves to Auckland, New Zealand.
1867: Refused a military promotion in New Zealand; leaves for Australia.
May 8, 1869: London Chartered Bank of Australia robbed at Mount Egerton, Victoria.
1872: Released in New South Wales and extradited to Victoria; escapes while on remand in Ballarat and is retaken; convicted in Ballarat and sentenced to ten years, plus one year for the escape.
1875 to 1877: Meets James Nesbitt in a Victorian prison.
Early 1879: Released after about seven years; settles in Fitzroy, Melbourne.
1879: Leaves Victoria for New South Wales with five young men.
Mid-November 1879: The gang holds the people of Wantabadgery Station for two days; two gang members die in the final exchange with police; Scott and two companions are taken, and Rogan the next day.
November 23, 1879: The Gundagai senior constable dies of his injury.
December 3, 1879: Trial opens in Sydney.
December 11, 1879: Scott, Rogan, Williams and Bennett found guilty of murder and sentenced to death.
January 20, 1880: Scott and Rogan executed in Sydney.