Ali Harbi Ali

Victims
1 MP murdered in Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, 2021; convicted April 11, 2022, by a unanimous jury of the murder of Sir David Amess MP and of engaging in the preparation of terrorist acts
Years active
Preparation count: May 1, 2019, to September 28, 2021. Murder: October 15, 2021
Location
Leigh-on-Sea, Essex; London (Kentish Town; Croydon)
Method
Murder of a sitting Member of Parliament, found by the court to have been committed for the purposes of terrorism
Status
Count 2 (murder): life imprisonment with a whole life order. Count 1: life, minimum term 30 years, concurrent. Sentenced April 13, 2022

On October 15, 2021, Sir David Amess, the Conservative Member of Parliament for Southend West, was murdered in Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, while he was meeting the people he represented. The man arrested that day, Ali Harbi Ali, was a Londoner of Somali heritage who had spent years aligning himself with Islamic State, the organization the United Kingdom proscribes as a terrorist group. Six months later a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London took 18 minutes to convict him of murder and of engaging in the preparation of terrorist acts over a period of more than two years. The trial judge imposed life imprisonment with a whole life order, under which he can never be considered for release on parole.

The court's findings put the killing in plain terms. It was a murder carried out in revenge for the losses Islamic State had suffered in Syria, and it was done with the intention of influencing the government and advancing a religious or ideological cause. The MP had done nothing to provoke it. He had voted, with hundreds of other members, on two motions authorizing British forces to take part in coalition operations against Islamic State, and for that reason a man he had never met chose him as a target.

The MP had sat in the House of Commons since 1983, first for Basildon, a marginal seat he held through close contests in 1987 and 1992, and later for Southend West, the Essex constituency that takes in Leigh-on-Sea. At his death he had given almost four decades to Parliament; the sentencing court counted 38 years devoted to the lawful service of the public. Queen Elizabeth II knighted him in 2015.

He was a backbencher by temperament and by choice. He was a Catholic and a social conservative who opposed abortion, and in 2006 he founded the All-Party Parliamentary Group for relations with the Holy See; in September 2010 he helped arrange the visit of Pope Benedict XVI to Parliament. He campaigned on animal welfare, for children with disabilities and for women with endometriosis, and he supported Britain's departure from the European Union. He chaired the All-Party Parliamentary British-Qatar Group and sat on the group for Tamils. He also campaigned for Southend to be made a city.

Holding regular meetings with constituents was part of the ordinary work of his office, and he was doing that work on the day he died. The sentencing judge later listed the fact that he was providing a public service, or performing a public duty, among the features that made the murder more serious, and described his loss as one of national significance.

Ali Harbi Ali was 25 at the time of the murder. He grew up in Croydon, in south London, and was a strong student until his final years at school, when his attendance became sporadic and his engagement declined. He later went to university to train for a medical career, then dropped out and gave up the ambition. By the time of his arrest he was living in Kentish Town, in north London. He had no previous convictions or cautions.

The court found that between about 2014 and 2016, when he was aged 18 to 20, he was radicalized over the internet. By his own admission he came to sympathize with, believe in and align himself with Islamic State. In October 2014 his school in Croydon referred him to Prevent, the government program intended to steer people away from extremism; he was taken onto its Channel scheme that November, met an intervention provider once, in January 2015, and was exited from the scheme in 2015, with the case closed after a review in December 2016 that found nothing of counter-terrorism concern.

On Friday, October 15, 2021, Ali went to Leigh-on-Sea, where the MP was meeting constituents, and murdered him there. A member of the MP's staff raised the alarm, and two constituents who arrived for a later appointment tried to help. The MP died the same day.

Two Essex Police officers arrested Ali in Leigh-on-Sea. Essex Police and paramedics answered the call; the investigation that followed was led by the Metropolitan Police's Counter Terrorism Command. He was held on suspicion of murder under the Terrorism Act, and police said that day that the motive might be linked to Islamist extremism. The court later found that he had sent a written statement of his reasons shortly before the murder, and that on reaching the police station he said the crime was terror-based.

In interview he admitted that he had acted in revenge and that he wanted to influence politicians. No mental health issue was raised at trial.

Counter terrorism detectives led the investigation.

Meanwhile an inquest into the MP's death was opened at County Hall in Chelmsford on October 27, 2021, and the senior coroner for Essex suspended it until the criminal proceedings were over.

The trial opened on Monday, March 21, 2022, before a High Court judge sitting at the Central Criminal Court, and was expected to last three weeks. The prosecution's case was that the murder was carried out for terrorist purposes, and it set out the evidence of more than two years of research and planning against Members of Parliament.

Over the following weeks the jury heard the prosecution's evidence. Much of that evidence was never in dispute. He accepted much of the evidence against him, and the jury was told he had no mental health issues. His defense rested on his belief about the purpose of what he had done, not on any claim that someone else had done it. The judge directed the jury that the killing could not amount in law to self-defense, defense of another or the prevention of crime, and that no other legal defense arose on the evidence.

He gave evidence himself on Thursday, April 7, 2022.

On Monday, April 11, 2022, the jury returned unanimous verdicts of guilty on both counts after 18 minutes of deliberation. The judge adjourned sentence to the Wednesday of the same week.

On April 13, 2022, the trial judge passed sentence. He set out the facts of which he was sure, beginning with the votes of 2014 and 2015 and ending with the arrest and interview. He found that the murder, like the conduct in the terrorism count, was done to influence the government and to advance the cause of Islamic State.

On the murder count the sentence was fixed by law at life imprisonment, and the only question was whether to set a minimum term or to make a whole life order. He held that the starting point was a whole life order. He identified the aggravating features: the terrorist connection, which he declared in open court but did not count twice; a significant degree of planning and premeditation; the means carried to the scene; the fact that the victim was performing a public duty; the fact that the murder was an act of revenge on an elected representative for the way he had voted in Parliament; and the fact that Ali prevented members of the public from trying to help him. Against these stood one mitigating feature, the absence of previous convictions or cautions, which he gave very little weight given the long course of preparation.

He held that this was an exceptional case in which just punishment required a whole life order, whether the murder was viewed alone or together with the terrorism count. On the preparation count, where the aggravating features were the choice of Members of Parliament as targets and repeated possession of terrorist material, he passed life with a minimum term of 30 years, concurrent. He also made a forfeiture order, a statutory surcharge order, and a direction that Ali would be subject to the terrorism notification requirements for 30 years.

Ali was in the dock as the sentence was passed. Under the whole life order he cannot be considered for parole and is likely to spend the rest of his life in custody.

The inquest suspended in October 2021 was never resumed. In 2024 the senior coroner for Essex decided, in an 18-page written decision, not to resume it, finding no arguable breach by the authorities of any duty that would require a full inquest, and no evidence that they arguably should have recognized a real and immediate risk of an attack on the MP, or on any member, and acted to prevent it.

Count 1 was brought under the Terrorism Act 2006, the offense of engaging in the preparation of terrorist acts, which carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The court sentenced it under the definitive guideline for that offense, agreeing with the prosecution that the case fell in Category 2A, which carries a starting point of life with a minimum term of 25 years. The aggravating features took the minimum term to 30 years.

The murder count was sentenced under the murder sentencing rules of the Sentencing Act 2020. Those rules make a whole life order the starting point where the court considers the seriousness of the offense, alone or combined with associated offenses, exceptionally high and the offender was over 21 when it was committed, and they make clear that a murder done for the purpose of advancing a religious or ideological cause will normally be of exceptionally high seriousness. Ali was 25 at the time of the murder. The same Act required the judge to treat the terrorist connection as an aggravating factor and to state in court that the offense was so aggravated; because that connection had already fixed the starting point, he took care not to count it twice.

Even where the starting point applies, the judge said, a whole life order remains a matter of judicial discretion, and each case must be considered on its own facts. The ancillary orders came from other statutes: the forfeiture order under the Terrorism Act 2000, and the 30-year notification requirements under the Counter-Terrorism Act 2008.

The facts of the murder and of the preparation were not in dispute at trial, and the jury's verdicts were unanimous. What remained contested was the defendant's own account of his purpose. No legal defense arose from it, and the sentencing court found the purpose to be revenge on behalf of Islamic State and the influencing of the government.

Timeline

2014 to 2016: The court finds he was radicalized over the internet during this period.

October 17, 2014: His school in Croydon refers him to Prevent.

November 13, 2014: He is formally adopted onto the Channel program.

2015: He is exited from Channel; the case is closed after a review in December 2016.

May 1, 2019: Start of the period covered by the preparation count.

September 28, 2021: End of the period covered by the preparation count.

October 15, 2021: The MP is murdered in Leigh-on-Sea; Ali is arrested there the same day.

October 21, 2021: He is charged with murder and preparing terrorist acts and appears at Westminster Magistrates' Court.

October 22, 2021: First appearance at the Central Criminal Court; provisional trial date set.

October 27, 2021: The inquest is opened in Chelmsford and suspended pending the criminal proceedings.

December 21, 2021: He pleads not guilty to both counts.

March 21, 2022: The trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.

April 7, 2022: He gives evidence in his own defense.

April 11, 2022: The jury convicts him on both counts.

April 13, 2022: Sentenced to life imprisonment with a whole life order for murder, and life with a minimum term of 30 years, concurrent, for preparing terrorist acts.

2024: The senior coroner for Essex decides not to resume the inquest.