On August 7, 1998, the United States embassies in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi, Kenya, were attacked on the same morning. Eleven people died in Dar es Salaam and 213 in Nairobi, and thousands more were hurt. Ahmed Khalfan Ghailani, a young Tanzanian born in Zanzibar in April 1974, who spoke Swahili and English, was indicted in New York four months later as one of the conspirators. He was not caught for almost six years, and when he finally came to trial in 2010 it was as the first prisoner from the U.S. detention camp at Guantanamo Bay to face a jury in an American civilian court.
On November 17, 2010, the jury in Manhattan convicted Ghailani on one count, conspiring to destroy United States buildings and property, and found that his conduct had directly or proximately caused the death of a person other than a conspirator. It acquitted him on all the other counts against him, among them a count of murder for every one of the 224 dead. He has never been convicted of murder. On the single count that remained, the trial judge sentenced him to life imprisonment in January 2011, and the Second Circuit upheld the conviction and the sentence in 2013. In the years between his capture and his trial he had been held by the Central Intelligence Agency at secret sites abroad and then at Guantanamo, and that history shaped almost every ruling in the case, from the witness the jury never heard to the appeal that asked whether five years in custody without trial had violated his constitutional right to a speedy one.
The two attacks came on the same morning. In Nairobi, 213 people were killed and about 4,000 were injured. In Dar es Salaam, 11 people were killed and 85 were injured. Every one of the dead in Dar es Salaam was African. Twelve Americans were among those killed in Nairobi.
The case in New York would be brought in the name of all 224, and it would treat the two attacks as a single conspiracy. In the Second Circuit's later summary, Ghailani was one of the men recruited into what the court called the "East Africa crew," a logistics team that prepared the attack in Dar es Salaam; the court placed three other men in the same crew. Its account of his part, drawn from the evidence at trial, was that he had helped prepare that attack and had left the region shortly before it took place.
On December 16, 1998, a federal grand jury in the Southern District of New York indicted Ghailani and three co-conspirators over the attacks. He was already gone. The day before the attacks, the appeals court later found, he had left East Africa for Karachi, Pakistan, traveling with senior al Qaeda figures. For roughly six years after that he stayed out of reach.
The prosecution went on without him. Co-conspirators who had been caught were tried in the same Manhattan courthouse in 2001, convicted and sentenced to life in prison. In the same year, a superseding indictment charged Ghailani with conspiring with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda and with murder for each of the 224 people killed in Tanzania and Kenya. That indictment, with its hundreds of counts, would be the one he eventually faced.
Ghailani was captured in Pakistan on July 25, 2004. He was not brought before a court. Instead the Central Intelligence Agency took him into its own program and held him outside the United States for about two years. The appeals court later described the program as one that used "standard" and "enhanced" interrogation techniques, and the trial court found that it had been effective in getting intelligence from him. His lawyers said he had been tortured, and much of what was done to him during those two years has stayed secret. The government's reason for holding him this way was national security: the decision to put him in the CIA program, the appeals court wrote, was made in the reasonable belief that he had information essential to combating al Qaeda.
In September 2006 the CIA handed him over to the Department of Defense, and he was taken to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. In March 2007 a Combatant Status Review Tribunal confirmed his status as an enemy combatant. In 2008 the government charged him before a military commission, with counts that included murder in violation of the laws of war, terrorism and conspiracy to commit terrorism, and referred the case for trial that October. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty.
The commission case never reached trial. In January 2009 the new president suspended the military commissions by executive order, and Ghailani's case stopped where it stood. In March 2009, in a petition he filed himself in the Southern District of New York, he asserted his right to a speedy trial for the first time.
In May 2009 the Attorney General directed that Ghailani be brought to the United States and tried in federal court on the indictment that had been waiting for him since 1998. On June 9, 2009, U.S. Marshals took him from his military jailers and brought him to Manhattan, where he was held in federal custody. He appeared in federal court the same day, was arraigned, and pleaded not guilty. He was the first detainee from Guantanamo to be transferred into the civilian court system for trial.
The move was a test of a larger policy. The new administration wanted to close the camp at Guantanamo and to try some of its prisoners in ordinary federal courts. In October 2009 the government said it would not seek the death penalty.
Before trial, Ghailani's lawyers moved to dismiss the indictment altogether. Nearly five years had passed between his capture in July 2004 and his arraignment in June 2009, and they argued that the delay had violated the Sixth Amendment's guarantee of a speedy trial. The trial court denied the motion in an opinion dated July 13, 2010.
The court divided the delay into two parts. The roughly two years in CIA custody, from July 2004 to September 2006, it found justified by the government's national security interest. The period at Guantanamo, from September 2006 to June 2009, it treated differently. That delay had come from the government's preparation of a military commission case under a new and untested legal system, with foreign witnesses and evidence, and the court found no bad faith in it. But it still counted against the government. Weighing everything, the court held that the Constitution had not been violated, and the case went forward.
The most consequential ruling of the case came on the eve of trial. Prosecutors planned to call a Tanzanian man as a central witness. The government had learned of him from Ghailani himself, during interrogation at a secret CIA site overseas, and the witness was expected to testify against him about his part in the preparations in Dar es Salaam. The defense argued that his testimony was the product of coercion and should be excluded.
On October 6, 2010, the trial judge agreed. He barred the witness from testifying, holding that the government had not shown that his testimony was sufficiently separated from Ghailani's coerced statements. His written opinion explained the reasoning. The government could not coerce a detainee into giving intelligence and then use the resulting evidence, or evidence closely tied to it, in a criminal prosecution. Prosecutors had not shown that the interrogation played no part in the witness's cooperation, and the judge did not find the witness credible about his own motives, concluding that his main reason for testifying was to avoid prosecution himself. The opinion did not decide whether the CIA's methods were constitutional, a question the judge said was not before him.
Prosecutors did not appeal the ruling, and on October 12, 2010, they opened their case without the witness.
The trial ran for about four weeks in federal court in Manhattan. The government's case was that Ghailani had played an integral part in the attack in Dar es Salaam and had then fled with the leaders of the plot. The defense case was that he had not understood what he was helping with, and it denied that he had taken the flight to Karachi the day before the attacks. The question for the jury, in the end, was what Ghailani had known.
That question shaped the judge's instructions. The court told the jury that it could find the required knowledge if Ghailani had consciously avoided learning what he otherwise would have known, an instruction known as conscious avoidance. The instruction would become one of the three grounds of his appeal.
The jury deliberated for about a week. On November 17, 2010, it returned its verdict. Ghailani was found guilty on one count, conspiring to destroy United States buildings and property. The jury also made a special finding that his conduct had directly or proximately caused the death of a person other than a conspirator. On all the other counts, including the murder counts, one for each person killed, and the counts of attempted murder and further conspiracy, it found him not guilty. The single conviction carried a mandatory minimum of 20 years in prison and a maximum of life.
The defense asked the trial court to acquit Ghailani outright or order a new trial, arguing among other things that the one conviction could not logically stand beside the acquittals on charges arising from the same attacks. The court ruled against the defense on January 21, 2011.
On January 25, 2011, the court sentenced Ghailani to life in prison without the possibility of parole and ordered restitution of nearly $34 million. In passing it, the court relied on the gravity of the offense and on the 224 deaths, and it said its findings on certain disputed out-of-court statements did not affect the result. The sentence fell within the federal sentencing guidelines range. Ghailani was 36.
Ghailani's appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit raised three issues: the speedy trial claim, the conscious avoidance instruction and the reasonableness of the life sentence. A three-judge panel rejected all three on October 24, 2013.
On the speedy trial claim, the panel agreed with the trial court that the CIA period was justified and that the Guantanamo period weighed against the government but without bad faith. Ghailani's late assertion of the right, the panel said, did not cut one way or the other. The harm he said he had suffered in CIA custody was not the kind of prejudice the Speedy Trial Clause protects against, because it came from the interrogation, not from the delay in bringing him to trial. His other claims of prejudice the panel found either unsupported, not caused by the delay or not raised in the trial court.
On the jury instruction, the panel held that the evidence supported giving a conscious avoidance charge and that its wording was not plain error. On the sentence, it held that life imprisonment was neither procedurally nor substantively unreasonable. The trial court had not erred by declining to hold a separate evidentiary hearing on the disputed hearsay, and it had not been required to compare his sentence with those given to his co-defendants. The judgment was affirmed.
The litigation did not end there. A later appeal in the Second Circuit was decided on July 27, 2017, and rehearing was denied that October. Ghailani asked the Supreme Court to review that decision, and on October 1, 2018, it declined.
In March 2011 Ghailani was assigned to a federal penitentiary in Colorado, outside the highest-security unit of the federal complex there. By 2017 he was held in a maximum-security federal facility in the same state and was subject to special administrative measures, restrictions the government imposes on some prisoners because of past terrorist activity and connections, which limited his contact with the outside world.
Ghailani challenged those restrictions in a lawsuit he filed himself, arguing that they violated the Constitution and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and asking in particular to be allowed to take part in weekly Friday group prayer. The trial court dismissed the suit. While his appeal was pending, the government let the special measures expire, but he remained barred from group prayer under the facility's housing rules. On June 21, 2017, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit held the claims about the special measures moot and sent the group prayer claim back for further proceedings. As of that ruling, he was serving his life sentence in Colorado.
The verdict itself is the plainest limit on what can be said about Ghailani. A jury acquitted him of murder, of attempted murder and of the wider conspiracy counts. He stands convicted of one conspiracy count, with a finding that his conduct caused a death. Accounts of the number of acquittals differ: most reports of the verdict give 284, the Second Circuit's opinion refers to 281 other counts, and an Associated Press report in 2013 to 280.
His treatment in CIA custody was never fully set out in public. His lawyers said he was tortured; the government acknowledged that the CIA program used enhanced interrogation techniques. No court ruled on whether what was done to him was lawful. The trial judge said that question was not before him, and the appeals court held only that the harm was not caused by the delay in trying him.
Prosecutors' allegations about his activities with al Qaeda after 1998 were never tested at trial. The defense denied that he took the flight to Karachi on the eve of the attacks, though the appeals court later described that journey as part of the background of the case. The excluded witness never testified, and what he might have said was never tested before a jury.
April 1974: Ahmed Khalfan Ghailani is born in Zanzibar, Tanzania.
August 6, 1998: He leaves East Africa for Karachi, Pakistan.
August 7, 1998: The U.S. embassies in Dar es Salaam and Nairobi are attacked; 224 people are killed, 11 in Dar es Salaam and 213 in Nairobi.
December 16, 1998: A federal grand jury in the Southern District of New York indicts him and three co-conspirators.
2001: Co-conspirators are tried and convicted in the same court; a superseding indictment charges him with murder for each of the 224 dead.
July 25, 2004: He is captured in Pakistan and taken into CIA custody.
September 2006: He is transferred to Department of Defense custody at Guantanamo Bay.
March 2007: A Combatant Status Review Tribunal confirms his enemy combatant status.
March 2008: The government announces military commission charges.
October 2008: Charges are referred for trial by military commission.
January 2009: The military commissions are suspended by executive order.
March 2009: He first asserts his right to a speedy trial.
May 2009: The government announces he will be tried in federal court in New York.
June 9, 2009: He is brought to Manhattan, arraigned and pleads not guilty.
October 2009: The government says it will not seek the death penalty.
July 13, 2010: The trial court denies his speedy trial motion.
October 6, 2010: The trial judge bars a key prosecution witness.
October 12, 2010: The trial opens.
November 17, 2010: The jury convicts him on one conspiracy count, with a special finding of a death, and acquits him on all other counts, including every murder count.
January 25, 2011: He is sentenced to life imprisonment and ordered to pay nearly $34 million in restitution.
March 2011: He is assigned to a federal penitentiary in Colorado.
October 24, 2013: The Second Circuit affirms his conviction and sentence.
June 21, 2017: The Tenth Circuit sends his group prayer claim back for further proceedings.
July 27, 2017: The Second Circuit decides a later appeal in his case.
October 1, 2018: The Supreme Court declines to review a later Second Circuit decision in his case.