Al Amin Khalifa Fhimah was one of two Libyan men charged in 1991 over the destruction of Pan Am Flight 103 above the Scottish town of Lockerbie on December 21, 1988, in which 259 people on board and 11 residents of the town died. For most of the 1980s he had run the Libyan Arab Airlines office at Luqa airport in Malta, and prosecutors in Scotland and the United States alleged that he had used that position to help the plot. Libya refused for years to surrender him. When it finally did, in April 1999, he stood trial beside Abdelbaset al-Megrahi before three Scottish judges sitting without a jury at Camp Zeist in the Netherlands.
On January 31, 2001, the court convicted Megrahi of murder and found Fhimah not guilty. The verdict was unanimous. The judges found no acceptable evidence that he knew the purpose of anything the Crown said he had done, and nothing at all to place him at Luqa airport on the day the Crown said mattered. The presiding judge told him he was discharged and free to go. He went home to Libya, lived quietly in Tripoli for a quarter of a century, never faced trial again, and died there on August 25, 2026. He always denied any part in the attack.
Fhimah was born in 1956 in Souq al-Jumaa, on the outskirts of Tripoli. After working his way through earlier posts he joined Libyan Arab Airlines, and in the mid-1980s the airline posted him to Malta as its official at Luqa, the island's international airport, where he handled dispatch and ran the station. The trial court found that he was the airline's station manager there from 1985 until about October 1988. He left the airline's Malta office shortly before the Lockerbie disaster. With a Maltese partner he set up a travel business, Medtours, and he kept an office diary there in 1988.
He knew Megrahi, the man who would later sit beside him in the dock. The two traveled together from Malta to Tripoli on December 18, 1988, and came back to Malta together on December 20. That evening both men visited Fhimah's business partner. The next day Pan Am Flight 103 was destroyed in the air over Lockerbie. Every one of the 259 passengers and crew died, as did 11 people in the town. The dead were citizens of 21 countries; 190 of them were Americans.
On November 13, 1991, a Scottish sheriff granted a warrant for the arrest of Fhimah and Megrahi on charges of conspiracy to murder, murder and a contravention of the Aviation Security Act 1982. The United States charged both men the same year. Neither Britain nor the United States had an extradition treaty with Libya, and Libya would not surrender them. It argued that they could not get a fair trial in either country and claimed the right to try them itself under the 1971 Montreal Convention.
The United Nations Security Council imposed sanctions on Libya in 1992 until it surrendered the accused, and widened them in 1993. Libya offered a trial in Malta, which London and Washington rejected, and in 1994 proposed a Scottish court sitting in a neutral country such as the Netherlands. In August 1998 the two governments accepted that idea, the Security Council approved it, and on September 16, 1998, the British government made the order that let a Scottish court sit on Dutch soil, naming Fhimah and Megrahi as the accused. The two men would fly directly from Libya to the Netherlands and be tried only for the Pan Am case; if acquitted, they would be returned directly to Libya. Nelson Mandela, then president of South Africa, and Saudi diplomats helped persuade the Libyan leader, Muammar Gaddafi, that the men would be tried fairly.
On April 5, 1999, almost a decade after the disaster, Libya handed the two men over, with Italy helping to arrange their transport. They were flown to Camp Zeist, a former American air base near Utrecht, and the Security Council suspended its sanctions.
The trial opened on May 3, 2000. Three judges of the High Court of Justiciary sat without a jury and held all the powers a jury would have had, with a fourth judge sitting as a reserve. The accused had chosen trial by judges in place of a Scottish jury.
The Crown's case against Fhimah, every part of which the court would in the end reject, was circumstantial. The first strand was his office diary, recovered from the Medtours office in April 1991. Prosecutors said entries for December 1988 showed him obtaining material from the airport for Megrahi. The second was opportunity: his years as station manager, his knowledge of Luqa and the airside pass he had kept after leaving the post, along with the trip to Tripoli with Megrahi and a telephone call to Fhimah early on December 21. Someone who knew the airport, the Crown said, had to be involved, and Fhimah fitted the part. The third strand was a witness, a Libyan who had worked in the airline's office at Luqa and had later defected and dealt with the American Central Intelligence Agency. He told the court he had seen the two men together at Luqa on December 20 and made other accusations against Fhimah.
When the Crown closed its evidence in late November 2000, Fhimah's defense asked the judges to rule that he had no case to answer, arguing that even at its highest the evidence did not show he knew of any plan to destroy an aircraft. The court refused, but it held only that there was enough evidence "in terms of quantity" for the case to go on. Guilt still had to be proved beyond reasonable doubt, and the quality of the evidence still had to be weighed.
The defense cases closed on January 8, 2001. No defense case was led for Fhimah. That day the Crown removed its description of him as a member of the Libyan intelligence service, and by the close of its submissions the charges had been restricted to murder alone.
The judges gave their verdicts at Camp Zeist on January 31, 2001. Megrahi was found guilty of murder. Fhimah was found not guilty. Scots law allowed a third verdict, not proven, and the court did not use it. The judge told Fhimah, "You are discharged and free to go."
The court's written opinion explained why. It said the diary entries could easily be read in an incriminating light, but they were unexplained, and "it would be going too far to infer that he was necessarily aware" that anything he obtained was meant for the destruction of an aircraft. There was "insufficient other acceptable evidence to support or confirm such an inference." Scots law required every essential element of a crime to be proved by evidence from more than one source, and without that corroboration the diary could not carry the case. The court found "no evidence at all to suggest that the second accused was even at Luqa airport on 21 December." It treated the early morning telephone call as wholly speculative proof of anything, and it found the purpose of the trip to Tripoli "simply unknown." "In these circumstances," the judges wrote, "the second accused falls to be acquitted."
The defector fared no better. His accusations about the airline office had emerged late, and the judges said they were unable to place any reliance on them. They rejected his account of seeing the two men at Luqa on December 20 as well, partly because Fhimah's business partner placed both men with him that evening. The court found the defector a witness motivated largely by money who had grossly exaggerated his own importance, and accepted him as credible on almost nothing. The verdicts, the opinion ended, were the unanimous decision of the three judges.
Under the terms agreed in 1998, an acquitted man was to be returned directly to Libya, and Fhimah was free to leave the Netherlands at once. In Tripoli he was welcomed by officials and by crowds. He did not seek attention afterward. He lived in Tripoli as a private citizen with his family and turned down requests for press interviews.
In December 2020 the United States charged a third Libyan, Abu Agila Masud Kheir Al-Marimi, over the destruction of Pan Am 103. An FBI affidavit filed with that complaint alleged that Masud, in an interview with Libyan law enforcement, had described flying to Malta to meet Megrahi and Fhimah. Masud came into American custody in December 2022. He denies the charges and says the statement attributed to him was obtained under duress. No court has tested the affidavit's account of Fhimah, and no new charge was ever brought against him.
Fhimah died in Tripoli on August 25, 2026. Libyan Airlines, his former employer, announced his death, PA Media reported, and Scottish Legal News gave his age as 70.
The prosecution's account of Fhimah's role, that he used his post and his knowledge of Luqa to help the plot, was an allegation the court rejected. The judges found no acceptable evidence that he knew the purpose of anything he did and no evidence that he was at the airport on December 21, 1988, and they acquitted him unanimously.
The description of him as a Libyan intelligence official, made when the charges were announced in 1991, was withdrawn by the Crown before the verdict.
The defector's evidence against him was rejected in full, and the court said it could place no reliance on his accusations about the airline office.
The 2020 FBI affidavit's account of what Masud told Libyan officials about Fhimah is an untested allegation that has never been put to a court against Fhimah. Masud denies the charges against him, and Fhimah, who denied any involvement throughout, died without being charged again.
1956: Born in Souq al-Jumaa, on the outskirts of Tripoli, Libya.
1985 to about October 1988: Station manager for Libyan Arab Airlines at Luqa airport, Malta.
December 18 to 20, 1988: Travels with Abdelbaset al-Megrahi from Malta to Tripoli and back.
December 21, 1988: Pan Am Flight 103 is destroyed over Lockerbie, Scotland; 270 people die.
November 13, 1991: Scottish warrant for his arrest on charges of conspiracy to murder, murder and a contravention of the Aviation Security Act 1982.
1991: Charges brought against both men in the United States.
1992 and 1993: United Nations sanctions imposed on Libya, then widened.
September 16, 1998: The British government makes the order allowing a Scottish trial in the Netherlands.
April 5, 1999: Handed over by Libya and flown to the Netherlands for trial at Camp Zeist.
May 3, 2000: The trial opens at Camp Zeist.
January 8, 2001: The defense cases close; no defense case is led for him.
January 31, 2001: Acquitted by the unanimous verdict of the three judges; Megrahi is convicted.
December 21, 2020: The United States charges a third Libyan; an FBI affidavit makes untested allegations that refer to Fhimah.
August 25, 2026: Dies in Tripoli, aged 70.