Abdul Quader Molla was the first man put to death for the crimes of Bangladesh's 1971 war of independence. In February 2013 a war crimes court in Dhaka convicted him of crimes against humanity committed in the spring of that year in Mirpur, then a fringe district of the capital: the killing of two men, of a woman together with her mother and two brothers, of between 300 and 350 unarmed villagers at Alubdi, and of most of one family, a charge that also carried rape. The court sentenced him to life and acquitted him on a sixth charge. Crowds gathered at Shahbag in central Dhaka to demand his death, and on February 17 parliament changed the law to let the state appeal a sentence it thought too light. Seven months later the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court convicted him on all six charges and sentenced him to death by a majority of four to one. He was executed in Dhaka on December 12, 2013.
At the time of his arrest he was the assistant secretary general of Jamaat-e-Islami. The death sentence rested on a law rewritten after his trial, and the way it reached him became the center of the dispute over his case.
Molla was born in 1948 in Amirabad, a village in the Sadarpur area of Faridpur district, south and west of Dhaka. He passed his secondary school examinations in 1964 and his higher secondary examinations at Rajendra College in Faridpur in 1966, where he went on to study for a science degree.
He came to student politics early. By his own testimony at trial he first joined the East Pakistan Chhatra Union, a left-wing student body, and in September 1966 moved to Islami Chhatra Sangha, the student wing of Jamaat-e-Islami, where he was elected president of the unit at Rajendra College. In 1969 he enrolled at the University of Dhaka to read physics, a course he did not complete, and in 1970 he became president of the Chhatra Sangha unit at Shahidullah Hall, one of the university's residential halls.
The prosecution's case was that Chhatra Sangha members formed the core of Al-Badr, an auxiliary force that worked with the Pakistan army against the independence movement in 1971, and that Molla organized it among the students. The tribunal accepted that the student wing was linked to Al-Badr. It did not find that Molla himself acted as a member of Al-Badr during the weeks of March and April 1971 that the charges covered.
The war began on the night of March 25, 1971, when the Pakistan army moved against the Bengali population of what was then East Pakistan. Five of the six charges against Molla concerned the four weeks that followed, from March 26 to April 24, in Mirpur. The tribunal found that he acted there with local collaborators who sided with the army, and in one case with its soldiers.
The first charge concerned Pallab, who was taken by force and killed in Mirpur in early April. The tribunal found that Molla and his accomplices planned and carried out the killing, and held that the law did not require him to have been present at the moment of death to share the guilt for it.
The second concerned Meherunnesa, killed in Mirpur on March 27 with her mother and two brothers. The tribunal found that Molla had led the group responsible to the family, and treated that as moral support and encouragement to those who did the killing.
The third concerned Khandaker Abu Taleb, who was taken to Mirpur and killed on March 29. The tribunal found him a member of the civilian population that supported independence; its finding against Molla rested on circumstantial evidence and on testimony placing him at the scene.
The fifth charge was the largest. On April 24, 1971, between 300 and 350 unarmed civilians of the village of Alubdi in Mirpur were killed by local collaborators together with Pakistani troops. The tribunal found that Molla went with the group that day and convicted him of murder as a crime against humanity.
The sixth charge went back to the first night of the war. On March 26, 1971, in Section 12 of Mirpur, Hazrat Ali Laskar, his wife and several of their young children were killed, and the same charge included rape as a crime against humanity. A daughter who survived, the only living member of the family, testified at the trial more than forty years later. The tribunal examined her evidence closely and accepted it. It found that Molla was present and took a direct part, and it convicted him of murder and rape as crimes against humanity.
The fourth charge came from the last weeks of the war, south of the city. On November 25, 1971, unarmed villagers were killed in the Bhawal Khan Bari and Ghatar Char areas of Keraniganj. The prosecution's case was that Molla led the local auxiliaries who took part. The tribunal accepted that mass killings had taken place there, but not that Molla had been identified as one of those responsible: two of the witnesses on the charge were not shown to have known him before that day, and the account of one of them was contradictory. It acquitted him of this charge. The Appellate Division later reached the opposite conclusion.
Bangladesh won its independence on December 16, 1971. By his own account Molla took a diploma in education in 1975 and a master's degree in education administration in 1977, taught at Udayan High School and later at the Bangladesh Rifles Public School and College, and worked for the Islamic Foundation Bangladesh.
His political career ran alongside. He joined Islami Chhatra Shibir, the student body that succeeded Chhatra Sangha, in 1977, and Jamaat itself in 1979. In 1981 he became executive editor of the party's daily newspaper, and in the early 1980s he served two terms as vice president of the combined Dhaka Union of Journalists. He was also the founding secretary of Manarat International School and College in Dhaka. Inside the party he became head of the Dhaka city unit in 1985, central publicity secretary in 1991 and assistant secretary general in 2000. He twice stood for parliament from Faridpur and lost his deposit both times.
The International Crimes (Tribunals) Act of 1973 was passed soon after independence for the trial of crimes committed during the war, but nearly four decades went by before anyone was tried under it. On July 14, 2009, parliament amended the Act to open the way for trials, and in 2010 the government set up the first tribunal. On July 13, 2010, Molla was arrested in Dhaka in a police case over the killing of hundreds of people in Mirpur in 1971. He was shown arrested before the International Crimes Tribunal on October 2, 2010, and remained in custody from then on.
His case came before the second tribunal, International Crimes Tribunal-2. On May 28, 2012, its judges framed six charges of crimes against humanity, and of aiding and complicity in such crimes, and Molla pleaded not guilty to each.
His defense was an alibi. Testifying on his own behalf, he said he left Shahidullah Hall on March 12, 1971, went home to his village in Faridpur, and was not in Mirpur at any point from the middle of March 1971 to the end of 1972. He said that from March 23 he trained with other young men in his village until the Pakistan army reached Faridpur on April 30, and he denied any tie to Jamaat-e-Islami in that period or to the collaborators of Mirpur.
The defense also challenged the trial itself. It argued that four decades of delay made a fair trial impossible, that the 1974 agreement among Bangladesh, India and Pakistan and the Collaborators Order of 1972 barred or had already covered the prosecution, and that a man could not be convicted of aiding crimes whose principal authors were never tried.
International Crimes Tribunal-2 delivered its unanimous judgment on February 5, 2013. It rejected each of the legal objections, holding among other things that no time limit applies to crimes against humanity, and it found that the alibi did not exclude his presence in Mirpur.
It convicted him on five charges. On the first three it found him guilty of complicity in murder as a crime against humanity and sentenced him to fifteen years on each. On the fifth, Alubdi, it found him guilty of murder as a crime against humanity, and on the sixth, the killing of the family in Section 12, of murder and rape as crimes against humanity. For those two charges it imposed imprisonment for life, with the fifteen-year terms merged into the life sentence. It acquitted him on the fourth charge, Keraniganj. Molla maintained his innocence in the dock. The defense announced an appeal, and the prosecution signaled one of its own.
Under the law as it stood, the state could appeal an acquittal but not a sentence. On February 17, 2013, parliament passed an amendment giving the government, and a complainant or informant, the same right of appeal against a sentence that the convicted person had, and made it effective from July 14, 2009, which brought the judgment against Molla within its reach. Both sides appealed to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, the prosecution seeking the maximum penalty and the defense an acquittal. The defense argued that the amended law could not apply to a man convicted before it was passed; the court held that it did.
The Appellate Division gave its decision on September 17, 2013, the first final verdict in any of the 1971 cases. On the sixth charge it found Molla guilty unanimously and sentenced him to death by a majority of four to one. On the fourth charge, Keraniganj, it reversed the acquittal and imposed imprisonment for life, again by four to one. It left the sentences on the first, second, third and fifth charges as the tribunal had set them. The one judge in the minority would have kept the sentence on the sixth charge at life imprisonment. Human Rights Watch and the International Commission of Jurists said that imposing a heavier penalty through a law passed after the trial breached international fair-trial standards.
The full judgment was released on December 5, 2013. An execution set for December 10 was stayed by the chamber judge of the Appellate Division, and his lawyers filed a petition for review. On December 12 the full bench heard the petition on its merits and dismissed it unanimously. Abdul Quader Molla was executed in Dhaka that night, December 12, 2013. He was 65.
Molla denied every charge to the end. His alibi placed him in Faridpur from mid-March 1971, and the trial court did not accept it.
His role in Al-Badr was alleged by the prosecution but was not part of the findings against him: the trial court did not find that he acted as a member of Al-Badr between March 26 and April 24, 1971.
The trial court found him directly responsible on two charges, Alubdi and the killing of the family in Section 12, and guilty of complicity on three. The difference mattered to the sentences it imposed.
On the Keraniganj charge the two courts disagreed. The trial court found the identification evidence too weak to convict; the Appellate Division, by a majority, convicted him and imposed life imprisonment.
On the sixth charge, which carried the death sentence, the defense argued that the conviction rested on a single witness. The trial court had examined her account closely and accepted it, and the Appellate Division upheld the conviction unanimously.
The trial court put the number of dead at Alubdi at between 300 and 350, a finding the Appellate Division left in place.
1948: Born in Amirabad, Sadarpur, Faridpur district.
1966: Joins Islami Chhatra Sangha, the student wing of Jamaat-e-Islami.
1970: Becomes president of the Chhatra Sangha unit at Shahidullah Hall, University of Dhaka.
March 25, 1971: The war of independence begins.
March 26 to April 24, 1971: Killings in Mirpur that form five of the six charges, including the killing of a family in Section 12 on March 26 and the Alubdi killings on April 24.
November 25, 1971: Killings in Bhawal Khan Bari and Ghatar Char, Keraniganj, the subject of the fourth charge.
December 16, 1971: Bangladesh wins its independence.
1979: Joins Jamaat-e-Islami.
2000: Becomes assistant secretary general of Jamaat-e-Islami.
July 14, 2009: Parliament amends the 1973 Act to open the way for war crimes trials.
July 13, 2010: Arrested in Dhaka.
May 28, 2012: International Crimes Tribunal-2 frames six charges; he pleads not guilty.
February 5, 2013: Convicted on five charges and sentenced to life; acquitted on the Keraniganj charge.
February 17, 2013: Parliament amends the 1973 Act to allow appeals against sentences, with effect from July 14, 2009.
September 17, 2013: The Appellate Division convicts him on all six charges and sentences him to death by a majority of four to one.
December 10, 2013: The chamber judge of the Appellate Division stays the execution.
December 12, 2013: Review petition dismissed; executed in Dhaka.