Andrew Engeldinger

Victims
6 people killed in Minneapolis, September 27, 2012; attributed by police, never charged or tried, as he died by suicide the same day.
Years active
September 27, 2012 (one day; one victim died October 10, 2012)
Location
Minneapolis, Minnesota (killings, Bryn Mawr neighborhood); Richfield, Minnesota (raised).
Method
Shot with a handgun, per the police account; never tested in court.
Status
No trial or sentence. Suicide before trial: died by suicide at the scene in Minneapolis, Minnesota, before police reached him, September 27, 2012.

Late on the afternoon of Thursday, September 27, 2012, Andrew Engeldinger was called into a meeting at Accent Signage Systems in Minneapolis, the company that had employed him since 1999, and told that his job was over. Within minutes, four people connected to the business were dead, others lay gravely hurt, and Engeldinger had died by suicide inside the building. A fifth man died the next day and a sixth on October 10. Minneapolis police identified Engeldinger, who was 36, as the person responsible for all six deaths, and the Hennepin County Medical Examiner ruled them homicides.

No court ever heard the case. Engeldinger was dead before officers reached him, so no charge was filed, no evidence was tested and no verdict was given. The state's labor and industry agency counted it as the deadliest workplace event in Minnesota since it began keeping track in 1992; before that day, no single episode had taken the lives of more than two workers.

Engeldinger grew up in Richfield, Minnesota, and graduated from the Academy of Holy Angels in 1994. For about 12 years before his death he lived in south Minneapolis. Neighbors knew him as a man who kept to himself, came back from work, put his car away and went inside.

His only brush with the courts came in January 1997, when he was 20. On January 21 of that year he was stopped by police in Bloomington over an expired vehicle registration, and the encounter ended with charges of fleeing a police officer and reckless driving. He pleaded guilty to reckless driving, and the fleeing charge was dropped. In the first hours after the September 2012 deaths, police said he had no prior record; the Bloomington case surfaced several days later, and it amounted to a traffic matter, with no violence of any kind on his record.

Accent Signage Systems hired him in 1999. The company had been built from almost nothing. Its founder had started it in Minneapolis in the 1980s and spent three decades turning it into a manufacturer of signs that met the standards of the Americans with Disabilities Act, including Braille signs made by a process the company had patented. Its signs hung in the White House and were sold abroad, as far as China. In August 2012 a visiting Under Secretary of Commerce had praised the company's innovation. By then it filled a large building in the Bryn Mawr neighborhood of Minneapolis, and more than 20 people were at work there on the afternoon of September 27.

Engeldinger spent most of his adult working life at the company. A former co-worker described him as withdrawn, a man who never ate lunch or took breaks with colleagues, who could be confrontational and hard to work with, and who had worn the same clothes and the same hairstyle for years.

The company's file on Engeldinger, which the Minneapolis Police Department released on December 24, 2012, traced a slow deterioration. Until 2006 the record was relatively clean. Then, in October 2006, two co-workers complained that he had been rude and abusive to a new employee, and two managers issued him an official warning. Later that month he went to the company's founder and complained that everyone at work was abusive to him; asked to name the people he meant, he said he needed to talk to his lawyer.

The entries kept coming. In January 2007 managers spoke to him about refusing to follow new manufacturing procedures. In July 2007 two more co-workers complained about his abrasive manner, and another complaint followed that November. On September 20, 2012, a manager put a final written warning in the file: his tardiness had to be corrected immediately. It was the last entry the file contains. Police said afterward that managers had counseled him about his performance before, and that the September warning told him he would be dismissed if nothing changed.

Near the end of the workday on Thursday, September 27, Engeldinger was asked to come to a meeting with the company's operations director and a second manager. In the meeting he was told that he was being dismissed for continued poor performance and lateness, and he was handed his final paycheck.

Police said the violence began immediately afterward and was over before the first officers arrived. Engeldinger had died by suicide before they reached him.

Four people died in Minneapolis that afternoon. A fifth died the next day at Hennepin County Medical Center. Two more were taken to the same hospital, one in serious and one in critical condition, and another person was treated and released.

Reuven Rahamim had founded the company. He grew up on a farm in Israel, served in the Israeli army and fought in the 1973 war, then came to the United States in the mid-1970s, where he first worked as a laborer and studied at Dunwoody College in Minneapolis before starting the business in 1984. People who knew him described a modest, generous and hardworking man. He belonged for many years to Beth El Synagogue in St. Louis Park, where he lived, and he donated dozens of signs to the congregation and to the Heilicher Minneapolis Jewish Day School. He loved to cook and to entertain friends, he cared about developing greener products, and he was devoted to his large family.

Rami Cooks, of Minnetonka, was also a native of Israel and had lived in the United States for about 30 years. He was the founder's right-hand man in day-to-day operations, one of the two managers in the meeting that afternoon, and the author of the September 20 warning. A former colleague remembered a man with a big heart who cared about everyone and tried to make the staff feel like a team. He was the one who died at Hennepin County Medical Center on September 28.

Ronald Edberg, of Brooklyn Center, had been with the company for more than a decade. He was a quiet outdoorsman with a big sense of humor who loved fishing and hunting.

Jacob Beneke, of Maple Grove, came from New Albin, Iowa. He was an artist, a sculptor and painter who had studied graphic design and later traditional bronze sculpture and jewelry making in Italy, and he once wrote that he had enjoyed building things, and the problem solving that came with it, all his life. He gave much of his time to the Maple Grove ArtsCenter, where his award-winning work was on display. A director there remembered him as creative and expressive.

Keith Basinski, of Spring Lake Park, did not work for the company. He was a Wisconsin native and a Green Bay Packers fan who had made regular deliveries and pickups at the business for years and was a familiar face there. Neighbors knew him as a family man.

Eric Rivers, of St. Paul, was one of the two people still in critical condition after September 27. He remained at Hennepin County Medical Center until Wednesday, October 10, 2012, when he died. The company called him a dear friend and colleague, and a co-worker said people could go to him with anything and strike up a conversation with him at any time. The Hennepin County Medical Examiner ruled his death a homicide, and with it the toll reached six.

The operations director survived; he was upgraded from critical to serious condition the day after the deaths.

In the first days police could say little about why it had happened. On September 28 they gave no reason for the dismissal, the company declined to discuss it, and the first police account had him let go that morning and returning in the afternoon. By Saturday, September 29, investigators understood that he had received a letter of reprimand the week before and had come in on Thursday afternoon, when the dismissal took place.

On Monday, October 1, investigators handed the police chief a detailed timeline, and the department made it public the same day, together with a chronology for each person who was harmed and a set of answers to common questions. The timeline set out the end-of-day meeting and the final paycheck. The department planned no further briefings, and no criminal charge was ever filed. The last public step came on Christmas Eve, when the department released the personnel file that set out six years of complaints and warnings ending on September 20.

Because Engeldinger died before any court could hear the case, every account of September 27 rests on the police reconstruction, which no judge or jury ever tested. Police identified him as responsible and closed the investigation without a criminal proceeding, so his responsibility was never adjudicated.

No court or inquest examined his state of mind, and no finding on motive was ever made.

Timeline

1994: Graduates from the Academy of Holy Angels in Richfield, Minnesota.

January 21, 1997: Charged in Bloomington, Minnesota, with fleeing a police officer and reckless driving; later pleads guilty to reckless driving, and the fleeing charge is dropped.

1999: Hired by Accent Signage Systems in Minneapolis.

October 2006: Receives an official warning after co-workers complain about his conduct toward a new employee.

January to November 2007: Further warnings and complaints about procedures and his manner at work.

September 20, 2012: Final written warning about tardiness.

September 27, 2012: Dismissed at an end-of-day meeting in Minneapolis; within minutes four people are dead and others gravely hurt; he dies by suicide.

September 28, 2012: A fifth person dies at Hennepin County Medical Center.

October 1, 2012: Minneapolis police release a detailed timeline; the chief says it may conclude the investigation.

October 10, 2012: A sixth person dies at Hennepin County Medical Center.

December 24, 2012: Minneapolis police release his personnel file.