Alfredo Astiz was a young officer of the Argentine Navy when, in the first years of the military dictatorship that ruled Argentina from 1976 to 1983, he served with the task group based at the Navy School of Mechanics in Buenos Aires, the ESMA. Courts on two continents have since held him to account for what that group did. On October 26, 2011, Federal Oral Court No. 5 in Buenos Aires sentenced him to life imprisonment for crimes against humanity committed at the ESMA. On November 29, 2017, the same court sentenced him to life a second time, at the close of the largest trial Argentina had ever held. By then a court in Paris and a court in Rome had each sentenced him to life in his absence.
The dead and the disappeared in those judgments include two French nuns, Alice Domon and Léonie Duquet; three of the women who founded the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, Azucena Villaflor de De Vincenti, Esther Ballestrino de Careaga and María Eugenia Ponce de Bianco; Rodolfo Walsh; and a Swedish-Argentine teenage girl. For more than twenty years he could not be tried in Argentina for any of it, and Argentina refused every request to send him abroad.
Astiz was born in November 1951 in Mar del Plata, the Atlantic resort city south of Buenos Aires. He made his career in the Navy, and in January 1977 he held the rank of teniente de corbeta, the most junior grade of commissioned naval officer. He was posted to the ESMA, a training school in the north of the capital that the dictatorship had turned into a clandestine detention center, and served in its Task Group 3.3.2.
On January 27, 1977, a Navy group seized the teenager in El Palomar, in the western suburbs of Buenos Aires, and took her to the ESMA. Her fate is unknown. Sweden took up her case at once, and it followed Astiz for the next forty years. On March 25, 1977, officers of the unit abducted Walsh in Buenos Aires, and the cassation court that later reviewed the 2011 verdict confirmed that officers of the unit had killed him.
The two nuns worked alongside a group of relatives of the disappeared who met in Buenos Aires to press for news of their children. Between December 8 and December 10, 1977, the task group seized members of that group, among them the three founders of the Mothers and the two nuns, and took them to the ESMA.
The first official inquiry into the teenager's case was the Navy's own. In 1980 a military investigative court ended its summary proceeding with the definitive dismissal of the case against Astiz and two other officers for lack of evidence. In 1985, after the return of democracy, he was tried and acquitted in the same case: the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces found the facts not proven, and the federal appeals chamber held that the time limit for prosecuting the offenses charged had run out. France, which had opened an investigation into the nuns' disappearance, first sought his extradition in 1985. A Buenos Aires trial over the nuns' case ended in 1987 with his release for lack of evidence. Then the Full Stop law of 1986 and the Due Obedience law of 1987 closed the Argentine courts to officers of his rank, and Astiz was among those the second law protected.
In 1982, during the war over the Falkland Islands, he surrendered the Argentine garrison on South Georgia to British forces, was held in Britain as a prisoner of war and was returned to Argentina in June.
France tried him anyway. On March 16, 1990, the cour d'assises of Paris convicted him in absentia over the abduction and death of the two nuns and sentenced him to réclusion criminelle à perpétuité, life imprisonment. In February 1991 France issued an international arrest warrant. Argentina refused to execute it, and while the amnesty laws stood and he stayed in Argentina, the verdict could not reach him.
In January 1998 a published interview in which Astiz spoke about his years in the Navy brought him an order of 60 days' detention, and the Navy discharged him that year. Prosecutors charged him over the interview itself. On March 8, 2000, a federal judge convicted him of apología del crimen, the public defense of crime, and sentenced him to three months in prison, suspended.
In July 2001 Italy asked for his arrest over the disappearance of Italian citizens, and he spent about six weeks in detention before Argentina refused to extradite him. France asked for enforcement of the 1990 judgment and was refused on two grounds: the principle that no one may be tried twice for the same acts, since the amnesty laws had covered them, and Argentina's policy of not extraditing its own nationals. On December 27, 2001, he was arrested in Mar del Plata at Sweden's request. The government refused that request too, on the ground that he had already been tried for the case, and at the end of January 2002 a federal judge ordered his release.
Italy tried him in his absence. The case concerned three people of Italian origin who disappeared under the dictatorship: Angela María Aieta, abducted on August 5, 1976, and Juan and Susana Pegoraro, who disappeared on June 18, 1977. In March 2007 a Rome court of assize convicted Astiz and other former ESMA officers of illegal detention, torture and forced disappearance and sentenced him to life. On April 24, 2008, the court of assize of appeal upheld the verdict and the sentence, and on February 26, 2009, Italy's Supreme Court of Cassation confirmed it.
By then the ground in Argentina had moved. In 2003 the Full Stop and Due Obedience laws were annulled, and the Supreme Court later voided them; the ESMA cases reopened. In May 2006 a federal judge indicted Astiz over the abductions of December 1977 and ordered him held in preventive detention. On August 18, 2006, the Federal Chamber of Criminal Cassation authorized the reopening of the teenager's case, which was later joined to the larger ESMA proceedings. He has been in custody ever since.
The second ESMA trial, case 1270, opened in late 2009 before Federal Oral Court No. 5. It covered 86 cases that had been frozen by the amnesty laws, among them the March 1977 abduction, the two nuns and the three founders of the Mothers. On October 4, 2011, while the trial was still running, Argentina's Supreme Court declared the French extradition request inadmissible, because Astiz was already on trial in Argentina for crimes against the same victims. On October 26, 2011, the court convicted him of crimes against humanity, among them kidnapping, torture, murder and forced disappearance, and sentenced him to prisión perpetua, life imprisonment, with absolute and perpetual disqualification. Eleven other defendants received life, four received terms of 18 to 25 years, and two were acquitted.
On April 23, 2014, Chamber II of the Federal Chamber of Criminal Cassation upheld his conviction, the life sentence and the disqualification. It rejected the defense claims of nullity, of limitation and of unconstitutionality, and confirmed that the acts were crimes against humanity. The Supreme Court later rejected the defense's extraordinary appeals, and the conviction became final. In August 2017 the same chamber refused to apply to him the reduced count of pretrial detention under Law 24,390, the so-called two-for-one rule.
The third ESMA trial, the unified case, opened on November 28, 2012, and covered crimes committed at the school from 1976 to the end of the dictatorship: 54 defendants, tried for crimes against 789 victims. The charges against Astiz included the January 1977 abduction in El Palomar. On November 29, 2017, the court sentenced 29 defendants to life imprisonment and 19 to terms of 8 to 25 years, and it acquitted six. Astiz received life for crimes against humanity that included kidnapping, torture and homicide, among them the enforced disappearance of the Swedish-Argentine teenager.
In March 2026 he was still held in a federal prison in Buenos Aires Province, serving his two Argentine life sentences.
The 1980 Navy inquiry and the 1985 trial cleared Astiz in the teenager's case, and he long denied the charges against him. Those outcomes gave way when the case was reopened in 2006, and in 2017 Federal Oral Court No. 5 convicted him of her enforced disappearance. What became of her has never been established.
November 1951: Born in Mar del Plata, Argentina.
March 24, 1976: The armed forces seize power in Argentina.
August 5, 1976: First abduction in the Rome case.
January 27, 1977: A Swedish-Argentine teenager seized in El Palomar and taken to the ESMA.
March 25, 1977: The task group abducts a man the cassation court later confirmed it killed.
June 18, 1977: Two further disappearances in the Rome case.
December 8 to 10, 1977: Members of the relatives' group, including the two French nuns and three founders of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, seized.
1980: Navy inquiry dismisses the 1977 abduction case against him.
1982: Surrenders the South Georgia garrison; held in Britain as a prisoner of war; returned to Argentina in June.
1985: Tried and acquitted in the 1977 abduction case.
1986 and 1987: Full Stop and Due Obedience laws.
March 16, 1990: Paris cour d'assises sentences him to life in absentia.
February 1991: France issues an international arrest warrant.
January 1998: Interview published; held for 60 days; discharged from the Navy that year.
March 8, 2000: Convicted of apología del crimen; three months, suspended.
July and August 2001: Held about six weeks at Italy's request; extradition refused.
December 27, 2001: Arrested at Sweden's request; freed at the end of January 2002.
2003: Amnesty laws annulled.
May 2006: Indicted and held in preventive detention.
March 2007: Rome court of assize sentences him to life in absentia (upheld 2008 and 2009).
Late 2009: Case 1270 trial opens.
October 26, 2011: Life imprisonment, Federal Oral Court No. 5.
November 28, 2012: Unified ESMA trial opens.
April 23, 2014: Cassation upholds the 2011 sentence.
November 29, 2017: Second life sentence, Federal Oral Court No. 5.
March 2026: Held in a federal prison in Buenos Aires Province.