On July 31, 2015, three members of the Dawabsheh family, a Palestinian family in the village of Duma in the northern West Bank, were killed in one night's attack. The couple's infant son died that night. Saad Dawabsheh died in August. Riham Dawabsheh died on September 7, 2015. Their older son survived, the only member of the household left alive.
Five years later, on May 18, 2020, the Lod District Court convicted Amiram Ben-Uliel, a Jewish settler from Jerusalem, of three counts of murder, two counts of attempted murder, two counts of arson and conspiracy to commit a crime with a racist motive. The court found the crimes racially motivated and acquitted him of membership in a terrorist organization. On September 14, 2020, it sentenced him to three consecutive life terms and a further 20 years. Israel's Supreme Court rejected his appeal unanimously on September 1, 2022, and the Supreme Court's president refused his request for a further hearing on February 7, 2023.
The case rested on his own words. Ben-Uliel said nothing to interrogators for 17 days after his arrest. He began to confess only after the Shin Bet, Israel's internal security service, was permitted to use what Israeli law calls special measures in a "necessity" interrogation. The trial court threw out the confessions given under those measures and kept the ones that followed, together with a reenactment he gave investigators. He has denied the murders throughout and says the confession was taken from him by torture. Every court that has examined the record has upheld the conviction.
Duma is a Palestinian village near Nablus, in the northern West Bank. The Dawabsheh household there in the summer of 2015 was a young couple and their two small sons. The attack came on the night of July 31.
The younger boy died that night. His father died eight days later, in August 2015. His mother lived for five weeks and died on September 7, 2015. Their older son survived and was later raised in Duma by his extended family. The court would later order Ben-Uliel to pay him compensation.
The government treated the attack as terrorism. In the weeks that followed, Israeli authorities began holding Jewish citizens suspected of political violence against Palestinians in administrative detention, without trial, and allowed harsher interrogation of suspected Jewish militants.
The inquiry was a joint effort of the Israel Police, the Shin Bet and the Central District office of the State Attorney. For months it produced no charge. Investigators first treated the case as one of the so-called "price tag" attacks, the label used for acts of vandalism and violence against Palestinians by Jewish extremists. They then turned their attention to a small, radical circle of young settlers. Dozens of adults and minors were arrested on suspicion of involvement in Duma and other nationalist crimes.
Ben-Uliel was detained in early December 2015. He was then 21, a settler activist from Jerusalem. Under the criminal procedure rules for security offenses, he was barred from seeing a lawyer for the first 21 days after his arrest.
For 17 days he did not answer questions. The Shin Bet then sought and received approval from the attorney general of the time to use special measures, on the ground that it was dealing with a network that posed a continuing danger. During that interrogation Ben-Uliel confessed. Four days later, in a regular interrogation, he confessed again and walked investigators through the attack, giving details that, the courts later found, only the person who carried it out could have known.
On January 3, 2016, the State Attorney's office filed indictments in the Lod District Court. Ben-Uliel was charged with three counts of murder, two counts of attempted murder, two counts of arson and one count of conspiracy to commit a crime with a racist or nationalist motive. He was also charged with membership in a terrorist organization.
The second defendant in the Duma case was a 17-year-old, charged with conspiracy to commit a crime from a racist motive and with other offenses.
According to the indictment, Ben-Uliel and the teenager agreed in July 2015 to carry out a revenge attack against Arabs after the killing of an Israeli in the West Bank the previous month. On the night itself, it said, the teenager did not join him, and Ben-Uliel went on alone.
The trial turned on one question for more than two years: which of the confessions, if any, the court could hear. Both defendants asked the Lod District Court to throw out everything they had said during the first weeks of custody.
The court gave its answer on June 19, 2018, in a long decision. It found that the special measures had seriously violated the defendants' bodily and mental integrity and their dignity. The court held that confessions given during the necessity interrogation could not be used, and it did not require the defense to prove that the measures had overcome Ben-Uliel's free will. It did not decide whether the Shin Bet had met the legal conditions for necessity. It accepted that the main purpose of the special interrogation had been preventive, that the Shin Bet's assumption that it faced a dangerous network was reasonable and based on evidence, and it said the ruling applied to this case alone.
The court then drew a line through what came after. It weighed the changes of interrogators, the gap in time and the different purpose of the later questioning. It admitted the confessions Ben-Uliel gave in regular interrogations about 36 hours after the special measures ended, which had been recorded on video and showed him composed and in control of himself. It excluded later statements that were not recorded. It also admitted the reenactment. For the teenager the result was harsher on the prosecution: nearly all of his confessions were thrown out, leaving only what he had said to undercover police officers posing as fellow inmates and a general account given without names.
With the recorded confessions and the reenactment admitted, the trial of Ben-Uliel went on.
In May 2019 the teenager reached a plea agreement with the State Prosecutor's Office. He admitted conspiracy to commit a crime with a racist motive, the count with which he had been charged in 2016, but the indictment was amended so that the crime he had conspired to commit was a lesser offense rather than murder. The amended indictment did not mention the three victims. He admitted planning the attack with Ben-Uliel and taking part in three other attacks on Palestinian property. Prosecutors said he had not been present in Duma on the night of the killings.
The sides left one question to the court: whether he was a member of a terrorist organization. On October 24, 2019, the Lod District Court ruled that he was a member, and the Supreme Court later upheld the charges against him. On September 16, 2020, he was sentenced to three and a half years in prison. He had already spent two years and eight months in custody.
No plea agreement was offered to Ben-Uliel. At a hearing in June 2019 he declined to testify in his own defense, saying he would not take part in what he called the injustice of the proceedings.
On May 18, 2020, the Lod District Court convicted Ben-Uliel of three counts of murder, two counts of attempted murder, two counts of arson and conspiracy to commit a crime with a racist motive. It found that the crimes were racially motivated and that he had acted from a radical ideology. It acquitted him of membership in a terrorist organization.
The judgment relied on the confessions the court had admitted in 2018 and on the reenactment. Ben-Uliel had confessed three times in all; two of those confessions had been excluded. The court found that what remained contained details of the scene that only the perpetrator could have known, and knowledge that investigators did not themselves have at the time he gave it.
On September 14, 2020, the Lod District Court sentenced Ben-Uliel to three consecutive life terms for the murders and a further 20 years for the attempted murders. It also ordered him to pay compensation to the surviving son. The court found the crimes planned in advance and rooted in his radical ideology and in racism.
Ben-Uliel took new lawyers for the appeal. They argued that earlier counsel had concentrated on whether the confession was true, when the stronger ground was that it was inadmissible because it had come out of torture. They argued that for the first 17 days the Shin Bet had asked only about the past attack in Duma rather than about any threat to come, so that the claimed necessity had never existed, and that Israeli law allowed no exception for interrogations of that kind.
On September 1, 2022, a three-justice panel rejected the appeal unanimously and left the conviction and sentence in place. The justices reviewed the video recordings of the interrogations. They found that the confessions the trial court had admitted were authentic and that there was no doubt he had carried out the attack. They relied on the confession, the reenactment and the racial character of the murders. One justice added a separate opinion on the interrogation methods of the security services.
Ben-Uliel's lawyers then asked for a further hearing, the rare procedure by which a wider panel of the Supreme Court can revisit one of its own judgments. They argued again that the confession had been obtained through what amounted to torture, that no necessity had been shown, and that he had been cut off from the outside world and from a lawyer without real justification. On February 7, 2023, the president of the Supreme Court refused the request. She accepted that the measures used had been extremely irregular, but held that the 2022 judgment had not created any new law on the admissibility of confessions, which is the test for granting a further hearing.
Ben-Uliel has been held since December 2015 and is classed by the Israel Prison Service as a security prisoner. A public campaign outside the prison has argued that he was tortured and wrongly convicted and has pressed for his release and for easier conditions.
In December 2025 the Prison Service refused his request for conjugal visits. It cited security assessments that recorded four instances of what it called negative involvement in 2023 and 2024, and concern over the campaign being run on his behalf outside the prison. In January 2026 prosecutors withdrew their objection, stating that a recent meeting with Shin Bet officials had produced statements by him that reduced the risk they had cited.
As of January 13, 2026, he was serving his sentence in Israel, about ten years after his arrest.
Ben-Uliel denies the murders. His position, put by his lawyers at trial and on appeal, is that he confessed only because he was tortured. The courts accepted that he was subjected to special measures and threw out what he said under them; they rejected his claim that the later recorded confessions and the reenactment were tainted by the same treatment.
Whether he acted alone on the night is settled only as far as the courts went. The prosecution's case, and the minor's admitted plea, was that the two planned the attack together and that the teenager did not come to the meeting point. The court convicted the teenager of conspiracy to commit a crime with a racist motive and of membership in a terrorist organization, not of murder.
The trial court acquitted Ben-Uliel of membership in a terrorist organization, although the minor was convicted of that charge. The acquittal stands. His convictions for murder and attempted murder were found to be racially motivated.
July 31, 2015: Three members of one family are killed in Duma, West Bank; the father dies in August and the mother on September 7, 2015.
Early December 2015: Ben-Uliel is detained; he is barred from seeing a lawyer for 21 days and stays silent for 17.
January 3, 2016: Indictments filed in the Lod District Court against Ben-Uliel and a 17-year-old co-defendant.
June 19, 2018: The court excludes the confessions given under special measures and admits later recorded confessions and the reenactment.
May 2019: The co-defendant reaches a plea agreement on amended charges.
June 2019: Ben-Uliel declines to testify.
October 24, 2019: The co-defendant is ruled a member of a terrorist organization.
May 18, 2020: Ben-Uliel is convicted of three counts of murder and related offenses and acquitted of terror-group membership.
September 14, 2020: Sentenced to three consecutive life terms plus 20 years.
September 16, 2020: The co-defendant is sentenced to three and a half years.
September 1, 2022: The Supreme Court rejects the appeal unanimously.
February 7, 2023: The president of the Supreme Court refuses a further hearing.
December 2025: The Prison Service refuses conjugal visits.
January 13, 2026: Prosecutors drop their objection to the visits; he remains imprisoned in Israel.