Ahmad Ajaj

Victims
6 people killed in the 1993 World Trade Center attack. Convicted on all ten federal counts against him, March 4, 1994.
Years active
February 26, 1993
Location
New York, New York (killings and trial); Houston, Texas (residence)
Method
Bombing; he was in custody when it took place and was convicted as a conspirator
Status
240 years, May 24, 1994; resentenced to 1,378 months, affirmed 2001; 30 years cut by February 2021. In federal custody as of February 2021.

Ahmad Mohammad Ajaj was locked up in a federal facility on a passport conviction when the World Trade Center was attacked on February 26, 1993. Six people died and more than a thousand were hurt. He had been in custody for almost six months by then, and he would argue for years afterward that a man behind bars could not have been part of what happened that day. The jury did not accept it. On March 4, 1994, after a months-long trial in Manhattan, Ajaj and three codefendants were found guilty on every count against them.

The courts that reviewed the case reached the same view of his place in it. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit found that Ajaj and Ramzi Ahmed Yousef had planned the attack together overseas in 1992, that Ajaj had entered the country beside Yousef, and that he had kept in touch with Yousef from custody while the plan went forward. In 2001 the same court called the finding that he was one of the conspiracy's architects well supported. Ajaj was sentenced to 240 years in 1994, resentenced to 1,378 months after a first appeal, and had 30 years cut from that term by February 2021. Apart from about a week in March 1993, he had been held from September 1992 onward, and as of February 2021 he remained in federal custody.

Houston and the asylum claim

Ajaj is Palestinian. He first entered the United States on September 9, 1991, and settled in Houston, Texas. There he applied for political asylum, telling immigration officials that the Israeli government had imprisoned him for opposing the occupation. The claim was never heard. He did not appear for his asylum hearing before the Immigration and Naturalization Service.

On April 24, 1992, he left Houston for the Middle East under an assumed name, and with a letter of introduction he attended a training camp on the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. There, in the spring of 1992, he met Yousef, and the two of them, the Second Circuit later found, hatched the plot to attack targets in the United States.

The arrival at Kennedy Airport

Ajaj and Yousef prepared to come to New York together under false identities, and they took care to hide the fact that they were traveling as a pair.

They landed at John F. Kennedy International Airport on September 1, 1992. Ajaj presented a Swedish passport in the name of Khurram Khan. An immigration inspector found it suspicious, confirmed that it had been altered, and sent him to secondary inspection. Officers took materials and false identification documents from his luggage, and immigration officers arrested him. He was detained as a danger to the United States.

Yousef stood at the next counter and gave no sign that he knew him. Ajaj told the inspectors he was traveling alone. Yousef presented an Iraqi passport, asked for political asylum, was arrested for entering without a visa and was released on his own recognizance. The Second Circuit later treated Ajaj's denial of his companion at the airport as part of the proof against him, because the government argued that it helped Yousef walk into the country.

The passport case

Federal prosecutors in Brooklyn charged Ajaj with passport fraud in the Eastern District of New York. On October 6, 1992, he pleaded guilty to one count of using another person's passport. A second passport count was to be dismissed at sentencing. His written plea agreement bound only the United States Attorney's Office for the Eastern District, but in court his lawyer stated an oral addition: the government would bring no charges arising from his September 1 entry or from the items he had carried. He was sentenced to six months in custody. The judge in that case ordered the government either to return his belongings or to explain why it had not.

The belongings never went back to him. In December 1992 he was served with a grand jury subpoena in the Eastern District for many of the seized materials, tied to a joint terrorism investigation by the FBI and the New York City Police Department.

Contact from custody

Ajaj had been incarcerated since September 2, 1992. He did not call Yousef directly at first. He called a friend in Texas, who passed on messages or connected three-way calls, and Yousef placed calls of his own to Ajaj's lawyer in New York and to the same friend beginning in December 1992. On December 29, 1992, a call from Ajaj was transferred to Yousef and the two men spoke directly about the belongings that had been taken from him at the airport. The Second Circuit found that Ajaj stayed informed about the conspirators' progress through these contacts and tried to get the seized materials to Yousef, and that the two men spoke in code about the plan because they knew the calls were monitored.

He finished his passport sentence and was released on March 1, 1993, three days after the attack. About a week later, on March 9, he was taken back into government custody on an immigration detainer, and he remained in custody from then on.

The attack came on February 26, 1993, beneath the World Trade Center complex in lower Manhattan. Six people were killed and more than a thousand were injured, the property loss exceeded $500 million, and the attack caused widespread fear. Yousef left the United States for Pakistan within hours.

The six who died

John DiGiovanni was born in Brooklyn and lived in Valley Stream, on Long Island, with his mother. Friends remembered a meticulous man who once detailed his car with a toothbrush.

Robert Kirkpatrick lived in Suffern, New York, with his wife. He was handy with carpentry, plumbing and locks.

Stephen Knapp was born on Staten Island and lived there with his wife and their two children. He liked time with family and friends, fishing from his boat, an afternoon at the racetrack and a ballgame.

William Macko lived in Bayonne, New Jersey, with his wife and their four children. He liked to fish and to cook.

Wilfredo Mercado lived in the East New York section of Brooklyn with his wife and their two daughters.

Monica Rodriguez Smith lived in Seaford, on Long Island, with her husband.

The investigation

The FBI took over the inquiry from the Port Authority police within days. Within weeks three men, Mohammed Salameh, Nidal Ayyad and Mahmud Abouhalima, had been arrested; all three were later convicted with Ajaj. Yousef and a second conspirator were still fugitives at the time of trial, and Yousef was later convicted at a separate trial.

The investigation also reached back to the September 1992 arrest at Kennedy Airport. The materials seized from Ajaj's luggage, and held ever since under the Eastern District subpoena, were brought into the inquiry, and prosecutors argued that they tied him and Yousef to the attack. In September 1993, a grand jury in the Southern District of New York returned the indictment on which Ajaj and the other three men were tried.

The charges

Ajaj faced ten counts. Count One charged a conspiracy to attack buildings and vehicles used in interstate commerce and federal property. Counts Two through Six charged the attack on the World Trade Center itself and its effects on federal offices and on vehicles in and near the complex. Count Seven, which named Ajaj alone, charged him under the Travel Act with traveling in foreign commerce to promote crimes of violence. Count Eight charged assault on federal officers, and Counts Nine and Ten were two further federal counts tied to the attack.

None of the ten was a murder count. The deaths of the six victims entered the case through the sentencing guidelines, and later through the way the trial judge built the sentence.

The trial

The joint trial of Salameh, Ayyad, Abouhalima and Ajaj opened in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York on October 4, 1993. The Second Circuit later described it as a six-month trial, while reporting at sentencing called it a five-month trial. More than 200 witnesses testified and more than 1,000 exhibits went to the jury.

The case against Ajaj rested on what he had done before he was arrested and what he did afterward from custody. The Second Circuit later summarized it: his travel to the Middle East under an alias to attend the camp, and the letter of introduction that got him there; his contact with Yousef abroad and their joint plan to enter the United States illegally; the false identities and the altered Swedish passport assigned to him so that he could carry the materials; the materials themselves, including handwritten notes the government said were his; the lie he told the inspector at Kennedy Airport; and his continued contact with Yousef while he was jailed.

Throughout, Ajaj maintained that he had nothing to do with the attack.

Verdict and sentence

On March 4, 1994, the jury found all four men guilty on every count. Ajaj was convicted on all ten counts against him.

By the time of sentencing all four had dismissed their trial lawyers, and they represented themselves at the hearing on May 24, 1994. Ajaj again denied any part in the attack, and he spent most of his statement on the suffering of Palestinians.

The trial judge sentenced each of the four to 240 years without parole. He arrived at the figure by working out, from actuarial tables, how many more years each of the six victims could have expected to live. The total came to 180 years. He added 30 years on each of two further counts to reach 240.

The first appeal

The Second Circuit heard the four appeals together and decided them on August 4, 1998. Ajaj raised more issues than any of the others, and the court rejected each one that went to his conviction.

He argued that the materials seized at Kennedy Airport should have been suppressed because the Eastern District subpoena had been misused to hold them for the attack inquiry. The court found that the subpoena had a proper dominant purpose, that the Southern District grand jury had conducted a wholly independent investigation into terrorist activity, and that Ajaj failed to present any proof that the government misused the subpoena. He argued that his Brooklyn plea agreement barred the Manhattan prosecution. The court held that the written agreement was expressly limited to the Eastern District office, that nothing showed the parties meant it to reach further, and that the Southern District had investigated the attack on its own and charged different crimes.

He challenged the admission of the government's expert testimony about the materials, and the court found that neither of his arguments had merit. He challenged the jury charge on the essential nature of the plan, the charge on vicarious liability for crimes committed by coconspirators, and the judge's failure to tell the jury, without being asked, that imprisonment could amount to withdrawal from a conspiracy. On the last point the court agreed with him in principle: whether an imprisonment constitutes withdrawal from a conspiracy, it held, must be decided by the jury. But Ajaj had offered no other evidence of withdrawal, the government had proved his continuing contact with Yousef while he was jailed, and the failure to give the instruction was not plain error.

The court found ample evidence that Ajaj had agreed to the essential nature of the conspiracy, upheld the Travel Act count on the strength of his journey from Pakistan with the materials and his denial of Yousef at the airport, and rejected his claims of prosecutorial misconduct. His motion for a new trial and his claims that his lawyer had been ineffective were sent back to the trial judge to decide first.

The convictions stood. The sentences did not. All four men had represented themselves at the May 1994 hearing without a valid waiver of their right to counsel, the government did not oppose vacating the sentences, and the court sent the case back for resentencing.

Resentencing and the second appeal

On remand the trial judge resentenced the four men to terms meant to end a month before each man's own life expectancy, which varied with his age, followed by two consecutive 30-year terms on Counts Nine and Ten. Ajaj received 1,378 months, about 114 years and 10 months. Each defendant was also ordered to pay a $250,000 fine and $250 million in restitution.

The Second Circuit decided the appeal from the new sentences on August 6, 2001. It held that any error in the life expectancy calculations was harmless because the defendants had no right to avoid a sentence that was tantamount to life imprisonment. It upheld the consecutive 30-year terms. It held that the trial judge had properly applied the sentencing guideline for first-degree murder.

Ajaj argued that his role was too remote for the murder guideline, that he deserved a reduction as a minor or minimal participant, that he should have received a downward departure, and that his sentence was out of proportion to what he had done. The court rejected each argument. Measured against his coconspirators, it held, he was not a minor or minimal participant, and the earlier finding that he was one of the conspiracy's architects enjoyed solid support in the evidence. The court did modify the financial penalties: because the four men were indigent, the fines and restitution would fall due only if they earned money from accounts of the attack.

Two decades later, the sentences changed again. Following a ruling of the United States Supreme Court, one part of the convictions of each of the four men was dropped, and each won a reduction in his sentence. For Ajaj the reduction was 30 years. In February 2021, at 55, he could be freed at 96 if he lived that long. In a court filing the year before, he had described chronic health problems, including cancer, the removal of his left lung and a severe spinal disorder.

Disputed and unproven points

Ajaj has always denied any part in the attack. He was in custody from September 2, 1992, through the day it took place, and his appeals argued that his imprisonment amounted to withdrawal from the conspiracy and that his role was too remote to support the sentence. The jury convicted him on every count, and the Second Circuit upheld the convictions in 1998 and his sentence in 2001.

Count Seven, the Travel Act charge, rested in part on his denial at Kennedy Airport that he was traveling with Yousef; the government argued that the denial helped Yousef enter the country, and the court accepted that the evidence supported the count.

Timeline

September 9, 1991: Ajaj first enters the United States and settles in Houston, Texas, where he applies for political asylum.

April 24, 1992: He leaves Houston for the Middle East under an assumed name.

Spring 1992: He meets Ramzi Ahmed Yousef at a training camp on the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

September 1, 1992: Ajaj and Yousef arrive at Kennedy Airport; Ajaj is arrested on an altered Swedish passport.

October 6, 1992: He pleads guilty in the Eastern District of New York to using another person's passport and is later sentenced to six months.

December 29, 1992: A call from Ajaj is transferred to Yousef.

February 26, 1993: The World Trade Center is attacked; six people are killed and more than a thousand injured.

March 1, 1993: Ajaj completes his passport sentence.

March 9, 1993: Ajaj is taken back into custody on an immigration detainer.

September 1993: The Southern District of New York indictment is returned.

October 4, 1993: The joint trial of Ajaj, Salameh, Ayyad and Abouhalima opens.

March 4, 1994: The jury convicts all four on every count.

May 24, 1994: Each is sentenced to 240 years.

August 4, 1998: The Second Circuit affirms the convictions and vacates the sentences.

August 6, 2001: The Second Circuit affirms the new sentences, Ajaj's at 1,378 months, as modified.

February 2021: Ajaj's sentence has been cut by 30 years; as of that month he remained in federal custody.