Ahmad Obeidi

Victims
1 sister murdered in Hamburg, 2008. Convicted of murder by the Hamburg Regional Court, February 13, 2009; life imprisonment
Years active
May 15, 2008
Location
St. Georg, Hamburg, Germany (killing); Hamburg, Germany (trial)
Method
Stabbed (court finding)
Status
Convicted of murder (base motives and treachery). Defense announced an appeal on points of law. Sentenced to life imprisonment in Hamburg, Germany, February 13, 2009.

On the night of May 15, 2008, Ahmad Obeidi killed his younger sister in the St. Georg district of Hamburg. He was 23, a German citizen born in Kabul, and already classed by the authorities as a repeat offender with convictions for violence. His sister was still a minor. Nine months later the Hamburg Regional Court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

The trial turned on a single question. The defense called it an act of sudden emotion; the prosecution charged murder committed by treachery and out of base motives. The chamber found murder.

His record with the courts began long before 2008. He was prosecuted for assaulting his sister and other people, and a court sentenced him to one year and five months' imprisonment without probation for those assaults.

She died on the night of May 15. He was taken into custody and admitted to police that he had killed her.

The Hamburg public prosecutor's office charged him with murder, and the case came before the 21st Grand Criminal Chamber of the Hamburg Regional Court in January 2009. Ahmad Obeidi stayed silent through the hearing of evidence. Relying on the assessment of a psychiatric expert appointed by the court, the defense asked the chamber to convict him of manslaughter (Totschlag) rather than murder and to order his placement in a psychiatric hospital. The prosecution asked for a murder conviction. In his final statement he told the court that he had not wanted to kill his sister and that he regretted what had happened.

On February 13, 2009, the chamber convicted him of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment, rejecting both the manslaughter verdict and the psychiatric placement. The court found that he had intended to kill, that the killing was premeditated, and that it met two of the qualifying features of murder under the German Criminal Code: treachery (Heimtücke) and base motives (niedrige Beweggründe). It found that he had killed her because she refused to live by the rules his family set for her and wanted to live as other girls in Germany lived, named wounded "honor" as the motive, and recorded that she had endured years of threats and assaults from her brother before her death.

On the day of the verdict, the defense announced that it would appeal on points of law (Revision) to the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof).

Whether the killing should be called an "honor" killing at all was argued in public around the trial. Shortly before the verdict, some press coverage held that the case grew out of a long-running conflict between brother and sister rather than out of any idea of family honor. The court found otherwise and named wounded "honor" as the motive.

The defense's account of a sudden, emotion-driven act, supported by the court-appointed expert, was rejected by the chamber, which found intent and premeditation.

Timeline

Before May 2008: Ahmad Obeidi is sentenced in Hamburg to one year and five months without probation for assaults on his sister and others.

May 15, 2008: He kills his younger sister in the St. Georg district of Hamburg.

May 2008: He is taken into custody and admits the killing to police.

January 2009: His murder trial is under way before the 21st Grand Criminal Chamber of the Hamburg Regional Court.

February 13, 2009: The chamber convicts him of murder, finding treachery and base motives, and sentences him to life imprisonment; the defense announces an appeal on points of law.