Alexander Pustovalov

Victims
22 contract murders proven in three Russian trials. Moscow City Court, 2004 (22 years); jury verdict, 2005 (banditry, 23 years combined); four counts, six deaths, December 2016 (24 years)
Years active
1995 to 1997 (offenses in the three verdicts)
Location
Moscow; Moscow Region; near Athens, Greece
Method
Murder for hire, aggravated; participation in an armed gang and a criminal community
Status
24 years combined, strict-regime colony; parole refused, including by the Supreme Court in 2021; released November 2023 under three years of court-ordered supervision

Alexander Pustovalov was a contract killer for the Orekhovo group, one of the most powerful criminal organizations in Moscow in the 1990s, and three Russian trials convicted him of 22 murders committed on its orders. The Moscow City Court sentenced him first in 2004 to 22 years. A jury in the same court convicted him again in August 2005 in the case of the Orekhovo-Medvedkovo group, and his combined term rose to 23 years. That case included the deaths in Greece, early in 1997, of Alexander Solonik and Svetlana Kotova, which the prosecution laid at his door. In December 2016 a third verdict added four more counts of murder, covering six deaths in Moscow and the Moscow Region in 1995 and 1996, and his combined term became 24 years.

He was arrested in November 1999. He bargained with investigators: his evidence against the group's leaders in exchange for the prosecution not asking for a life sentence. He served his full term, twice failed to win early release, and walked out of a strict-regime colony in Tver Region in November 2023 into three years of court-ordered supervision in Moscow.

Pustovalov was born in Moscow on September 25, 1973, and grew up in the city. As a boy he trained in judo and later tried karate, taekwondo and wushu, without any competitive success of note.

He was called up in 1991 and did his military service as a conscript in the naval infantry of the Northern Fleet. When he came out he wanted a place in one of the Interior Ministry's special units. The units took mostly men with secondary or higher education, and he was turned down for lacking it.

He went instead to the Orekhovo criminal group, which in the early 1990s ran protection rackets in Moscow and was then counted among the most powerful gangs in the former Soviet Union. After the killing of its founder in 1994 the group split into factions. Pustovalov attached himself to one of the largest, led by Sergei Butorin. He began as Butorin's bodyguard and was then given killings to carry out.

By the middle of the decade the Orekhovo factions and the Medvedkovo group, a brigade of contract killers led by Oleg Pylev, had come together in a criminal community of more than 30 people. Its members controlled businesses and took money from them in return for what they called protection.

Pustovalov was detained on November 19, 1999. He refused to write a confession, but he let it be known that he might be willing to cooperate.

That opening became a bargain. In exchange for his testimony against Butorin, the Pylev brothers and other figures in the group, prosecutors agreed not to ask for a life sentence. The leaders he was to testify against were tried in the years that followed, and in September 2011 the Moscow City Court sentenced Butorin to life.

The investigation took five years. The first case against Pustovalov came to trial in the Moscow City Court in the spring of 2004. Of some 35 killings the investigation laid at his door, the prosecution proved his part in 13 at that trial. The court sentenced him to 22 years in a strict-regime colony for that series of contract murders.

The two deaths near Athens early in 1997 came before a jury in the second case, the trial of the Orekhovo-Medvedkovo group in the Moscow City Court, and the prosecution's case was that Pustovalov had killed both. On August 10, 2005, the jury returned guilty verdicts against him and his co-defendants, and sentence followed on August 17. Pustovalov was convicted of banditry, his part in an armed gang and a criminal community, and the court set his combined term at 23 years, taking in the 22 years from 2004. The first of the two deaths in Greece was among the 22 contract killings the courts proved against him across his trials.

More than a decade later, investigators of the Moscow directorate of the Investigative Committee brought a further case against him for killings that had not been part of the earlier verdicts. He was charged with four counts of aggravated murder. The six people named in those four counts died in Moscow and the Moscow Region in 1995 and 1996.

In December 2016 the court accepted the Investigative Committee's evidence as sufficient and convicted him on all four counts. It sentenced him to 24 years in a strict-regime colony. Because the new sentence took in the 23 years already imposed, the effect was to lengthen his total term by one year.

Pustovalov served the first part of his term in Vladimir Region and the later years in a strict-regime colony in Tver Region. Until 2017 the colony administration classed him as a persistent violator of the rules of his sentence. After that he worked, at assembly and later salting vegetables.

He twice applied for early release on parole, and both applications failed. The first, early in 2021, had the support of the Federal Penitentiary Service and the investigating authorities; prosecutors opposed it, and the court refused. In the same year he took a request for early release to the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, and it was refused. A request in the same year to move to a colony-settlement, a lighter regime, was also turned down.

Before his release, on the colony's application, the Nelidovo Interdistrict Court of Tver Region placed him under administrative supervision for three years from his release. His 24-year term ran out in mid-November 2023, and he left the colony that month.

The order bound him to report to the police twice a month and limited where he could live and travel. After his release he lived in Moscow under those terms.

The four counts of 2016 were brought under the murder article of the 1960 RSFSR Criminal Code, the Soviet-era code under which the six deaths of 1995 and 1996 fell. The aggravating features charged were a mercenary motive, the murder of two or more persons, and commission by a group acting by prior agreement.

The 22 murders proved across his three trials are fewer than the investigation attributed to him: of some 35 episodes laid at his door, 13 were proved at the 2004 trial. The killings that were never proved in court remain allegations only.

Timeline

September 25, 1973: Pustovalov is born in Moscow.

1991: He is called up for military service in the naval infantry of the Northern Fleet.

1994: The Orekhovo group's founder is killed and the group splits into factions; Pustovalov serves under Sergei Butorin.

1995 to 1996: Six people die in Moscow and the Moscow Region in the killings later proved against him in 2016.

Early 1997: Two people die near Athens, Greece, in the deaths later laid at his door in the 2005 case.

November 19, 1999: Pustovalov is detained.

Spring 2004: After a five-year investigation, his first trial opens in the Moscow City Court.

2004: The Moscow City Court convicts him of 13 contract murders and sentences him to 22 years.

August 10, 2005: A Moscow City Court jury convicts eleven members of the Orekhovo-Medvedkovo group, among them Pustovalov.

August 17, 2005: He is sentenced to 23 years, combined with the 2004 term.

September 2011: The Moscow City Court sentences Butorin to life.

December 2016: Convicted of four further counts of murder covering six deaths, he receives a combined term of 24 years.

Early 2021: A court refuses his first application for early release on parole.

2021: The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refuses his request for early release.

2023: Before his release the Nelidovo Interdistrict Court places him under three years of administrative supervision.

November 2023: His term ends and he leaves a strict-regime colony in Tver Region.