Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh was the man Pakistan put on trial for the abduction and death of Daniel Pearl, the South Asia bureau chief of The Wall Street Journal, who had come to Karachi in January 2002 to report on armed militant groups. On July 15, 2002, an anti-terrorism court sitting inside the central jail in Hyderabad, Sindh, convicted Sheikh of conspiracy, kidnapping for ransom and murder and sentenced him to death.
The verdict did not hold. His appeal sat before the Sindh High Court for nearly eighteen years. When the court finally ruled, on April 2, 2020, it found no evidence linking him to the killing, acquitted him of murder and of kidnapping for ransom, and convicted him only of abduction, for a seven-year term he had long since served. On January 28, 2021, the Supreme Court of Pakistan, by a vote of two to one, dismissed the appeals against that ruling and went further, holding that even the abduction conviction should not have stood. No conviction remained. By law he was an acquitted man. In practice the state kept him, and as of September 2024 he was still in custody in Punjab.
Sheikh was born in England and grew up partly there and partly in Lahore. In 1992 he was admitted to the London School of Economics, but he did not stay long. In the early 1990s he traveled to Bosnia with an aid convoy organized from Britain, never went back to finish his degree, and joined Harkat-ul-Ansar, a militant group fighting in Kashmir. Arrested in India in 1994 over the abduction of four Western backpackers, he spent five years in Indian custody without a court deciding his role, until India released him on December 31, 1999, in exchange for the passengers of a hijacked airliner.
The journalist was abducted in Karachi on January 23, 2002. Four days later ransom emails reached news organizations from a group no one had heard of, and a further email followed on January 30. On February 21, Pakistani and American authorities announced that he was dead. When he had been killed, and by whose hand, was a question that would shadow every court that later heard the case.
By early February, three men held by Karachi police had named Sheikh as the plan's organizer, and police announced that he had been arrested in Lahore. On February 14, brought before an anti-terrorism judge in Karachi so that police could ask for his remand, he said in English that he had been involved in the kidnapping and that he had surrendered on February 5. The written order made no mention of what he said, the statement never became part of the trial record, and he later retracted any admission.
Sheikh and three co-accused were charged under the Pakistan Penal Code with criminal conspiracy, kidnapping for ransom and murder, read with the Anti-Terrorism Act of 1997. All four pleaded not guilty. The trial opened in Karachi on April 22, 2002, and on April 30 the Sindh High Court moved it to Hyderabad, where it sat inside the guarded central jail.
The prosecution called 23 witnesses. The most important for Sheikh was a Karachi taxi driver whose testimony placed him with the journalist on the day of the abduction. The state also relied on expert evidence tying Sheikh's handwriting to a ransom demand, on confessions two co-accused had made before a magistrate, and on a computer the police said had been used to send the emails. Sheikh and his co-defendants denied any part in the kidnapping.
On July 15, 2002, the judge convicted all four. Sheikh was sentenced to death and moved to the jail's condemned ward; the three co-accused were given life terms, which the Sindh High Court set aside in 2020, acquitting them outright. In the United States, Sheikh was indicted the same year for hostage-taking, a charge that has never been tried.
The appeals then sat before the Sindh High Court for almost two decades, while Sheikh remained under sentence of death. When a two-judge bench finally ruled, it acquitted him of murder, holding that the prosecution had brought no evidence linking him to the killing, and of kidnapping for ransom, finding no proof of a conspiracy to abduct. The state's appeal for heavier sentences was dismissed.
The bench took the prosecution's case apart piece by piece. The two confessions had been recorded 27 days after the arrests, and the magistrate who took them had admitted at trial that they were not voluntary; the court discarded them. The dates the police gave for recovering the computer did not fit the date on which an FBI expert began examining it, and the court said it could not rule out that the machine had been doctored. The handwriting evidence carried no legal weight because the expert's qualifications had never been proved. There was no direct evidence that Sheikh had sent the ransom emails. Even the arrest was in doubt: the court found he had surrendered to police in Lahore in early February, while the prosecution's case placed the arrest in Karachi on February 13.
What remained was the testimony placing Sheikh with the journalist on the day of the abduction. Without strong corroboration, the bench held, it could not support convictions for kidnapping for ransom or murder, but it did support a conviction for abduction under section 362 of the Penal Code, an offense outside the Anti-Terrorism Act. His death sentence was set aside and he was sentenced to seven years' rigorous imprisonment with a fine. With his years in custody and remission, the term counted as served.
The government did not let him go. The Sindh provincial government placed him in detention under public-order and then anti-terrorism orders, and in December 2020 the Sindh High Court declared those orders void and ordered his release. He stayed in custody under emergency orders while the provincial government appealed the acquittal to the Supreme Court.
A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court of Pakistan dismissed the appeals on January 28, 2021, by a majority of two to one, upheld the acquittal and ordered Sheikh's release unless he was wanted in another case. In its detailed judgment, released in late March, the majority held that the Sindh High Court had rightly given him the benefit of the doubt on every charge but one, and had been wrong on that one: the abduction conviction rested on the taxi driver's testimony, which was too doubtful to rely on. A single circumstance creating reasonable doubt, the majority held, entitled an accused to its benefit as of right. The third judge dissented and would have convicted Sheikh of kidnapping for ransom, conspiracy and terrorism, though not of murder, with life imprisonment. The day after the ruling, the Sindh government asked the court to review it.
On February 2, 2021, the Supreme Court ordered Sheikh moved out of the death cell into a government rest house, with visits allowed but no contact with the outside world. On March 25 it allowed the authorities to take him to Punjab and hold him in a high-security area, without ordering his release. On April 8, 2021, he was flown from Karachi to Lahore and lodged in the staff colony of a high-security jail. As of September 2024 he was still in custody in Punjab.
No court has found who killed the journalist. The trial court's murder verdict was set aside on appeal, the Supreme Court majority found that the prosecution had proved no charge against Sheikh, and the one judge who would have convicted him did not find him guilty of murder.
The date and circumstances of his surrender are contested. He told the Karachi court that he surrendered on February 5, 2002; police announced an arrest in Lahore; the prosecution's case at trial placed the arrest in Karachi on February 13, a discrepancy the Sindh High Court counted against the state. His statement in court on February 14 was never part of the trial record and was later retracted.
1992: Sheikh is admitted to the London School of Economics.
Early 1990s: He travels to Bosnia with an aid convoy and does not return to his studies.
1994: He is arrested in India over the abduction of four Western backpackers.
December 31, 1999: India releases him in exchange for the passengers of a hijacked airliner.
January 23, 2002: The journalist is abducted in Karachi.
January 27 and 30, 2002: Ransom emails are sent to news organizations.
February 14, 2002: Sheikh appears before an anti-terrorism judge in Karachi.
February 21, 2002: Pakistani and US officials announce the journalist's death.
April 22, 2002: The trial opens in Karachi.
April 30, 2002: The Sindh High Court moves the trial to Hyderabad.
July 15, 2002: The Anti-Terrorism Court convicts all four accused and sentences Sheikh to death.
2002: He is indicted in the United States for hostage-taking.
April 2, 2020: The Sindh High Court acquits him of murder and kidnapping for ransom and convicts him of abduction, seven years.
December 2020: The Sindh High Court declares his detention orders void.
January 28, 2021: The Supreme Court of Pakistan upholds the acquittal, 2-1, and orders his release.
January 29, 2021: The Sindh government files a review petition.
February 2, 2021: The Supreme Court orders him moved from the death cell to a rest house.
March 25, 2021: The Supreme Court allows his transfer to Punjab.
April 8, 2021: He is flown from Karachi to Lahore and held in a jail staff colony.
September 2024: He remains in custody in Punjab.