On August 13, 2007, Chiara Poggi was killed in Garlasco, a small town in the province of Pavia. Her boyfriend, Alberto Stasi, then finishing his degree at Bocconi University in Milan, was the one who raised the alarm that day. Within a week he was under investigation for voluntary homicide, and within six weeks he had spent four days in custody. The case became one of the longest in modern Italian criminal justice: an acquittal in 2009, a second acquittal in 2011, an annulment by the Court of Cassation in 2013, a conviction at a retrial in December 2014, and a final judgment on December 12, 2015, that left him with a sentence of 16 years.
Stasi has always denied the killing. For years his denials changed nothing. Two revision attempts failed, an extraordinary appeal was declared inadmissible, and the European Court of Human Rights rejected his complaint about the fairness of the retrial. Then, in March 2025, the Pavia prosecutors placed another man under investigation, and by 2026 they were saying that this man, not Stasi, had committed the murder alone. In November 2026 they asked for him to be tried. As of November 12, 2026, Stasi's conviction remained final, he was serving the rest of his sentence on probation, and no request to reopen his case had yet been filed.
Stasi was born in 1983 in Sesto San Giovanni, on the northern edge of Milan. In the summer of 2007 he was writing his thesis in economics and finance at Bocconi. He graduated on March 27, 2008, with top honors, by then already under investigation.
The inquiry was led by the prosecutors of Vigevano, working with the Carabinieri. On or around August 20, 2007, they opened an investigation against Stasi for voluntary homicide. He was the only suspect. On September 24 the prosecutor in charge ordered his detention. Four days later the judge for preliminary investigations refused to validate it and ordered him released, finding that the scientific results on which the order rested were still provisional and could not support the accusation, and rejecting the claim that he might flee.
The prosecutors asked for Stasi to be sent to trial on November 3, 2008. When the preliminary hearing opened before the Vigevano judge for preliminary hearings, the GUP, on February 23, 2009, his lawyers made the choice that would shape the rest of the case. They asked for the giudizio abbreviato, the abbreviated trial, in which the judge decides on the file assembled by the investigators and a convicted defendant has his sentence reduced by a third. The judge granted it.
He was not ready to decide on the papers alone. On April 30, 2009, he ordered new evidence on his own motion, including four new expert reports and the rehearing of two witnesses, identified in later court records only by the initials B. and T., who had told investigators what they had seen on the morning of the killing. One of them, heard again in June 2009, repeated her earlier description and said that what she had seen did not match the item belonging to Stasi that investigators had seized.
On December 17, 2009, the GUP of Vigevano acquitted Stasi. The judge found the evidence against him "contraddittori o insufficienti," contradictory or insufficient, relying among other things on the two witnesses, whom he judged credible, and noting that nothing matching their description had been found in the possession of Stasi's family.
The prosecution and the civil parties appealed, complaining among other things that an item in the family's possession which, they argued, did match the description had never been seized. On December 6, 2011, the Assize Court of Appeal of Milan rejected the requests for further evidence and confirmed the acquittal. Two courts had now cleared him, four years after the killing.
On April 18, 2013, the First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation annulled the acquittal and sent the case to a different section of the Milan Assize Court of Appeal for a new trial on appeal. Its reasons, filed on October 31, 2013, held that the lower courts had not properly weighed the fact that an item belonging to Stasi's family, which fit the witnesses' description, had never been seized.
The new appeal opened in Milan in April 2014, and the court reopened the evidence on its own motion. The item the Cassation court had singled out was finally seized, new scientific and technical expert reports were commissioned, and the prosecution filed a large volume of new evidence. In October 2014 the court refused a defense request to call the two witnesses back to look at the newly seized item. Their full statements were already in the file, it said, and in its later judgment it added that years of media coverage had affected their memory to the point that they could no longer separate what they had seen from what they believed they had seen.
On December 17, 2014, the Milan Assize Court of Appeal convicted Stasi of the murder, sentenced him to 16 years' imprisonment and ordered him to pay damages to the victim's family. It did not accept the aggravating circumstance of cruelty that the prosecution had sought. The judgment held it established that the victim knew her killer and that the killer knew the family property well. It called Stasi's account of the morning of August 13 "incongrua, illogica e falsa," incongruous, illogical and false. It relied on physical evidence it tied to him and found that he had been in the area at a time compatible with the killing. Although the evidence had not identified what the two witnesses had seen, the court held that Stasi had several items at his disposal that fit their broad description, and that his failure to mention one of them to investigators showed he understood its importance. The motive, the court said, remained unknown.
The sentence followed from the choice made in Vigevano. The court treated the offense as simple voluntary homicide, with no aggravating circumstances and no mitigating ones. The starting point was 24 years; the abbreviated procedure took off a third, leaving 16. Premeditation had never been charged.
Both sides appealed to the Court of Cassation, the defense for acquittal and the Milan prosecutor general's office for the cruelty aggravation to be restored, which would have meant 30 years. At the hearing in December 2015 the deputy prosecutor general at the Court of Cassation asked instead for the conviction itself to be annulled, arguing that no certain motive had been identified and that the evidence was insufficient. On December 12, 2015, the court rejected both appeals. The conviction for voluntary homicide and the sentence of 16 years became final, and Stasi surrendered the same day to begin serving it.
The court's written reasons, filed on June 21, 2016, described the evidence as converging on Stasi like the tiles of a mosaic. They characterized the crime as committed with "dolo d'impeto," sudden intent, "senza alcuna programmazione preventiva," without any planning, and held that the killer had not acted with the intent to inflict additional suffering. They also criticized the early investigation, including the failure to seize the item at the center of the 2013 annulment until 2014, and rejected his complaint about the refusal to rehear the witness, finding that her statements were not decisive for the conviction.
On December 19, 2016, a request to reopen the case was made on Stasi's behalf, resting on a new defense expert report. Four days later the Pavia prosecutors placed a second man, A.S., under investigation on the basis of that report. On January 24, 2017, the Brescia Court of Appeal declared that there was no ground to rule on the revision request. On March 28, 2017, the Pavia judge for preliminary investigations closed the inquiry into A.S., finding his responsibility "categoricamente esclusa," categorically excluded, and describing the defense's genetic consultancy as radically unreliable.
Other routes failed too. An extraordinary appeal asking the Court of Cassation to revoke its own judgment for an alleged "errore di fatto," an error of fact, was declared inadmissible on June 28, 2017. A new request for revision, filed in June 2020, was declared inadmissible on October 5, 2020.
Stasi also took his case to Strasbourg, complaining under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights that the refusal to rehear the witness he considered decisive had denied him a fair trial. On December 12, 2023, the European Court of Human Rights unanimously declared the application inadmissible as manifestly ill-founded. By choosing the abbreviated procedure, it held, Stasi had agreed to be judged on the investigators' file, including that witness's earlier statements, and had given up the right to have her heard in return for the reduced sentence; the judge's decision to gather new evidence on his own motion did not undo that waiver. In any case, the court said, the conviction rested on several pieces of evidence that her statements had only corroborated.
Stasi served his sentence in Lombardy. In January 2023 the Milan supervisory court, the tribunale di sorveglianza, allowed him to work outside the institution, and he took accounting and administrative work in an office in Milan, returning each evening. His first leave permits began in May 2024. On April 11, 2025, after he had served two-thirds of his sentence, the court granted him semi-liberty.
On June 12, 2026, the same court heard his application for affidamento in prova ai servizi sociali, probation under the supervision of the social services, and granted it with the support of the prosecutor general's office. The order was served on June 13, 2026, and Stasi left custody. The court found that semi-liberty had "di fatto, confermato l'assenza di profili di pericolosità," in practice confirmed the absence of any danger, described his conduct as "senza sbavature," without a blemish, and recorded that he continued to meet his civil obligations to the victim's family.
On March 11, 2025, the Pavia prosecutors placed A.S. under investigation a second time, for murder committed in complicity with others. Over the following months a court-supervised evidentiary hearing, the incidente probatorio, examined the old evidence with new expert reports; it ended in Pavia on December 18, 2025.
In April 2026 the Pavia office supported a revision of Stasi's conviction, and on April 29 the accusation against A.S. was changed: prosecutors now alleged that he had acted alone. On November 3, 2026, they asked for him to be tried for aggravated voluntary homicide, alleging the aggravating circumstances of cruelty and abject motives. As of November 12, 2026, a preliminary hearing before a Pavia judge was set for February 25, 2027. A.S. denies the accusation, has not been tried, and is presumed innocent.
As of November 12, 2026, no request for revision of Stasi's conviction had been filed. Any request lies with the Brescia Court of Appeal, which must first rule on whether it is admissible before it can hear new evidence.
For now the legal position is plain. Alberto Stasi stands convicted, by a final judgment of the Court of Cassation, of the voluntary homicide of his girlfriend in Garlasco on August 13, 2007, and he is serving the remainder of his 16-year sentence on probation in Lombardy. He has always said he did not do it. The Pavia prosecutors now say another man committed the killing, a claim no court has yet tested.
The central dispute is who killed the victim. The Court of Cassation held in 2015 that the evidence against Stasi converged beyond reasonable doubt. Two earlier courts had found the same evidence contradictory or insufficient, the deputy prosecutor general at the Court of Cassation asked for the conviction to be annulled, and since 2025 the Pavia prosecutors have accused another man of acting alone. That man has not been tried, and the accusation against him has not been tested in court. Stasi's conviction stands unless and until a revision court rules otherwise.
The motive has never been established. The Milan court that convicted Stasi in 2014 said it remained unknown, and the Court of Cassation described the crime as a sudden, unplanned act. The prosecutors in the new case attribute to A.S. a different motive of their own, which no court has examined.
1983: Alberto Stasi is born in Sesto San Giovanni, near Milan.
August 13, 2007: the victim is killed in Garlasco, province of Pavia; Stasi raises the alarm.
About August 20, 2007: the Vigevano prosecutors open an investigation against Stasi for voluntary homicide.
September 24, 2007: Stasi is detained on a prosecutors' order.
September 28, 2007: the judge for preliminary investigations refuses to validate the detention and releases him.
February 23, 2009: Stasi chooses the abbreviated trial.
December 17, 2009: the GUP of Vigevano acquits Stasi.
December 6, 2011: the Milan Assize Court of Appeal confirms the acquittal.
April 18, 2013: the Court of Cassation annuls the acquittal and orders a new trial on appeal.
December 17, 2014: the Milan Assize Court of Appeal convicts Stasi and sentences him to 16 years.
December 12, 2015: the Court of Cassation rejects both appeals; the conviction is final, and Stasi begins serving his sentence.
December 23, 2016: the Pavia prosecutors place A.S. under investigation.
January 24, 2017: the Brescia Court of Appeal finds no ground to rule on a revision.
March 28, 2017: the inquiry into A.S. is closed.
June 28, 2017: the Court of Cassation declares Stasi's extraordinary appeal inadmissible.
October 5, 2020: a further revision request is declared inadmissible.
December 12, 2023: the European Court of Human Rights declares his application inadmissible.
March 11, 2025: A.S. is placed under investigation again.
April 11, 2025: Stasi is granted semi-liberty.
June 13, 2026: Stasi leaves custody on probation with the social services.
November 3, 2026: the Pavia prosecutors ask for A.S. to be tried for aggravated voluntary homicide.
February 25, 2027: preliminary hearing for A.S. scheduled in Pavia (as of November 12, 2026).