Adrian Bayley

Victims
1 murder, Brunswick, Victoria, 2012, by guilty plea. Also convicted of rape on many counts, 1991 to 2015; one rape conviction from 2014 was quashed on appeal in 2016.
Years active
September 22, 2012
Location
Brunswick, Victoria, Australia (killing); Coburg, Victoria, Australia (residence); Melbourne, Victoria, Australia (courts)
Method
Strangled, by his own admission at his June 2013 plea hearing; murder and rape under Victorian law.
Status
Life plus 15 years concurrent, 35-year minimum (June 19, 2013); appeal dismissed 2013; minimum raised to 43 years (2015), cut to 40 (2016). Serving life in Victoria as of July 2016.

On September 22, 2012, Adrian Ernest Bayley, a 41-year-old man from the Melbourne suburb of Coburg, raped and murdered Jill Meagher in Brunswick, the Melbourne suburb where she lived. She had come to Australia from Ireland about three years before, and she and Bayley had never met. Within a week he stood in the Melbourne Magistrates' Court charged with her rape and murder. In April 2013 he pleaded guilty to both, and the Supreme Court of Victoria sentenced him that June to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 35 years before he could be considered for parole.

The plea ended the case over her death, but it did not end the questions about how he came to be free that night. When it happened he was a parolee and a man on bail at the same time. He had been convicted of rape and attempted rape in 1991, of 16 counts of rape against five women in 2002, and in February 2012 of recklessly causing serious injury to a man in Geelong, a sentence he was appealing on bail; he had been released on parole in 2010, and his parole was never cancelled. A review of the state's parole system commissioned after the murder found that the Adult Parole Board had both the cause and the opportunity to cancel it before September 2012.

At his plea hearing Bayley admitted that he had gone through a sexual-offender rehabilitation program in the 1990s only to win parole, telling the program what he believed it wanted to hear.

Victoria Police arrested him in the last days of September 2012, after the inquiry linked him to the case by evidence, and on Friday, September 28, he appeared at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court charged with her rape and murder. He was remanded in custody. At first he meant to fight. When his committal hearing opened on March 12, 2013, he pleaded guilty to one count of rape and not guilty to murder and to two further counts of rape, and the case went up to the Supreme Court.

The contest he had signaled never came. On Friday, April 5, 2013, at an appearance in the Supreme Court earlier than expected, Bayley pleaded guilty to one count of rape and one count of murder. There would be no trial over her death.

On Wednesday, June 19, 2013, the Supreme Court sentenced him to life imprisonment for the murder and 15 years for the rape, and fixed a non-parole period of 35 years. The court treated the guilty plea as showing a small degree of genuine remorse and said that without it no minimum term would have been set; it treated as aggravating the fact that he had been on parole and on bail when he offended. Bayley sought leave to appeal against the sentence and asked for seven years off the minimum. In September 2013 the Court of Appeal dismissed the application, and in reasons published on October 21, 2013, it found the 35-year minimum within the range open to the sentencing judge and rejected the argument that his sentence should be measured against those of other offenders.

The murder plea did not close every charge against him. Beginning in July 2014, Bayley stood trial three times before juries in the County Court of Victoria over rapes in St Kilda. He pleaded not guilty each time, and each jury convicted him. The first trial concerned the rape of a woman in 2000; the second and third, both held in March 2015, concerned the rape of a second woman in April 2012 and of a third in July 2012, two months before the murder in Brunswick. On Thursday, May 28, 2015, the County Court sentenced him to 18 years in total for the three rapes, to be served concurrently with his life sentence, and extended his non-parole period by eight years, from 35 to 43. The court found that he had shown no remorse for any of the three offenses. On that sentence he would not be eligible for parole until 2056.

He appealed against two of the three verdicts, and in July 2016 the Court of Appeal gave judgment. On the 2000 case he won. The complainant had identified him after seeing his photograph online in connection with the murder, twelve years after the events she described. The court held that the identification evidence should not have gone before the jury, because its value as proof was outweighed by its unfair prejudice, and that without it there was no evidence on which a jury could have found him guilty. The conviction was quashed and he was acquitted on that indictment. On the July 2012 case the appeal was dismissed: the court held that the evidence challenged at trial had been relevant and that the jury had other evidence on which it could convict. An appeal against the sentence on one of the 2012 convictions also failed. With the 2000 verdict gone, the court cut his non-parole period by three years, from 43 to 40, which put his earliest parole eligibility in 2055.

As of July 2016 Bayley was serving life imprisonment in Victoria, with a non-parole period of 40 years.

Bayley's conviction for the 2000 offenses in St Kilda was quashed in July 2016 and an acquittal entered; those offenses are not convictions. He pleaded guilty to only one of the three rape counts first laid over the events of September 2012, together with the murder. What became of the two remaining counts is not known.

Timeline

June 1991: Jailed for five years, with a three-year minimum, on six charges including rape and attempted rape.

April 2002: Jailed for 11 years, with a minimum of eight, on 16 counts of rape against five women.

2010: Released on parole.

February 2012: Convicted of recklessly causing serious injury and sentenced to three months' jail; appeals the sentence and is bailed. His parole is not cancelled.

April 2012 and July 2012: Rapes in St Kilda for which juries later convict him.

September 22, 2012: Rape and murder in Brunswick, Victoria.

September 28, 2012: Appears at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court charged with rape and murder.

March 12, 2013: Pleads guilty to one count of rape and not guilty to murder and two further rape counts.

April 5, 2013: Pleads guilty in the Supreme Court of Victoria to one count of rape and one count of murder.

June 19, 2013: Sentenced to life imprisonment for murder and 15 years for rape, with a non-parole period of 35 years.

September 2013: The Court of Appeal dismisses his application against sentence; reasons follow on October 21, 2013.

July 2014: Convicted by a County Court jury of a 2000 rape in St Kilda (quashed in 2016).

March 2015: Convicted in two further County Court trials of rapes in St Kilda in April and July 2012.

May 28, 2015: Sentenced to 18 years concurrent; non-parole period extended to 43 years.

July 2016: The Court of Appeal quashes the 2000 conviction, dismisses his other appeals and reduces the non-parole period to 40 years.