Aleksandras Lileikis

Victims
At least 75 Jews, prosecutors charged, handed to Nazi killing units, 1941 to 1944; died before a verdict; never convicted
Years active
August 1941 to July 1944
Location
Vilnius, Lithuania (arrests and killings; 1998 to 2000 trial; death); Norwood, Massachusetts (US residence)
Method
Arrested Jews handed to the German Security Police and the Special Detachment, which killed them by shooting (US court finding and prosecutors' case; no criminal verdict)
Status
US citizenship revoked by a federal court in Boston (civil ruling, not a conviction), May 24, 1996. Trial halted July 2000, no verdict. Died untried in Lithuania, September 26, 2000.

From August 1941 until July 1944, while German forces occupied Lithuania, Aleksandras Lileikis ran the Lithuanian security police, the Saugumas, for the whole of Vilnius province. Half a century later a federal judge in Boston studied the orders that bore his name and ruled that his work in that office amounted to personal participation in persecution. The ruling was civil, not a criminal conviction, but it stripped him of the American citizenship he had held since 1976, and he left the United States for Lithuania within weeks.

Lithuania charged him with genocide in February 1998. Prosecutors accused him of handing at least 75 Jews held in a Vilnius prison over to Nazi killing units, and the case became the first trial for Holocaust crimes in any of the three Baltic states since they won independence from the Soviet Union. His trial opened in 1998 but was halted in July 2000 with no verdict. Medical panels, adjournments and changes to the law stretched the proceedings across more than two years, and he appeared in the courtroom only once. He died on September 26, 2000, at the age of 93, an accused man who was never convicted of any crime. He always denied the charges and called the documents against him forgeries.

The German army entered Lithuania in the summer of 1941, and the occupation lasted until 1944. Under it the Lithuanian security police worked as a Nazi-sponsored force, and in Vilnius province it answered to Lileikis from August 1941 until the occupation ended in July 1944. He never disputed that he held the post. What he disputed, from the first accusation to the last, was what the post had meant.

Vilnius had one of the largest Jewish communities in Europe before the war. About 55,000 of the city's 60,000 Jews died during the occupation, and across Lithuania about 94 percent of a prewar Jewish community of some 240,000 people were killed. The Saugumas was one link in that machinery. Its officers arrested Jews who had escaped or tried to escape the ghetto, and those people were held, then handed to the German Security Police or to a unit of Lithuanian volunteers known as the Ypatingas Burys, the Special Detachment, which killed them.

The case against Lileikis rested on paper. His signature appears on orders preserved in the Lithuanian Central State Archives, to which American investigators were given free access in the early 1990s. Investigators read in those orders the reasons given for arrests: "suspected of being a Jew," "escaping from the ghetto," and "hiding" a child of six. According to the same records, he directed such prisoners removed from a hard-labor prison under his control and turned over to the Special Detachment or the German Security Police. Evidence gathered by the US Justice Department and the Lithuanian Prosecutor General's Office described written orders, issued between 1941 and 1944, to kill dozens of Jews held in a Vilnius labor prison.

When the occupation ended, Lileikis went west and spent time in a refugee camp in Germany. American records that came to light in 2014 show that United States intelligence recruited him in that period to gather information in East Germany.

He reached the United States in 1955 and settled in Massachusetts. He became an American citizen in 1976. For decades he lived in Norwood, a suburb of Boston, and worked in publishing; by the 1990s he was retired. He was 87 when the federal government moved against his citizenship.

The Justice Department's Office of Special Investigations built its case from the Lithuanian archives. In September 1994 it filed a civil complaint in the US District Court in Boston, asking the court to revoke his citizenship. The complaint alleged that from August 1941 he had directed his force to find and arrest Jews, especially those who escaped or tried to escape the ghettos, that he had ordered them held in a prison in Vilnius, and that they were then killed by the German Security Police or the Special Detachment. One of the people whose case it set out was a girl of six. He was the first Lithuanian police official ever prosecuted in the United States for crimes of the Nazi period. Lileikis told reporters he had nothing to do with the Jews.

He admitted that he had worked with the occupation authorities, but he denied responsibility for any death and fought the case. Questioned about the documents, he acknowledged that he had headed the security police in Vilnius but invoked his Fifth Amendment privilege rather than say whether he had signed the orders. In October 1995 federal lawyers put before the court copies of orders that carried his signature and directed that Jews in Vilnius be handed to the Special Detachment.

Lithuania at first kept its distance. In February 1995 its authorities told the US Embassy that they had no documents to support the accusations and would not prosecute. Within two weeks, after protests, the government reversed itself and reopened the case. In October 1995 Lithuania told the court in Boston that it would not request his extradition.

On May 24, 1996, the federal judge granted the government summary judgment, deciding the case on the undisputed record without a trial. The ruling found that, as chief of the Vilnius Saugumas, Lileikis had ordered arrests for the "offenses" listed in his own documents, including being suspected of being a Jew and hiding a child of six, and had ordered the same prisoners removed from the hard-labor prison and turned over to the Special Detachment or the German Security Police, who killed them. The judge held that these activities "clearly constitute" personal participation in persecution. The proceeding was civil: the government never charged him with a crime in the United States, and the ruling cost him his citizenship, not his liberty.

He did not wait for deportation proceedings. In June 1996 he left the United States, and he arrived in Vilnius on June 18. He said he had come back to seek justice, and that he would not have returned if he felt guilty.

Lithuanian prosecutors questioned him the following week, in a session cut short by his health. The United States had already supplied documentary evidence at Lithuania's request, and the investigation went on through the summer.

His age and health shaped everything that followed. Under Lithuanian law as it then stood, a suspect could not be brought to trial if medical experts ruled that he was too ill. In July 1997 the proceedings against him were postponed after medical experts found him unfit. The following year the parliament changed the law to allow suspected war criminals to be prosecuted regardless of their health, and in February 1998 prosecutors filed the genocide charge. He was 90.

The case came before the Vilnius Regional Court in early March 1998, and it proceeded in his absence. The court rejected a defense motion to drop the charges for lack of evidence. One day after the trial began, the presiding judge adjourned it for ten weeks and ordered the prosecution to obtain the original documents and to question witnesses abroad, among them a woman in Denver whom the defense believed to be the person Lileikis said he had saved.

The documents obtained that spring were originals, among them orders that prosecutors said he had signed as head of the Saugumas; according to the prosecution, one of them handed over 75 Jews held in a Vilnius prison to Nazi killing units. In May the judge postponed the trial again so that investigators could finish examining them.

In September 1998 the court suspended the trial indefinitely and ordered a medical commission to decide whether he was too ill to defend himself. In October a team of doctors found him fit. He came to court that November, the only time he ever appeared in the trial, and declared his innocence. He fell seriously ill shortly after he testified, and the trial was postponed until he was well enough to attend.

He never was. Three panels of doctors warned the court that an appearance could endanger his life, and on September 9, 1999, the Vilnius Regional Court adjourned the trial indefinitely.

Lithuania changed its procedure again in the spring of 2000 so that the elderly defendant could follow the case from outside the courtroom. In June 2000 the court reopened the trial, and Lileikis watched it by video link from his bed. The first session was interrupted when he became ill. In early July 2000 the court halted the trial indefinitely, citing his poor health.

He died on September 26, 2000, at the age of 93, before the trial could be completed. He had been the first person Lithuania brought to trial for Nazi-era crimes, and the Vilnius Regional Court never ruled on the 75 deaths in the indictment.

The core dispute was the documents. Lileikis maintained that the case was fabricated from papers forged by the Soviet KGB after the war to discredit Lithuanian emigres. The federal court in Boston treated the archival record as undisputed, and the Lithuanian court ordered the originals obtained, but no criminal court ever ruled on their authenticity.

His rank is itself contested. He acknowledged heading the Vilnius province Saugumas, and the US court found that he was its chief, but at the time of the 1998 Lithuanian charge he was also described as its deputy head.

Lileikis said he had saved a Jewish woman during the war, and in March 2000 he said he had worked to prevent the massacres of Jews. A Holocaust survivor in Denver told a newspaper in 1998 that he had saved her life. None of these claims was tested at a verdict.

Timeline

August 1941: Lileikis takes charge of the Lithuanian security police for Vilnius province under the German occupation.

July 1944: The occupation of Lithuania ends; his service in the post ends with it.

1955: He enters the United States.

1976: He becomes a US citizen.

September 1994: The Justice Department files a civil complaint in Boston to revoke his citizenship.

February 1995: Lithuania first declines to prosecute, then reopens the case within two weeks.

October 1995: Lithuania says it will not seek his extradition.

May 24, 1996: A federal judge in Boston revokes his citizenship by summary judgment in a civil case.

June 18, 1996: He arrives in Vilnius.

July 1997: Lithuanian proceedings are postponed after medical experts find him unfit.

February 1998: Lithuanian prosecutors charge him with genocide.

March 1998: His trial opens before the Vilnius Regional Court and is adjourned after one day.

September 1998: The court suspends the trial pending a medical commission.

November 1998: He makes his only court appearance and declares his innocence.

September 9, 1999: The court adjourns the trial indefinitely.

June 2000: The trial reopens with Lileikis watching by video link and is soon interrupted.

July 2000: The court halts the trial indefinitely, citing his health; no verdict is ever reached.

September 26, 2000: Lileikis dies at 93, never convicted.