Adolf Wahlmann

Victims
Over 400 Polish and Soviet laborers killed at Hadamar, 1944-1945. Found guilty by a US military commission, 1945; sentenced to death in Frankfurt, 1947, over German patients
Years active
August 1942 to March 1945; Hadamar, Germany
Location
Hadamar; Wiesbaden; Frankfurt am Main; Koblenz-Ehrenbreitstein; Michelfeld (Germany)
Method
Aiding, abetting and participating in the killing of Polish and Russian nationals as chief physician at Hadamar; the killing of German patients (Frankfurt)
Status
Life imprisonment (Wiesbaden, 1945); death sentence (Frankfurt, 1947) converted to a penitentiary term; pardoned and released 1953; died 1956

Adolf Wahlmann was a veteran psychiatrist of the regional asylum service when, in August 1942, he took charge of the state institution at Hadamar, a town in the Hesse-Nassau region of western Germany. From then until American troops arrived in March 1945 he was its chief physician and its only doctor. In those years Hadamar became a place where people were sent to be killed: German patients from across the Reich and, from the summer of 1944, Polish and Soviet forced laborers.

Two courts tried him. In October 1945 a United States military commission sitting at Wiesbaden found him guilty of a violation of international law in the killing of Polish and Russian nationals, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. In 1947 the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main, a German court, tried him for the killing of the German patients and sentenced him to death. That sentence was never carried out. It was converted to a term in the penitentiary, and in 1953 he was pardoned and released. He died in 1956.

Wahlmann was born in 1876 in Ehrenbreitstein, a district of Koblenz on the Rhine. He studied medicine, qualified to practice and trained as a psychiatrist, and he spent his working life in the state asylum service of Hesse-Nassau. He knew Hadamar long before the war: he worked there from 1908 to 1911, in the years when it was a small regional institution.

He joined the Nazi Party in 1933 and the SS in 1934. In September 1933 he returned to Hadamar as senior physician. In 1936 he was placed on leave. Four years later, in 1940, he was reinstated at another of the region's state institutions, one that served as an intermediate institution for the central killing program known as T4.

The first phase of killing at Hadamar belonged to T4 and ended in August 1941, when the central program was halted. A year later, in August 1942, the staff at Hadamar began killing again. This second phase was not run from Berlin. Responsibility lay largely with the state and regional administrations, which acted without central instructions, and the medical staff on site chose the victims. In Hesse-Nassau a central figure in the regional administration was an official of the district administration.

Wahlmann was transferred to Hadamar in August 1942, the month the killing resumed, and became its chief physician and medical director. Ordinary hospital routine was kept up on the surface. Each day the nurses on the wards reported to him, and decisions on which patients were to die were made by Wahlmann together with his chief nurses.

A member of the staff later described the daily rhythm of the place in a written statement. Wahlmann, he said, was the physician in charge of Hadamar and conducted all medical treatment in the institution. Every morning he held a conference with the chief male nurse, Heinrich Ruoff, and the chief female nurse, Irmgard Huber. When the district official came to Hadamar, which he did often, he held conferences with Wahlmann and with the institution's chief administrative officer, Alfons Klein.

The people brought to Hadamar in these years came from all over the German Reich and from the occupied countries, chiefly Poland and the Soviet Union. Many were transferred from regions exposed to bombing.

The case that brought Wahlmann before an American court concerned a single group among the dead: men, women and children of Polish and Soviet nationality who had been deported to Germany for forced labor and who were sent to Hadamar from the summer of 1944. Before the first of them arrived, Wahlmann attended a conference with a district official and Klein at which it was decided that they would be killed as the German patients were being killed.

They began to arrive in the summer of 1944. The charge against the Hadamar staff covered the period from about July 1, 1944, to about April 1, 1945. Most were killed within hours or days of arrival. The commission's evidence put their number at 476. Policy was set in the regional administration, and the orders to kill reached the wards through Klein.

As the one doctor on the staff, Wahlmann entered a stated cause of death on each patient's hospital card and signed the death certificate. The certificates were signed at the daily morning conferences with the chief nurses, and at those same meetings the next deaths were planned.

The officials who directed and carried out the killings maintained that they had been justified. The commission found that the evidence did not support that claim.

American troops reached Hadamar in late March 1945. Soldiers of the 2nd Infantry Division secured the institution on March 29 after townspeople alerted them, and some 550 people still living there were freed.

A US Army war crimes investigation began at once. The members of the institution's management still on site, Wahlmann among them, were taken into custody and questioned, witnesses were interviewed and records were seized. Investigators drew on the staff's own files, on interrogations of the staff, on former inmates and on people from the town.

The case was tried as United States of America v. Alfons Klein et al. before a military commission at Wiesbaden from October 8 to October 15, 1945. Seven members of the Hadamar staff stood trial together. Wahlmann was the only physician among them.

The single charge was "Violation of International Law." Its specification accused the defendants of acting jointly and in pursuance of a common intent to "aid, abet, and participate in the killing of human beings of Polish and Russian nationality," in a number "in excess of 400," at Hadamar between about July 1, 1944, and about April 1, 1945. The German dead were not part of the charge.

The defense raised the arguments that would recur in the German courts. The accused pleaded that they had acted on superior orders. They pleaded that the killings were lawful under German law, pointing to an alleged decree. They pleaded coercion and necessity. The commission rejected all of these. A civilian employee who carried out an illegal order remained criminally liable for it. The existence of the decree was never established; at most an administrative order had been shown, and it would have to be read strictly. Coercion and necessity were established neither in fact nor in law.

On October 15, 1945, the commission found all seven defendants guilty. Wahlmann was sentenced to life imprisonment. Three of the accused were sentenced to death: Klein, the administrator; Ruoff, the chief male nurse; and Karl Willig, a male nurse. All three were executed in March 1946. The bookkeeper Adolf Merkle received 35 years, the doorman and cemetery keeper Philipp Blum 30 years, and Huber, the chief female nurse, 25 years.

The sentences were reviewed and confirmed by the commanding general of the Seventh Army's Western Military District. The death sentences went on for a further confirmation by the commanding general of US Forces in the European Theater; Wahlmann's life sentence did not require it. The case had been reviewed by February 1946.

Between 1946 and 1948 the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main heard four criminal trials against the staff of three institutions in the region, Hadamar among them. Forty-four people were charged in all: doctors, nurses, attendants and administrative and technical staff. The trials at first instance produced six death sentences, one life sentence, three terms of eight years and sixteen other prison terms.

Twenty-five people were charged when the Hadamar case came before the Frankfurt court in 1947. Wahlmann was tried there for the killing of the German patients at Hadamar, deaths that lay outside the Wiesbaden charge. He was sentenced to death.

None of the death sentences handed down in the four Frankfurt trials was carried out. Wahlmann's was converted to a term in the penitentiary. Across all four trials, after appeals and pardons, most of the defendants were free again by the early 1950s.

In 1953 Wahlmann was pardoned and released. He spent his last years in Baden-Württemberg and died in 1956 at Michelfeld.

The Wiesbaden commission had to settle its own authority before it could reach a verdict, and its answers shaped what Wahlmann could be tried for there. It held that a United States military commission could try civilians under the common law of war. It held that it had jurisdiction although none of the dead were American nationals, resting that finding on the universality of jurisdiction over war crimes, on the interest of the United States in crimes committed against the nationals of its allies, and on the Berlin Declaration of June 5, 1945. The victims before it had been deported from occupied territory as laborers, and the commission treated their killing as a violation of the laws and customs of war. Civilians, it held, could commit war crimes by illegal acts against enemy nationals. The charge it tried was confined to those nationals, and the German dead of Hadamar came before the German court at Frankfurt two years later.

The Wiesbaden commission's figure of 476 dead covers only the Polish and Soviet forced laborers; the German patients killed at Hadamar were outside its charge and came before the Frankfurt court.

Timeline

1876: Born in Ehrenbreitstein, Koblenz.

1908 to 1911: Works at the state institution at Hadamar.

1933: Joins the Nazi Party; in September returns to Hadamar as senior physician.

1934: Joins the SS.

1936: Placed on leave.

1940: Reinstated at another state institution in Hesse-Nassau.

August 1941: The central T4 program halted; the first phase of killing at Hadamar ends.

August 1942: Transferred to Hadamar as chief physician and medical director; killing resumes.

About July 1, 1944: Start of the period charged at Wiesbaden; Polish and Soviet forced laborers begin to arrive.

March 29, 1945: American troops secure the institution at Hadamar; Wahlmann taken into custody.

October 8 to 15, 1945: Tried at Wiesbaden with six other staff; found guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment.

March 1946: Klein, Ruoff and Willig executed.

1947: Tried by the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main for the killing of German patients; sentenced to death; sentence later converted to a penitentiary term.

1953: Pardoned and released.

1956: Dies at Michelfeld, Baden-Württemberg.