Adelaide Bartlett

Victims
1 charge of wilful murder, of her husband; found not guilty at the Central Criminal Court, London, April 1886. No conviction
Years active
1886 (the death, January 1, 1886)
Location
Pimlico, London, England (death charged at trial as a killing); Dover, Kent, England (residence, 1885); London, England (trial)
Method
Poisoning (the Crown's case at trial); the jury found her not guilty
Status
A co-accused was formally acquitted at the opening of the trial and gave evidence for the Crown. The jury found her not guilty. Acquitted at the Central Criminal Court, London, April 1886

On January 1, 1886, Thomas Edwin Bartlett died in Pimlico, in London, where he lived with his wife. Early in 1886 a coroner's jury returned a verdict of wilful murder against her and found that a young Wesleyan minister, a close friend of the couple, was an accessory before the fact. Both were arrested. When the case reached the Central Criminal Court in April, the Crown abandoned its case against the minister at the outset; he was formally acquitted and then gave evidence for the prosecution. Adelaide Bartlett stood trial alone for "the wilful murder of her husband." After about a week the jury found her not guilty, and in law that was the end of it. No one was ever convicted, and the cause of the death has no judicial answer beyond the verdict.

The woman tried in 1886 had come to England from the Continent. She had spent her childhood abroad and spoke French, and the name on her marriage certificate, Adelaide de la Tremoille, had an aristocratic ring. Her future husband's family first knew her by another name: she introduced herself to them as Blanche.

The couple first tried to marry at the parish church in Herne Hill. That attempt failed, because she was under 21 and did not have her father's permission. In April 1875 they were married instead at Croydon Parish Church. The certificate gave her age as 19. From then on she was Mrs. Adelaide Bartlett, and in the formal style of the day Mrs. Edwin Bartlett.

In 1885 a young Wesleyan minister came into the couple's lives and quickly became a fixture in them. He grew close to the husband first. By the autumn the couple had a pet name for him, "Georgius Rex," and the husband was paying his way: train fares, and a day trip across the Channel to Calais.

In September 1885 the husband rented a house on the Kent coast, at Dover, so that the couple could take a rare holiday, with their Saint Bernards. He went up to London on most weekdays and left his wife at the coast. The minister came down to stay with them two or three times that autumn, for six to nine days in all; questioned in 1886, he could not say exactly how long.

On September 20, 1885, the husband traveled from Dover to Putney to see the minister. He had made a new will. It left everything he owned to his wife, and it named the minister as one of its executors. The following week he sent a telegram and money so that his friend could come down again. The minister's reply was warm. "Dear old Dover," he wrote, "it will ever possess a pleasant memory for me."

That autumn the minister moved to new lodgings in Putney and took on fresh duties, with charge of a large parish. He also visited Mrs. Bartlett during the day while her husband was at work. In October 1885 the Bartletts took lodgings in Pimlico. It was there, three months later, that the husband died.

The death came in the first hours of January 1, 1886. It was Mrs. Bartlett who raised the alarm in the household.

The death was quickly treated as a matter for the coroner. An inquest followed in the opening weeks of the year. The coroner's jury returned a verdict of wilful murder against Adelaide Bartlett. It added a second finding, that the minister had been an accessory before the fact. Both were taken into custody. She was charged with the wilful murder of her husband, and he with being an accessory before the fact to that murder.

The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, on April 12, 1886. At once the prosecution asked that the case against the minister be dropped, and that the jury return a verdict of not guilty in his case. He was formally acquitted, and the Crown then called him as one of its own witnesses. Mrs. Bartlett was left in the dock alone. Her defense answered that the Crown had not proved murder.

The jury retired after about a week of evidence and speeches. When they came back, their foreman told the court that the jury did not think there was sufficient evidence to show how the death had been brought about or by whom. They found Adelaide Bartlett not guilty of "the wilful murder of her husband." The verdict settled her legal position, and after it she left public life.

The central point is the one the jury left open. The Crown's case at trial was that the husband had been murdered. Whether the death was murder, an accident or suicide is still argued over. The jury did not decide between them: its verdict was that guilt had not been proved. No court ever found how the death came about, and the verdict is the only judicial word on it.

The death fell either late on December 31, 1885, or in the early hours of January 1, 1886, and it is usually dated to New Year's Day.

Mrs. Bartlett's origins remain uncertain. Her parentage and her exact date and place of birth are uncertain, and more of her family background has come to light only in recent years.

Her later life is unknown. Where she went after the trial, and when and where she died, has never been established.

Timeline

April 1875: The couple married at Croydon Parish Church, after a first attempt at Herne Hill failed for want of her father's consent.

1885: A young Wesleyan minister became a close friend of the couple.

September 1885: The couple took a house at Dover, Kent, for a holiday.

September 20, 1885: The husband told the minister of a new will leaving everything to his wife and naming the minister an executor.

October 1885: The couple took lodgings in Pimlico, London.

January 1, 1886: The husband died in Pimlico.

Early 1886: A coroner's jury returned a verdict of wilful murder against Adelaide Bartlett and found the minister an accessory before the fact; both were arrested.

April 12, 1886: The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court; the Crown dropped its case against the minister, who was formally acquitted and gave evidence for the prosecution.

April 1886: After about a week, the jury found Adelaide Bartlett not guilty of "the wilful murder of her husband."