Andrew George

Victims
1 woman abducted and murdered in Shrewsbury, 1984. Convicted of kidnapping and murder, Stafford Crown Court, May 6, 2005
Years active
March 21, 1984
Location
Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England (killing); Telford, Shropshire, England (first court appearance); Stafford, Staffordshire, England (trial)
Method
Stab wounds and hypothermia, per the Court of Appeal judgment of 2006
Status
Appeal dismissed by the Court of Appeal, June 9, 2006. Sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of 15 years (7 years concurrent, kidnapping), Stafford Crown Court, May 6, 2005.

For twenty-one years nobody was charged with the death of Hilda Murrell. She was abducted from Shrewsbury on March 21, 1984, a well-known conservationist and campaigner against nuclear weapons and nuclear power, and she was found three days later. The case went unsolved for two decades, and in that time it gathered theories about who might have wanted her dead.

The answer, when it came, had nothing to do with the theories. On May 6, 2005, at Stafford Crown Court, Andrew George was convicted of kidnapping and murdering her. He had been sixteen and a half at the time. A High Court judge sentenced him to life imprisonment with a minimum period of 15 years, with a concurrent sentence of seven years' imprisonment for the kidnapping. He had been questioned in 1984, a week after her death, and released because nothing linked him to it. Scientific advances two decades later placed him at the scene, and the Court of Appeal, dismissing his appeal on June 9, 2006, found that he had concealed his presence there for all of those twenty-one years.

The victim was among the first women to graduate from Cambridge, taking her degree in 1927, and she returned afterward to Shrewsbury. By the 1980s she was a familiar figure in Shropshire and beyond, a member of conservation and environmental groups and of nuclear disarmament groups, and a writer on the problem of nuclear waste. The Court of Appeal described her as a well-known local and national conservationist and campaigner.

In the months before her death she had been working on a paper opposing the Sizewell B project, the pressurized water reactor then before a public inquiry. The paper was never presented.

The court that later heard the appeal set out the core of the day in a few sentences. On March 21, 1984, she was abducted from Shrewsbury. She was found on Saturday, March 24. The inquest, held at Shrewsbury on December 5, 1984, found that she had probably died on March 21.

West Mercia Police led the inquiry, and it was a large one. By November 30, 1984, officers had interviewed nearly 12,000 people and taken more than 2,000 statements, and still no one had been charged.

Andrew George was among the people the police spoke to in those first weeks. A week after the death he was arrested for another offense and questioned about where he had been on March 21. He was interviewed again two months later. He gave an alibi, and in the words of the Court of Appeal, there was no evidence to link him with her death at that time.

He was sixteen and a half, and he already had previous convictions. Those convictions would later be put before the jury at his trial, though not as proof that he had committed the murder.

The case stayed open through the 1980s and 1990s without a charge. A cold-case review by West Mercia Police, using scientific techniques that had not existed in 1984, finally led to Andrew George and placed him at the scene on the day she was taken. He was charged with murder at the age of 35 and appeared before magistrates in Telford to answer the charge.

The case was tried at Stafford Crown Court before a High Court judge and a jury in 2005, on charges of kidnapping and murder.

The Crown's case was that he had been burgling her home when she returned, and that he took part in taking her away. It relied on the scientific evidence, on accounts that it said had shifted over twenty-one years, and on lies told in his written account and in the witness box. A man who had once been a police informant, identified in the appeal judgment only as Mr A, said that George had given him details only George could have known. The judge allowed the jury to hear about his previous convictions.

George gave evidence. He admitted that he had been there and that he had been present when she came back. He denied kidnapping her and he denied murder, and he put the blame on another person, who gave evidence at the trial and was never charged.

On May 6, 2005, he was convicted of kidnapping and murder. The judge passed the mandatory life sentence for murder with a minimum period of 15 years, and a concurrent sentence of seven years' imprisonment for the kidnapping.

He appealed against both convictions. The single judge who considered his papers gave him leave on three grounds, which came down to two parts of the trial: the way the judge had directed the jury about his previous convictions, and the judge's handling of the evidence of Mr A. Three judges of the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, heard the appeal and gave judgment on June 9, 2006.

On the previous convictions, the court held that the trial judge's direction had been correct. The evidence had been admitted because George had attacked the character of the person he blamed, not to show that he had a tendency to commit crimes of this kind, and the jury had been properly warned about how to use it. On Mr A, the court noted that no application had been made at trial to exclude his evidence, and found that the jury had been properly warned about his unreliability.

The defense also pressed several factual points, among them evidence that he could not drive and an unidentified man seen running in the area. The court rejected each of them. The man seen running matched neither George nor the person George blamed, and there was no evidence linking him to the murder.

The defense argued finally that the twenty-one-year delay had made a fair trial impossible. The court disagreed: George had known all along that he had been at the scene and had said nothing, and the delay was of his own making. The court refused leave to pursue the renewed grounds and dismissed the substantive grounds. "We are not persuaded that the verdicts were unsafe," it concluded. "This appeal is dismissed."

The central question at the appeal was how a jury may use a defendant's previous convictions under section 101 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 when he has attacked another person's character. The defense argued that the judge should have told the jury to separate convictions that showed dishonesty from those that did not. The court held that this distinction belonged to cases where convictions are admitted to show a tendency to commit offenses, not to cases like his, where they were admitted to test the credibility of the man making the accusation. The trial judge had told the jury it could take his character into account only if it thought it right and fair to do so, and that direction was adequate.

For years before the arrest, claims were raised in Parliament that the intelligence services had been involved in her death; no court heard evidence supporting them, and the convictions rest on the scientific evidence and George's own accounts.

The conviction has its own critics, who question whether George could drive in 1984 and whether evidence from the scene pointed to another man. The Court of Appeal considered the driving evidence, the unidentified man seen running and the other scene evidence, and held that none of them made the verdicts unsafe. No court has found that anyone other than George took part in the kidnapping or the murder.

Timeline

1927: The victim graduates from Cambridge and returns to Shrewsbury.

March 21, 1984: She is abducted from Shrewsbury; the inquest later finds she probably died that day.

March 24, 1984: She is found.

Late March 1984: Andrew George, aged sixteen and a half, is arrested for another offense and questioned about March 21; he gives an alibi.

May 1984: He is interviewed a second time; nothing links him to the death.

November 30, 1984: Police have interviewed nearly 12,000 people and taken more than 2,000 statements.

December 5, 1984: The inquest is held at Shrewsbury.

After a cold-case review: George, aged 35, is charged with murder and appears before magistrates in Telford.

May 6, 2005: At Stafford Crown Court he is convicted of kidnapping and murder; life imprisonment with a minimum period of 15 years, and seven years concurrent for the kidnapping.

June 9, 2006: The Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal.