Alfons Klein

Victims
More than 400 forced laborers killed at Hadamar, 1944-1945. Convicted October 15, 1945, by a US military commission at Wiesbaden of aiding, abetting and participating in the killings
Years active
Specification: on or about July 1, 1944, to on or about April 1, 1945; Hadamar, Germany
Location
Hadamar; Wiesbaden; Bruchsal; Frickhofen (Germany)
Method
Aiding, abetting and participating in the killing of human beings of Polish and Russian nationality; chief administrative officer who received and passed on the orders
Status
Sentenced to death October 15, 1945; confirmed by the 7th Army commander and the commanding general, US Forces, European Theater; executed at Bruchsal March 14, 1946

Alfons Klein was the chief administrative officer of the state institution at Hadamar during the months in 1944 and 1945 when hundreds of Polish and Soviet forced laborers were sent there and killed. He did not hold a medical post. His work was records, food, housing and reports, and, by the finding of the court that tried him, the receiving of orders from his superiors and their transmission to the staff who carried them out. In October 1945 a United States military commission sitting at Wiesbaden found him guilty of a violation of international law and sentenced him to death. He was executed at Bruchsal on March 14, 1946.

The case carried his name. Its formal title was United States of America v. Alfons Klein et al., and it was one of the earliest war crimes trials held in connection with German atrocities of the Second World War, and among the first tried by a military commission after Germany surrendered on May 8, 1945. It was also the first trial of the Nazi "euthanasia" killings held anywhere in the western zones of occupied Germany. Six other members of the Hadamar staff stood trial beside him. All seven were convicted. Klein and two members of the nursing staff were condemned to death; the four others received prison terms, all of which were later reduced.

Klein was born on June 8, 1909, in Frickhofen. He worked as a white-collar employee. He joined the Sturmabteilung, the Nazi Party's paramilitary wing, on January 1, 1930, and the Nazi Party itself on October 1 of the same year, more than two years before Hitler came to power.

His immediate superior was an official of the district administration in Wiesbaden who visited Hadamar often, and above him stood the Gauleiter. The court that tried Klein found that the policy carried out at Hadamar came from the Wiesbaden officials and, at the top, from the Gauleiter. Neither man was in the dock.

Hadamar had opened as a state sanatorium for the mentally ill in 1906. In 1941 it became a killing center of the Nazi program against psychiatric patients, and in August 1942 its staff began killing again while the institution kept the outward appearance of an ordinary hospital. One staff member later stated that Klein became the administrative inspector of Hadamar in November or December 1942. By the time the foreign laborers began to arrive in 1944, he was its chief administrative officer, and a staff statement read into the record of a later American trial put his position plainly: "Klein was Chief of the Hadamar-Institution and issued all orders."

The institution's formal head was its chief physician, Adolf Wahlmann, who had been its only doctor since August 1942. The practical running of the place sat with Klein. He kept the records and ran the household, and when transports arrived, the papers of the people on them were taken to the office and handed to him, and he passed them on to the bookkeeper. The district official from Wiesbaden, on his frequent visits, held his conferences with Klein and with the physician together.

During the war hundreds of thousands of Polish and Soviet civilians were deported to Germany for labor. The commission that tried Klein took judicial notice of that fact, and it was on that fact that the case turned. Between June 1944 and March 1945, 476 Polish and Soviet men, women and children were sent to Hadamar from the labor system. Nearly all of them were killed within one or two days of their arrival. The charge against Klein and his co-accused described their number as unknown but exceeding 400.

A name list of the Hadamar victims was compiled during the investigation, and a list of the Russian and Polish dead went into evidence at trial. They came to Hadamar as workers under the control of the German Reich, not as patients of the institution, and the staff falsified their death records as to both the date and the cause of death. One woman escaped.

The decision was made in the summer of 1944, and Klein was in the room for it. At a conference in July or August of that year he was told that foreign laborers would be sent to Hadamar. At a later meeting he was told that they were to be killed under the same supposed law that had been applied to the German patients. He attended the planning conference with the Wiesbaden official and the physician before the first of them arrived, and it was there that the course to be followed was settled.

The prosecution's case against Klein rested on his position in the chain of command. He received from the Wiesbaden official and the Gauleiter the orders to receive the foreign workers and to have them killed, and he passed those orders to the staff. The chief male nurse and a second male nurse carried out the killings. The chief female nurse was present when some of the deaths occurred and when the false certificates were made out. The bookkeeper falsified the death registers, and the doorman was charged with knowing in advance what was to happen.

His co-accused placed him at the center of it. One of them told the commission that Klein "gave all the orders." The male nurse stated that the orders to kill came from Klein, and the chief male nurse said that he was given the names of the dead on Klein's instruction, for the institution's statistical reports.

Klein did not deny the orders. He testified that he had protested both the transfers and the killings, without success, that he had no authority over who was admitted or what was done with them, and that he feared he would be sent to a concentration camp if he refused. He said he had never threatened any member of the staff himself.

At first he denied that he had ever ordered the killings or taken part in them. Under cross-examination he admitted that he had given the orders, though he insisted he had only passed on what the Wiesbaden official instructed. His other orders, on the reception of the transports, he called "purely administrative." He said he had never seen the decree under which the institution supposedly acted, though he did not doubt it existed. He conceded that what had been done was wrong.

US Army units reached Hadamar on March 26, 1945, and the 2nd Infantry Division secured the institute on March 29, after townspeople alerted the soldiers to what had happened there. More than 500 patients were still inside.

The investigation began at once. The leadership of the institution still on the premises was taken into custody and interrogated, and the US Army questioned witnesses. Statements taken from Klein and from three of his co-accused were later entered at trial as prosecution exhibits.

The commanding general of the 7th Army appointed the commission, six American officers sitting at Wiesbaden, 27 miles north of Hadamar.

The trial opened on October 8, 1945. There was a single charge, Violation of International Law, with one specification. It alleged that the seven accused, acting jointly and for the German Reich, between on or about July 1, 1944, and on or about April 1, 1945, at Hadamar, did "wilfully, deliberately and wrongfully, aid, abet, and participate in the killing of human beings" of Polish and Russian nationality, whose number was unknown but exceeded 400, and who were then confined by the German Reich "as an exercise of belligerent control." Klein's name stood first. Every defendant pleaded not guilty.

The defense opened by attacking the commission's right to hear the case at all. The victims were not Americans and the acts had not taken place on American soil, and the American and German defense counsel argued that the commission had no jurisdiction under international law. The commission rejected the challenge.

The defense then argued compulsion. The accused, counsel said, could neither leave their posts nor protest the orders without risking imprisonment and death in a concentration camp. The Trial Judge Advocate answered that they could have resigned without fear for their lives, and the commission accepted that argument. Klein had made the same claim of fear for himself, and his own earlier statement that the staff were free to leave stood against it.

The plea of superior orders failed as well. Klein's case was that he had passed on what came down to him from Wiesbaden. The commission applied the settled doctrine that a subordinate who carries out an illegal order is liable for it, and it rejected the defenses of coercion and necessity both on the facts and in law.

The defense also sought to rest the killings on German law. It failed to prove that any decree authorizing them existed. At most, the court found, there had been an administrative order issued from Hitler's office, and even if such an order existed, it could not be read to cover people who were not German nationals. In his closing statement Klein maintained that the killings had been justified and were no violation of international law.

On October 15, 1945, the commission found all seven defendants guilty. Klein was sentenced to death, as were the chief male nurse, Heinrich Ruoff, and the male nurse Karl Willig. The physician, Wahlmann, received life imprisonment. The bookkeeper, Adolf Merkle, received 35 years, the doorman and cemetery keeper, Philipp Blum, 30 years, and the chief female nurse, Irmgard Huber, 25 years.

The sentences went up through two levels of review. The Staff Judge Advocate of the 7th Army reviewed the case, and the Deputy Theater Judge Advocate's office reviewed it again. The commanding general of the 7th Army, as reviewing authority, confirmed the findings of the commission but altered the form of the death sentences. In the final review the commanding general of US Forces, European Theater, confirmed the death sentences, Klein's among them, as the commission had pronounced them, and ordered them carried out.

Klein was executed at Bruchsal on March 14, 1946, the same day as Ruoff and Willig.

The prison terms of the four other defendants were later reduced, and all four had been released by 1954.

The case left aside the killing of German patients at Hadamar. American legal authorities held that the deaths of German nationals there, carried out by Germans under a directive of their own head of state, were not a violation of international law that a military commission could punish. Many thousands of German patients had died at Hadamar, but the indictment named none of them. The case was confined to the Polish and Russian nationals.

For the victims named in the charge, the commission found jurisdiction under international law on several grounds. Under the Hague Convention of 1907, which Germany and the United States had both ratified, the occupying and belligerent powers owed protection to civilians in their control, and the killing of civilians without just cause was a war crime. A 1943 opinion of the Judge Advocate General of the US Army held that such violations could be tried and punished even when citizens of the prosecuting nation were not among the victims. The commission also relied on the direct interest of the Allies in the case and on the supreme authority the four occupying powers assumed in Germany under the Berlin Declaration of June 5, 1945, under which the United States stood as the local sovereign in its zone. The accused were civilians, not soldiers, and the commission held that the laws of war bind civilians who commit illegal acts against enemy nationals. Because the killings were punishable as violations of the laws and customs of war, the commission had no need to reach the question of crimes against humanity.

The judgment entered the international law reports as In re Klein and Others, the Hadamar Sanatorium Case, a precedent on three points: superior orders, the killing under belligerent occupation of Allied nationals deported from their own countries, and civilians as the authors of war crimes.

The date on which Klein took charge of Hadamar's administration is not settled. A staff statement dates his appointment as administrative inspector to November or December 1942; by 1944 he stood at the head of the administration. The specification fixed the period of the killings at about July 1, 1944, to about April 1, 1945, and the number of the dead at more than 400, while 476 Polish and Soviet laborers had been sent to Hadamar between June 1944 and March 1945.

Klein's claim that he had protested the orders and acted in fear of a concentration camp was put to the commission and rejected. So was the defense's case that the killings rested on German law: the decree Klein said he believed in, but had never seen, was never produced.

Timeline

June 8, 1909: Alfons Klein is born in Frickhofen.

January 1, 1930: Joins the Sturmabteilung.

October 1, 1930: Joins the Nazi Party.

August 1942: Killing resumes at Hadamar.

November or December 1942: Klein becomes administrative inspector of Hadamar, by a staff statement.

July or August 1944: At a conference, Klein is told that foreign laborers will be sent to Hadamar.

June 1944 to March 1945: 476 Polish and Soviet forced laborers are sent to Hadamar; nearly all are killed.

Late March 1945: US forces reach Hadamar; the 2nd Infantry Division secures the institute on March 29.

October 8, 1945: The trial of United States of America v. Alfons Klein et al. opens at Wiesbaden.

October 15, 1945: All seven accused are convicted; Klein is sentenced to death.

March 14, 1946: Klein is executed at Bruchsal.