Anderson Lee Aldrich

Victims
5 people murdered in Colorado Springs, November 2022. Pleaded guilty to five first-degree murders and 46 attempted murders, 2023, and to 74 federal counts, 50 of them hate crimes, 2024.
Years active
November 19-20, 2022
Location
Colorado Springs, Colorado
Method
First-degree murder; attempted first-degree murder; bias-motivated crime (no contest); federal hate crimes and offenses under the federal arms law
Status
State: five consecutive life terms without parole plus 2,208 years. Federal: 55 concurrent life terms, then 190 years. A 2026 motion to set aside the federal sentence was denied

On the night of November 19, 2022, Anderson Lee Aldrich killed five people in Colorado Springs: Daniel Aston, Kelly Loving, Ashley Paugh, Derrick Rump and Raymond Green Vance. Nineteen others were injured, and the federal plea that closed the case would name 26 more people Aldrich had tried to kill. Aldrich was 22. Aldrich was taken into custody that night by the Colorado Springs Police Department.

Two prosecutions followed, one by the State of Colorado and one by the United States. Neither reached a trial. Both ended in pleas, and both ended in life sentences.

The Colorado Springs Police Department led the investigation, with the FBI assisting from the start, and Aldrich was held without bond. In December 2022 the El Paso County district attorney's office filed 305 counts, among them murder, attempted murder and bias-motivated crime; amendments brought the total to 323. After a two-day preliminary hearing in February 2023, the judge in the 4th Judicial District Court found probable cause on every count and bound all 323 over for trial.

The trial never came. On June 26, 2023, under an agreement with the district attorney's office, Aldrich pleaded guilty to five counts of first-degree murder and 46 counts of attempted first-degree murder, admitting to intentionally and deliberately causing the death of each of the five victims. To two counts of bias-motivated crime, one a felony and one a misdemeanor, Aldrich pleaded no contest, telling the court the plea rested on the high probability of being found guilty at trial. Sentence came the same day: five consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole for the murders, 48 years on each of the 46 attempted-murder counts, all consecutive, for a total of 2,208 years, and three years and 164 days on the bias-motivated crime count.

The state case was over, but the federal case had not yet been filed. On January 9, 2024, federal prosecutors gave notice that the United States would not seek the death penalty. Joint filings by the Justice Department and the defense set out the bargain that would end the case: Aldrich would plead guilty to every count, and both sides agreed that multiple concurrent life sentences, followed by 190 more years, was the appropriate sentence. A week later the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Colorado and the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division filed a criminal information in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado charging 74 counts: 50 under the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act and 24 under the federal arms law. The first pleas entered in federal court were not guilty; under the agreement, they were to be changed.

On June 18, 2024, Aldrich did. In pleading guilty to all 74 counts, Aldrich admitted a willful, deliberate, malicious and premeditated attack, and admitted that it had been motivated in part by the actual or perceived sexual orientation and gender identity of the people targeted. The court accepted the agreement, which fixed the sentence and left no room for another, and imposed its terms: life imprisonment without the possibility of parole on each of counts 1 through 55, to run concurrently, followed by prison terms totaling 190 years on counts 56 through 74. The federal pleas carried what the state pleas had not. In state court the bias counts had been answered with no contest; in federal court Aldrich admitted the motive.

The federal plea agreement had generally barred an appeal. It left one route open, a claim that defense counsel had fallen short of the constitutional standard, and in May 2026 Aldrich took it, asking the federal court to set the sentence aside so the case could go to trial. The federal court denied the motion in an order dated July 17, 2026, and rejected every ground in it.

The motion came too late. The deadline had run in September 2025, the court held, and Aldrich had filed about eight months after it without giving any specific reason to excuse the delay. The claims failed on their merits as well. Aldrich argued that the plea had been entered while Aldrich's capacity was impaired; the court found nothing in the record to support the claim. Aldrich argued that a public defender on the case had been conflicted by leaving the defense to become a state judge; the court found no authority for the idea that a lawyer's change of career creates a conflict of interest. Aldrich had acknowledged, in the plea agreement and again in open court, having been represented effectively and competently. And to win, Aldrich had to show that counsel's advice had done harm. Given the evidence in the case, the court held, turning down the plea would not have been a reasonable choice.

In a further order dated July 20, 2026, the court held that a reply filed after its ruling changed nothing. As of July 2026, Aldrich was serving both sentences: five consecutive life terms without parole and 2,208 years from Colorado, and 55 concurrent life terms and 190 years from the federal court.

Motive was contested until the federal plea. The defense disputed the bias charges before trial, and in the state case Aldrich never admitted them, pleading no contest instead. The federal plea of June 2024 settled the point in law.

The 2026 claims that the federal plea had been entered with impaired capacity and conflicted counsel were rejected by the federal court as untimely and unsupported.

Timeline

November 19, 2022: Five people are killed and 19 injured in Colorado Springs; patrons hold Aldrich until officers arrive.

November 20, 2022: The Colorado Springs Police Department names Aldrich, 22, as the person in custody.

December 6, 2022: The El Paso County district attorney files 305 state counts, later amended to 323.

February 2023: After a two-day preliminary hearing, all 323 counts are bound over for trial.

June 26, 2023: Guilty pleas to five counts of first-degree murder and 46 of attempted first-degree murder; no contest to two counts of bias-motivated crime; five consecutive life terms without parole plus 2,208 years.

January 9, 2024: Federal prosecutors give notice that they will not seek the death penalty; joint filings set out a plea to every count with concurrent life terms and 190 years.

January 16, 2024: A 74-count federal information is filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado: 50 hate-crime counts and 24 under the federal arms law.

June 18, 2024: Guilty pleas to all 74 federal counts; life without parole on counts 1 through 55, concurrent, and 190 years on counts 56 through 74.

July 17, 2026: The federal court denies the motion to set aside the federal sentence as untimely and without merit.

July 20, 2026: A second order finds that a late reply does not change the decision.