Adel Kermiche

Victims
1 death attributed by prosecutors (never tried): Father Jacques Hamel, July 26, 2016, with Abdel-Malik Petitjean; a parishioner seriously injured.
Years active
July 26, 2016
Location
Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray, Seine-Maritime, France (killing; his death); Normandy, France (birth); Paris, France (2015 case; 2022 trial of others)
Method
Throat cut with a knife (prosecutors' account; never tried).
Status
Released in March 2016 to house arrest with an electronic tag; a prosecution appeal failed. Killed by police at Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray, France, July 26, 2016 (untried).

On the morning of Tuesday, July 26, 2016, two men entered the Catholic parish church of Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray, a working-class town on the southern edge of Rouen, while a weekday Mass was being said. Within the hour the priest who was celebrating it, Father Jacques Hamel, was dead, a parishioner had been seriously injured, and both men had been killed by police at the church. The Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor named them as Adel Kermiche and Abdel-Malik Petitjean. Both were 19. The Islamic State group claimed the killing the same day.

Kermiche was a local man. He had grown up a short distance from the church, and at the time of the killing he was living in the town under a court order, wearing an electronic tag and awaiting trial for two attempts the year before to reach Syria. Investigating judges had freed him from pre-trial detention four months earlier over the objection of prosecutors, whose appeal failed. The tag let him out only within fixed hours, and the killing took place inside them.

Neither man was ever charged or tried. In death they could not be. The case that reached a courtroom, in Paris in 2022, was the case against the people around them: an Islamic State recruiter tried in his absence, who was convicted of complicity in the killing, and three young men from the attackers' circle, who were convicted of association de malfaiteurs terroriste, the French offense of belonging to a group preparing a terrorist act. The killing of the priest is therefore a matter of record through the prosecutor's findings and that later judgment, never through any verdict on Kermiche himself.

Adel Kermiche was born on March 25, 1997, in Normandy, and grew up in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray. His childhood was difficult. From about the age of six he received regular psychological care, including psychotherapy and medication until he was 13, and in adolescence he spent several periods in hospital, among them about two weeks in a psychiatric unit. When he was around 12 or 13 he was removed from his ordinary school for behavioral problems and sent to an establishment for pupils with similar difficulties. By 2016 he was unemployed.

Acquaintances dated a hardening of his religious views to 2015, the months after the January attacks on the Charlie Hebdo offices and a kosher supermarket in Paris. In March of that year he left France for the first time, aiming to reach territory held by the Islamic State group in Syria. He was stopped in Germany and returned to France, the first time French anti-terrorism officials took formal notice of him. He was charged in connection with the journey and released under judicial supervision, with an order not to leave his local area.

In May 2015 he left again and got as far as Turkey, where the authorities detained him and sent him back. The second journey ended his liberty. He was charged with association de malfaiteurs en lien avec une entreprise terroriste and placed in pre-trial detention, a young man with no criminal conviction of any kind. In the course of the investigation he told the investigating judge that he regretted trying to leave for Syria, presented himself as a Muslim who believed in mercy and in doing good, and denied being an extremist.

In March 2016, after roughly ten months in custody, the investigating judges ordered his release pending trial. He was to live in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray under house arrest, monitored by an electronic tag, with his passport surrendered. The Paris prosecutor's office opposed the release and appealed, and the appeal court upheld the judges' decision. He remained in that position, untried and under monitoring, for the four months that followed, and he was still awaiting trial on the 2015 charge when he died. In those months he ran a channel of his own on Telegram, the encrypted messaging application.

The other man in the church, Abdel-Malik Nabil Petitjean, had been born in Saint-Dié-des-Vosges, in eastern France, and had grown up in Aix-les-Bains, in Savoie, at the other end of the country. He had no police record. On June 10, 2016, Turkish authorities saw him at a Turkish airport, apparently bound for Syria; he did not reach it and returned quickly to France, where on June 29 he was added to the watch list of people regarded as a potential threat to national security. On July 22 the French counterterrorism coordination unit circulated a photograph from a foreign partner warning that the man pictured could be ready to take part in an attack. The bulletin carried no name, and only after July 26 did officials confirm that the man was Petitjean. Two days after the killing it was still unclear how he and Kermiche knew each other, but by July 24 at the latest they were together in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray.

Around them was a small circle of young men. Yassine Sebaihia crossed France to join them there on July 24 and left the following day. Jean-Philippe Steven Jean-Louis had traveled with Petitjean to Turkey in June. Farid Khelil was among those in contact with the two attackers. Above them all, prosecutors placed Rachid Kassim, a French recruiter for the Islamic State group, whom they accused of using social media to encourage and facilitate the attack.

The priest had been born in 1930 in Darnétal, in Normandy. As a young man he hoped to join the Missionaries of Africa, but he was told his health would not allow it, and he became instead a parish priest in the Archdiocese of Rouen, serving its congregations for several decades. In 2016 he was still saying Mass at the church in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray. People who knew him spoke of his memory for names and faces, of his discretion, and of a patience with people on the margins of parish life; in the town he had taught the catechism some 30 years before.

That Tuesday morning the congregation was small. Kermiche and Petitjean entered during the service and took the priest, two nuns and two elderly parishioners hostage. The priest was killed, and one of the two parishioners was seriously injured. Police killed both men at the church.

The Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor took charge of the case. Kermiche was identified the same day; Petitjean was formally identified on July 28. Within days investigators had the outline that would later go to court: that Petitjean had come to Normandy to join Kermiche, and that a handful of other young men had known them, shared their ideology and, in some cases, met them in the week before July 26. Sebaihia, Khelil and Jean-Louis were taken into custody and charged. Kassim was believed to have been killed in a strike near Mosul, in Iraq, in 2017; because his death was never confirmed, he was tried in his absence.

The trial before the cour d'assises spéciale de Paris opened in February 2022, with no one in the dock as a principal for the killing. On March 9, 2022, the court convicted all four men. Kassim was sentenced in his absence to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 22 years, for complicity in the murder. Jean-Louis received 13 years, Khelil 10 years and Sebaihia eight years for association de malfaiteurs terroriste, with a minimum term of two-thirds of the sentence for Jean-Louis and Khelil.

The court found that the three men had approved of jihadist ideology at the time of the crime and had been in contact with the attackers, and that even without knowing the details of the plot they had known the two belonged to a criminal group preparing a violent act. It found that Khelil had reinforced Petitjean's determination to carry out an attack and that Sebaihia had visited Kermiche two days before the killing and had been aware of the two men's intentions; Jean-Louis's sentence reflected his attempt to reach Syria with Petitjean and his running of a Telegram channel that spread jihadist material among young people. Kassim's life sentence is the only judgment to hold anyone criminally responsible for the death of the priest. No verdict on the role of Kermiche himself exists, and none can.

Kermiche's own part in the killing has never been tested by a court. The account of what he did rests on the findings of the Paris prosecutor and the investigating judges, and on the evidence heard at the 2022 trial of others, at which he was not a defendant and could not answer. The same is true of Petitjean, who also died untried.

Whether the authorities could have prevented the killing has been argued over since July 2016. A 2018 press investigation asserted that a Paris police intelligence unit had seen messages from Kermiche pointing toward an attack about a week beforehand; no court has ruled on the claim.

Timeline

March 25, 1997: Adel Kermiche is born in Normandy.

March 2015: He is stopped in Germany while trying to reach Syria, returned to France, charged and released under judicial supervision.

May 2015: He reaches Turkey, is detained there and returned to France, charged with association de malfaiteurs en lien avec une entreprise terroriste, and placed in pre-trial detention.

March 2016: He is released to house arrest with an electronic tag in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray; the prosecution's appeal fails.

June 10, 2016: Petitjean is seen at a Turkish airport, apparently bound for Syria, and returns to France.

June 29, 2016: Petitjean is added to the French watch list.

July 22, 2016: French counterterrorism officials circulate an unnamed photograph of Petitjean with a warning that he could be ready to take part in an attack.

July 24 to 25, 2016: Sebaihia joins the two men in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray and leaves.

July 26, 2016: The priest is killed in his church at Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray and a parishioner is seriously injured; Kermiche and Petitjean are killed by police; the Islamic State group claims the killing.

July 28, 2016: Petitjean is formally identified.

2017: Kassim is believed killed in a strike near Mosul, Iraq.

March 9, 2022: The cour d'assises spéciale de Paris sentences Kassim in absentia to life imprisonment with a 22-year minimum term for complicity; Jean-Louis, Khelil and Sebaihia receive 13, 10 and eight years for association de malfaiteurs terroriste.