On July 1, 2009, Marwa El-Sherbini came to the Dresden Regional Court to give evidence against a man she had never wanted to see again. Eleven months earlier, in a Dresden park, Alex Wiens had insulted her as a Muslim when she asked him to make room on a swing for her small son. A local court had fined him for the insult, and he had appealed. She gave her testimony at the appeal hearing that morning, and as she was about to leave he killed her. Her husband, who tried to protect her, was seriously injured, and a federal police officer who came into the room mistook him for the attacker and shot him.
Four months later the same court convicted Wiens of murder, attempted murder and dangerous bodily harm. It found that he had killed her treacherously and from base motives, that hatred of foreigners was his only motive, and that he had acted not out of fear but out of revenge. It sentenced him to life imprisonment and found that his guilt was of particular gravity, a finding that in German law makes release after the usual fifteen years practically impossible. The Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal in June 2010, and the judgment became final.
She was born in Alexandria, Egypt, in 1977, and grew up there. From 1992 to 1999 she played for the Egyptian women's national handball team. In 2005 she moved to Germany with her husband, and their son was born the following year. In 2008 the family settled in Dresden.
Alex Wiens was born in Perm, in the Ural region of Russia. The Dresden court later found that he had spent his childhood in Perm and in Kazakhstan and looked back on those years with contempt. He came to Germany in 2003 as an ethnic German resettler from the former Soviet Union, and at times found work in a warehouse.
The two met in August 2008, in a Dresden park, over a swing. She reported his abuse to the police, and he was prosecuted for insult. In November 2008 he was convicted and fined 780 euros. He appealed, and the appeal came before the Dresden Regional Court on July 1, 2009, with her summoned to testify again.
She had finished her testimony when he killed her. Her husband survived his injuries and later gave evidence against him. Wiens was taken into custody that day and held in pretrial detention in Dresden.
The Dresden public prosecutor's office commissioned a psychiatric assessment, and the expert found nothing that pointed to mental illness. Among the papers in the file was a 1999 Russian document exempting Wiens from military service on health grounds; German investigators asked the Russian authorities what lay behind it and received no answer. The prosecution charged him with murder, attempted murder and dangerous bodily harm, and her husband joined the case as a co-plaintiff, the role German procedure gives a victim.
The trial opened on October 26, 2009, before the jury chamber of the Dresden Regional Court, in the same building where she had died. Later in the trial Wiens spoke through a statement read by one of his lawyers. He admitted the killing. He acknowledged hostility toward foreigners but denied that it was his motive, and he said he did not understand his own act.
Shortly before the verdict, the Russian Prosecutor General's Office sent a statement saying that Wiens, then registered in Russia under the name Aleksandr Igorevich Nelsin, had been diagnosed in 2000 with undifferentiated schizophrenia. The German expert had found him sane and fit to stand trial. The defense asked for a further expert opinion on whether his responsibility had been diminished, and the court declined. In closing, the prosecution asked for life imprisonment; the defense asked for convictions for manslaughter and attempted manslaughter instead of murder.
On November 11, 2009, the jury chamber convicted Wiens of murder, attempted murder and dangerous bodily harm and sentenced him to life imprisonment.
The court rejected the defense case at every point. It found no diminished responsibility and no killing in the heat of passion; the act, it held, was planned. It found two of the qualifying features that turn a killing into murder under the German Criminal Code: that he acted treacherously and that he acted from base motives. Xenophobia, the court held, was his only motive. In its findings he resented foreigners, saw them as rivals for jobs and largely despised Muslims, while suppressing his own foreign origins in his idea of himself as a German. He had not killed her out of fear or anxiety, the judgment said, but out of revenge.
The court also found that his guilt was of particular gravity and ordered him to pay all material and non-material damages to her family. The defense took the case to the Federal Court of Justice, Germany's highest court in criminal matters, which rejected the appeal as unfounded. In June 2010 the Dresden Regional Court announced that the life sentence was final. Where he has been held since then has not been made public.
Wiens never denied the killing. What he contested was its legal character. Through his lawyers he said that hostility toward foreigners was not his motive, that he had not planned the act, and that a mental illness reduced his responsibility. The court rejected each claim and found the motive to be xenophobia alone.
The Russian statement of a schizophrenia diagnosis in 2000 arrived only days before the verdict and was never tested by a second German expert, because the court refused the defense request for one. The German psychiatric assessment found no mental illness, and the court found him fully responsible. The Federal Court of Justice upheld the judgment.
1999: A Russian military commission in Perm exempts him from service on health grounds.
2003: He moves from Russia to Germany as an ethnic German resettler.
2005: The victim and her husband move from Egypt to Germany.
2008: The family settles in Dresden.
August 2008: He insults her in a Dresden park; she reports him to the police.
November 2008: He is convicted of insult and fined 780 euros, and he appeals.
July 1, 2009: At the appeal hearing at the Dresden Regional Court he kills her and injures her husband.
October 26, 2009: His murder trial opens at the Dresden Regional Court.
November 11, 2009: He is convicted of murder, attempted murder and dangerous bodily harm and sentenced to life, with a finding of particular gravity of guilt.
June 2010: The Federal Court of Justice rejects his appeal; the judgment becomes final.