Andrew Golden

Victims
5 people killed near Jonesboro, Arkansas, March 24, 1998. Adjudicated delinquent in juvenile court, August 11, 1998, on five counts of capital murder; partly reversed on appeal, 2000
Years active
March 24, 1998
Location
Jonesboro, Craighead County, Arkansas
Method
Capital murder (five counts) and first-degree battery (ten counts), charged by juvenile delinquency petition
Status
Indeterminate juvenile commitment; held to age 21, released 2007; Supreme Court of Arkansas ruling July 13, 2000; died 2019

Five people died near Jonesboro, Arkansas, on March 24, 1998, and ten more were wounded. Two boys were taken into custody that day by the Craighead County Sheriff's Office. The younger was Andrew Golden, who was eleven. Under Arkansas law he was too young to be tried as an adult, and so the case that followed was a juvenile proceeding, held in a closed system whose stated purpose was rehabilitation rather than punishment.

On August 11, 1998, a Craighead County juvenile court ruled him delinquent on every count and committed him to the state's youth services for an indeterminate term. He was held until he turned 21 and was released in 2007. In between, his lawyers carried one question to the Supreme Court of Arkansas: whether a child in juvenile court had the right to have his competency decided before he was judged. In July 2000 the court said that he did. The ruling made Golden the name on a precedent in Arkansas juvenile law, and it left his own adjudication partly undone.

Four of the dead were children. Their first names were Natalie, Paige Ann, Stephanie and Brittheny. The fifth was an adult, Shannon Wright. Ten other people were wounded, nine of them children and one an adult. The petition filed the next morning carried each death as a separate count of capital murder and each of the wounded as a separate count of first-degree battery.

Both boys were in the hands of the sheriff's office within minutes. On March 25, 1998, the day after the deaths, a petition was filed in juvenile court charging each of them with five counts of capital murder and ten counts of first-degree battery. They appeared that same day at a juvenile detention hearing and were held at the county's juvenile detention center. A further hearing was set for April 29.

The age line in the Arkansas code decided the shape of everything that came next. The minimum age at which a child could be charged as an adult was 14, and neither boy had reached it. There was no adult court to transfer the case to, no jury and no sentence of years. Whatever the facts proved, the case would end in juvenile court, with a commitment whose outer limit was set by the child's birthday rather than by the gravity of the charges. State officials asked the United States Department of Justice to look at whether any federal statute would allow an adult trial. Federal law would later play a part in how long Golden was held.

The juvenile system also kept the case largely out of view. Arkansas law barred the release of the name of a juvenile in state custody, and the judge's pretrial rulings were made under a gag order. Several of them became public only on the day of the hearing.

At the probable cause hearing, Golden's counsel told the court that he would raise an insanity defense and challenge Golden's competency to proceed. The juvenile court took up both questions at a separate hearing. It rejected the defense's due process and equal protection arguments and held that a juvenile in Arkansas could not raise competency or insanity at all in a delinquency proceeding, because the juvenile code did not provide for either. Any mental disease or defect, the court ruled, could be considered later, at disposition, when it came time to decide where he would be placed. The safeguards built into a juvenile proceeding, in the trial court's view, made a separate inquiry into his mind before the hearing unnecessary.

That ruling left the defense with a choice. It could seek an interlocutory appeal before the hearing, or it could go through with the adjudication and appeal afterward. Golden's counsel chose the second course. To preserve the two issues, the defense agreed to stipulate to the facts, without entering a guilty plea and without stipulating to intent.

The co-accused, the older boy, pleaded guilty on the morning of August 11, 1998, and was adjudicated delinquent on the same five counts of capital murder and ten counts of first-degree battery.

Golden's adjudication hearing was held the same day before the Craighead County circuit-chancery judge, sitting as juvenile judge. The defense entered a plea of not guilty. In open court his counsel restated the position the judge had already ruled against: that Golden had taken part in the events but had been insane at the time, and that he was not competent to understand the proceeding then under way.

The prosecution called seven witnesses who connected both boys to the deaths. The hearing lasted a little more than three hours. At its close the judge ruled that Golden was delinquent under the juvenile law, the juvenile court's equivalent of a guilty verdict, on all charges.

Disposition followed that afternoon. As the later appellate opinion put it, the court adjudicated him guilty and committed him to an indeterminate term in the Division of Youth Services Training School. The length of the commitment was left to the state's youth services, and it could run to his 21st birthday. The judge added time for aggravating circumstances and for separate statutory violations. The order carried one further condition: if the state released him before he turned 21, he would remain in a juvenile detention center for up to ninety days. Golden declined to make a statement. No motive was offered at the hearing.

The appeal, Golden v. State, No. 99-572, reached the Supreme Court of Arkansas on the two questions the defense had preserved. Counsel framed them as four points: that denying him a competency determination violated due process and equal protection, and that denying him an insanity defense violated the same two guarantees. A first opinion was delivered in June 2000. A substituted opinion followed on July 13, 2000, written by the chief justice, with one justice dissenting.

On competency, the court reversed. It began from the adult rule. The United States Supreme Court had held, in Drope v. Missouri and again in Cooper v. Oklahoma, that a person may not be tried while incompetent. The question was whether that protection reached a child in a delinquency hearing, and the Arkansas juvenile code at the time of Golden's hearing gave no answer, because it made no provision for competency at all. The court read that silence as a presumption. The code, it wrote, "seems to presume that a defendant being tried in juvenile court is incompetent", and so had never thought to ask.

The decisive authority was the United States Supreme Court's decision in In re Gault. Gault had held that a juvenile proceeding need not match a criminal trial in every respect, but that a child facing commitment had a right to counsel. The Arkansas court drew the consequence: "Logically, this right to counsel means little if the juvenile is unaware of the proceedings." It noted that a Michigan appellate court had reached the same conclusion that year, in In the Matter of Carey, and it held that a juvenile has a due process right to have competency determined before adjudication, in the words of the opinion: "we hold that a juvenile must be allowed to assert incompetency and have his competency determined prior to adjudication." Because it decided that point on due process grounds, it did not reach the equal protection argument on competency.

On insanity, the court affirmed. Relying on its own earlier decision in K.M. v. State and on the United States Supreme Court's decision in Medina v. California, it held that no Arkansas statute at the time gave a juvenile the right to an insanity defense, and that the absence of one did not violate due process. It also rejected the equal protection argument, finding a rational basis for giving juveniles fewer procedural rights in proceedings that were rehabilitative in purpose and that carried no jury trial. Its conclusion on the second question was flat: "neither due process nor equal protection affords a juvenile the right to an insanity defense."

The disposition read: "Reversed and remanded in part; affirmed in part." The dissent would have affirmed on every point, including competency. It wrote that "juveniles do not have a fundamental due process right to not be deprived of their liberty as a result of a hearing during which they were incompetent." The juvenile system, in that view, was built to work without regard to a child's competence, because its absence was presumed; the state's interest as parens patriae could, in proper circumstances, outweigh the child's liberty interest. The dissent saw the majority's ruling as part of a wider drift and called it "the continued erosion of all distinction between juvenile court and adult criminal courts."

The remand sent the competency question back to the Craighead County juvenile court. By then the question of how long Golden would be held had already moved onto a second track.

The juvenile commitment had a ceiling that state law and state facilities set together. On paper an Arkansas delinquent could be held to 21, and the length of the term was left to the state's youth services. In practice the state had no specialized facility for juveniles past 18, and had the means to hold the two boys only until that age. The state's youth services held them at its locked juvenile center.

To make sure that custody would continue past 18, federal prosecutors brought separate federal charges under statutes that allowed a juvenile to be held to age 21. The federal cases did what the state could not. They kept both boys in custody for three more years than Arkansas alone could have managed, and the federal government held each of them until his 21st birthday. The co-accused, who was two years older, was released in August 2005. Golden remained in federal custody, held on the same federal charges, for two years after that.

Golden was released on his 21st birthday in 2007. Because he had been tried as a juvenile, his records were sealed. He later took a new legal name, Drew Douglas Grant, a change that became public in 2008. He was living in Missouri in his last years.

He died on July 27, 2019, in Arkansas.

Golden never pleaded guilty. His adjudication rested on facts his counsel stipulated to preserve the appeal, on the testimony of the prosecution's seven witnesses, and on the juvenile court's finding; the defense did not stipulate to intent. His claims of insanity and incompetence were never tested by any court, the first because the law did not allow it and the second because the ruling that allowed it came two years after the hearing.

His custody after the July 2000 ruling rested on the federal charges as well as on the juvenile commitment, and he was held until 21 on that footing.

Timeline

1986: Andrew Douglas Golden is born.

March 24, 1998: Five people die and ten are wounded near Jonesboro, Arkansas; Golden and an older boy are taken into custody by the Craighead County Sheriff's Office.

March 25, 1998: A juvenile petition charges each boy with five counts of capital murder and ten counts of first-degree battery; a juvenile detention hearing is held.

1998: The juvenile court rules under a gag order that Golden may not raise competency or insanity.

August 11, 1998: The co-accused pleads guilty and is adjudicated delinquent; Golden's adjudication hearing ends with a finding of delinquency on all counts and an indeterminate commitment to the Division of Youth Services.

June 2000: The Supreme Court of Arkansas delivers its first opinion in Golden v. State.

July 13, 2000: Substituted opinion: "Reversed and remanded in part; affirmed in part."

2007: Golden is released on his 21st birthday.

2008: His change of name to Drew Douglas Grant becomes public.

July 27, 2019: He dies in Arkansas.