Andreas S.

Victims
2 police officers murdered near Ulmet, Kusel district, 2022. Life imprisonment with particular severity of guilt, Kaiserslautern, November 30, 2022; final after his appeal failed, July 2023.
Years active
January 31, 2022
Location
Ulmet and Kusel (Rhineland-Palatinate); Sulzbach and Spiesen (Saarland); Kaiserslautern; Neunkirchen; Saarbrücken; Karlsruhe
Method
Murder in two cases, found by the court to have been committed to conceal commercial poaching
Status
Life imprisonment with a finding of particular severity of guilt (release after 15 years ruled out); appeal rejected by the Federal Court of Justice, July 18, 2023; final

In the early hours of January 31, 2022, two officers from the police station in Kusel, in the western Palatinate, were killed while on duty near the village of Ulmet. The man the court held responsible was Andreas S., a 38-year-old master baker from Spiesen in the neighboring Saarland, who had spent that night taking game illegally with a younger companion. On November 30, 2022, the Landgericht Kaiserslautern convicted him of murder in two cases, sentenced him to life imprisonment and found that his guilt was of particular severity, a finding that rules out release after the minimum fifteen years. The Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal in July 2023, and the judgment is final.

Yasmin B. was a police trainee nearing the end of her training. Alexander K., a police commissioner, came from Freisen in the Saarland district of St. Wendel. Both served with the police station in Kusel, and that night they were on patrol.

The two officers had come upon evidence of illegal hunting near Ulmet, and they died there that night. The court later established that the man who killed them acted alone and acted to keep the poaching from coming to light; the prosecution's case was that he had made his living largely from game taken illegally and sold.

Within hours, two men were arrested in Sulzbach, in the Saarland: Andreas S. and a 32-year-old companion who had been with him that night. On February 1 an investigating judge ordered both men held in pretrial custody on suspicion of jointly committed murder and poaching. At that stage the prosecutors believed that both had taken part, and that the deaths had served to hide the poaching that came before them. Andreas S. gave no statement. His companion admitted that the two had been poaching that night but denied any part in the deaths. Neither man had a criminal record in force. Within days a judge refused the younger man's first application for release.

For the first weeks the Kaiserslautern public prosecutor's office treated the case as a joint killing by two men. That changed at the end of February. On March 1, 2022, the prosecutors announced that the evidence now pointed to the 38-year-old alone. The younger man admitted that he had been poaching with Andreas S. that night but denied any part in the deaths, and the evidence did not tie him to them. The murder suspicion against him was dropped, and a new warrant was issued against him for poaching and for obstructing justice, on the allegation that he had helped cover up the offense afterward.

On March 9 the Landgericht Kaiserslautern lifted that warrant as well, and he was released. From then on Andreas S. was the only suspect in the killings. He remained in custody and, at that stage, said nothing.

Investigators also looked back over his past. In October 2004, while he still held a hunting license and leased a hunting ground, he had seriously injured another hunter in a hunting accident near Bexbach in the Saarland; a court in Saarbrücken fined him 4,500 euros in 2006 for negligent bodily injury. By 2022 that conviction had been removed from his record.

On May 10, 2022, the Kaiserslautern prosecutors announced the indictment. Andreas S. was charged with murder in two cases, attempted murder, dangerous bodily injury, assault on law enforcement officers and joint commercial poaching. The murder charges rested on two of the aggravating features of German murder law: that he had killed to conceal another offense, and that he had acted out of greed. Preliminary psychiatric reports found no reduction in criminal responsibility for either man.

The younger man was charged separately in the same proceedings with joint commercial poaching and attempted obstruction of justice. He was by then no longer accused of any part in the deaths.

The trial opened before the Fourth Criminal Chamber of the Landgericht Kaiserslautern on Tuesday, June 21, 2022, and ran for roughly five months. Andreas S. denied murder and claimed self-defense, and he blamed his companion for one of the two deaths. The companion had given police a full account before the trial and stayed silent in court.

In its closing argument the prosecution asked for life imprisonment for murder and a finding of particular severity of guilt. For the younger man it asked the court to find him guilty of poaching but to impose no penalty, because his statements had been essential to clearing up the case. The defense for Andreas S. argued that he had committed no murder.

On Wednesday, November 30, 2022, about ten months after the killings, the chamber convicted Andreas S. of murder in two cases and sentenced him to life imprisonment. It rejected his claim of self-defense. Because several aggravating features of murder were present, it found his guilt to be of particular severity. The court found that he had killed the officers to conceal commercial poaching.

The younger man was found guilty as a co-perpetrator of commercial poaching. The court did not treat him as having taken part in the killings, and it refrained from imposing any penalty, because he had given investigators a full account before the trial began.

Andreas S. lodged an appeal on points of law. On July 18, 2023, the Fourth Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe rejected it (4 StR 117/23), as the court announced on Friday, July 21. With that decision the life sentence and the finding of particular severity of guilt became final.

In a separate Saarland case over a 2017 incident, the local court in Neunkirchen acquitted him on March 2, 2023, of poaching and attempted dangerous bodily injury, and the prosecution appealed.

Andreas S. has been serving life imprisonment since the judgment became final in July 2023.

Andreas S. denied murder throughout and claimed self-defense. The court rejected that account and found that he alone had killed both officers, and the Federal Court of Justice let the judgment stand.

Timeline

October 2004: injures another hunter in a hunting accident near Bexbach, Saarland; fined in 2006 for negligent bodily injury.

January 31, 2022: two officers of the Kusel police station are killed near Ulmet; Andreas S. and a companion are arrested within hours in Sulzbach, Saarland.

February 1, 2022: an investigating judge orders both men held in pretrial custody on suspicion of murder and poaching.

March 1, 2022: prosecutors announce that the evidence points to Andreas S. alone; the murder suspicion against the companion is dropped.

March 9, 2022: the Landgericht Kaiserslautern lifts the companion's remaining warrant, and he is released.

May 10, 2022: indictment announced: murder in two cases, attempted murder, dangerous bodily injury, assault on law enforcement officers and joint commercial poaching.

June 21, 2022: trial opens before the Fourth Criminal Chamber of the Landgericht Kaiserslautern.

November 30, 2022: life imprisonment for murder in two cases, with a finding of particular severity of guilt; the companion is convicted of commercial poaching with no penalty imposed.

March 2, 2023: acquitted by the local court in Neunkirchen of poaching and attempted dangerous bodily injury in the 2017 matter; the prosecution appeals.

July 18, 2023: the Federal Court of Justice rejects his appeal (4 StR 117/23); the judgment becomes final.