In April 1994 Aloys Simba was a retired lieutenant colonel of the Rwandan army and a former member of parliament for Gikongoro, his home prefecture, and he held no office in the government, the army or any party. The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda found that on April 21, 1994, he took part in a joint criminal enterprise to kill Tutsi civilians who had sought refuge at Murambi Technical School and Kaduha Parish. Thousands of Tutsi were killed at the school that day, and large numbers at the parish.
On December 13, 2005, Trial Chamber I of the tribunal, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, found him guilty of genocide and of crimes against humanity (extermination) and sentenced him to twenty-five years' imprisonment. The Appeals Chamber affirmed the convictions and the sentence on November 27, 2007. He served his sentence in Benin, was granted early release with conditions in 2019 and died in Porto-Novo on July 4, 2023. He maintained to the end that he was innocent.
Simba was born on February 28, 1938, in Musebeya commune, Gikongoro Prefecture. He joined the army in 1961, and in July 1973 he was among the officers, known as the Comrades of the Fifth of July, who brought Juvénal Habyarimana to power. He sat in parliament for Gikongoro from 1989 to 1993 and gave up his post as chairman of the ruling MRND party in the prefecture in September 1993. Retired and out of office, he remained, the trial chamber found, a respected national figure, well known in his native region.
President Habyarimana was assassinated on April 6, 1994, and within days the killing of Tutsi began in Gikongoro, where thousands fled to parishes and a school that had offered safety before.
The chamber found that the attacks of April 21 at Murambi Technical School, Cyanika Parish and Kaduha Parish formed a highly coordinated operation by militiamen backed by gendarmes, with support from local authorities and prominent figures such as Simba. It found that he was present at Murambi and at Kaduha that day, and that his acts of assistance and encouragement at both places had a substantial effect on the killings that followed.
Simba had left Rwanda by the middle of August 1994. On November 27, 2001, he was arrested in Senegal at the tribunal's request, and on March 11, 2002, he arrived at the UN Detention Facility in Arusha. He pleaded not guilty to all four counts against him: genocide, complicity in genocide, and extermination and murder as crimes against humanity.
His trial opened on August 30, 2004. His defense was that he had been in Kigali and then in Gitarama, far from the massacres. The chamber accepted that he may have been in Kigali until April 13, but it found that the alibi failed for the days that followed and that it had no doubt he was at Murambi Technical School and at Kaduha Parish on April 21.
The chamber convicted him through the doctrine of joint criminal enterprise. It found that he acted with the intent to destroy the Tutsi group, and that the killings were part of a widespread attack on the Tutsi civilians of Gikongoro on ethnic grounds, of which he knew. The verdict was unanimous: guilty on Count 1, genocide, and on Count 3, crimes against humanity (extermination); not guilty on Counts 2 and 4, complicity in genocide and murder, which the prosecution had withdrawn. The chamber did not hold him responsible for the killings at Cyanika Parish, where no reliable evidence placed him. Because both convictions rested on the same acts, it imposed a single sentence of twenty-five years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since his arrest.
Both sides appealed. On November 27, 2007, the Appeals Chamber dismissed every ground Simba raised, along with the prosecution's appeal against the Cyanika acquittal and against the sentence, and held that convictions for genocide and for extermination on the same facts are permissible. The twenty-five years stood.
The judgment answered his arguments one by one. Simba had argued that the indictment never said which form of joint criminal enterprise the prosecution relied on. The Appeals Chamber agreed that it had not named the category, but held that it pleaded the shared intent the basic form requires, which gave him sufficient notice, and it confirmed that both convictions rested on that basic form alone. It rejected his claim that the convictions could not stand once the trial chamber had found no proof that he planned the massacres. A participant need not have planned the enterprise, the chamber held; it is enough that he took part in a common design to commit a crime under the Statute. The trial chamber's observation that local authorities might have drawn up the plan and then asked for his help had only shown that more than one inference was open, and it had not been held against him.
On genocide, the Appeals Chamber held that neither a plan nor a policy is an element of the crime. The question, it said, is not whether genocidal intent was formed before the killing began but whether the perpetrators held it at the moment they acted, and the trial chamber had asked exactly that question. It had inferred Simba's intent from facts it found proved, facts he had not challenged on appeal. Nor had it made motive part of the offense: it had found, in line with settled law, that a possible personal motive for joining the enterprise did not rule out the intent to destroy the group.
On the double conviction, the chamber held that each crime carries an element the other lacks. Genocide requires the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group; extermination as a crime against humanity requires that the killing form part of a widespread or systematic attack on a civilian population. Convicting him of both on the same facts was therefore permissible as a matter of law.
The prosecution's appeal over Cyanika Parish failed on its own terms. The Appeals Chamber agreed that a participant in a joint criminal enterprise need not be physically present when the crime is committed, and that his contribution need not be necessary or substantial, though it must be significant. But it found that the trial chamber had imposed neither requirement. Although that chamber had found a common purpose spanning all three sites, its findings on Simba's own responsibility amounted in effect to a separate enterprise limited to Murambi and Kaduha. It had treated the absence of any evidence placing him at Cyanika only as part of its finding that nothing showed he shared the intent to kill the Tutsi there, and it had found no direct evidence linking him to the parish or showing that he knew and accepted it would form part of the operation. The prosecution had not properly challenged those findings on intent, and the acquittal stood.
On June 27, 2009, Simba was among nine convicts transferred from Arusha to Benin to serve their sentences. Enforcement later passed to the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, whose President granted him early release with conditions in January 2019, after he had served two-thirds of his sentence, finding some signs of rehabilitation. The Government of Rwanda opposed the release. Simba remained in Benin and died in Porto-Novo on July 4, 2023.
Simba never accepted the verdict. At trial he said he had been in Kigali and Gitarama while the massacres took place; on appeal he maintained his innocence and challenged the reliability of witnesses who were themselves accused or convicted in Rwanda. He argued too that he could not physically have reached both Murambi and Kaduha in the time the trial chamber allowed. Both chambers rejected those arguments.
Much of the prosecution case was not proven. The chamber did not hold him responsible for the killings at Kibeho Parish, at Cyanika Parish or in Ruhashya commune, and it found unproven a series of other allegations of incitement and support in Gikongoro in March and April 1994.
The chamber found that thousands of Tutsi were killed at Murambi Technical School and large numbers at Kaduha Parish, and it made no more precise finding on either site.
The date of the early release is recorded two ways: the President's decision is dated January 7, 2019, while the tribunal's case record lists the release as granted on January 29, 2019.
February 28, 1938: Aloys Simba is born in Musebeya commune, Gikongoro Prefecture, Rwanda.
July 1973: He is among the Comrades of the Fifth of July, the officers who bring Juvénal Habyarimana to power.
1989 to 1993: Member of parliament for Gikongoro.
April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana is assassinated.
April 21, 1994: Thousands of Tutsi are killed at Murambi Technical School and large numbers at Kaduha Parish; the tribunal later finds Simba took part in a joint criminal enterprise at both places.
November 27, 2001: Arrested in Senegal at the request of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.
March 11, 2002: Arrives at the UN Detention Facility in Arusha.
August 30, 2004: Trial opens before Trial Chamber I.
December 13, 2005: Found guilty of genocide and of crimes against humanity (extermination); sentenced to twenty-five years' imprisonment.
November 27, 2007: The Appeals Chamber affirms the convictions and the sentence.
June 27, 2009: Transferred to Benin to serve his sentence.
January 2019: Granted early release with conditions.
July 4, 2023: Simba dies in Porto-Novo, Benin.