On October 12, 2000, the guided missile destroyer USS Cole was attacked in the port of Aden, Yemen. The United States attributes the attack to al-Qaeda. Seventeen American sailors died and 39 others were wounded. The United States accuses Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, a Saudi national, of organizing that attack, of planning a failed attempt on another American destroyer in the same harbor earlier that year, and of directing the October 2002 attack on the French tanker Limburg in the Gulf of Aden, in which one crew member died.
He has been in American custody since 2002. For roughly the first four years he was held by the CIA at secret sites outside the United States, and the treatment he received there, which a U.S. Senate report, a European human rights court and an American military judge have all addressed, shaped everything that followed. A court in Yemen sentenced him to death in absentia in 2004. In the United States he was charged before a military commission, arraigned in 2011 and then held for well over a decade in pretrial proceedings. He pleaded not guilty, and his capital trial at the U.S. Navy base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, began with the selection of a panel of military officers on November 2, 2026. As of November 2026 there was no verdict, and every allegation against him remains an allegation.
Al-Nashiri is a Saudi citizen of Yemeni descent, born in Saudi Arabia. His full name is Abd al Rahim Hussein Muhammed al Nashiri. He was 46 when he was arraigned at Guantanamo Bay in November 2011, and he was 61 when his trial opened in November 2026.
The first of the three cases did not cost a life. On January 3, 2000, the charges allege, an attempt was made on the destroyer USS The Sullivans in the harbor at Aden. It failed. Prosecutors allege that al-Nashiri planned it, and the attempt became part of the charge sheet sworn against him in 2011.
In October the USS Cole, a destroyer based at Norfolk, Virginia, was in Aden. The attack came on October 12, 2000. The United States charges that al-Nashiri arranged it. He has pleaded not guilty, and no American court has convicted him of any part of it.
The dead were Kenneth Eugene Clodfelter of Mechanicsville, Virginia; Richard Costelow of Morrisville, Pennsylvania; Lakeina Monique Francis of Woodleaf, North Carolina; Timothy Lee Gauna of Rice, Texas; Cherone Louis Gunn of Rex, Georgia; James Rodrick McDaniels of Norfolk, Virginia; Marc Ian Nieto of Fond du Lac, Wisconsin; Ronald Scott Owens of Vero Beach, Florida; Lakiba Nicole Palmer of San Diego, California; Joshua Langdon Parlett of Churchville, Maryland; Patrick Howard Roy of Cornwall on Hudson, New York; Kevin Shawn Rux of Portland, North Dakota; Ronchester Manangan Santiago of Kingsville, Texas; Timothy Lamont Saunders of Ringgold, Virginia; Gary Graham Swenchonis Jr. of Rockport, Texas; Andrew Triplett of Macon, Mississippi; and Craig Bryan Wibberley of Williamsport, Maryland.
On October 6, 2002, the French oil tanker Limburg was attacked in the Gulf of Aden. One member of her crew died, and a large quantity of oil spilled into the gulf. The United States charges that al-Nashiri was in charge of planning and preparing that attack as well, and it is the third of the three cases in the American indictment.
Al-Nashiri was seized in Dubai, in the United Arab Emirates, in October 2002, and handed to American custody. The United States announced his arrest later that year. He then disappeared from view. For almost four years he was held incommunicado by the CIA at secret detention sites, including sites in Poland and Romania. In 2006 he was transferred to Guantanamo Bay.
What happened to him in those years became the central legal fact of his case. In February 2008 the director of the CIA publicly confirmed that al-Nashiri had been subjected to abusive interrogation in the agency's custody. A U.S. Senate report released in 2014 found that he had been subjected to what the CIA called "enhanced interrogation techniques" on at least four occasions. In 2023 an American military judge would find that his later statements to federal agents were tainted by that history.
His lawyers also took his treatment to the European Court of Human Rights. In July 2014, according to reports of the judgment, the court ruled against Poland for its part in his torture and enforced disappearance at a CIA site on Polish territory. On May 31, 2018, it ruled against Romania. As reported, it found that Romania had hosted a secret CIA site where al-Nashiri was held, that it bore responsibility for his unlawful detention and ill-treatment there, and that it had failed to investigate his complaints effectively. It also found that Romania had breached his rights by helping to transfer him out of the country despite a substantial and foreseeable risk that he would face the death penalty, and a risk of a flagrant denial of justice in a trial before a U.S. military commission. Romania and Poland were each ordered to pay him about 100,000 euros, and Poland paid.
While al-Nashiri was still held at an undisclosed location by the CIA, Yemen put six men on trial over the attack on the Cole. All six were charged in July 2004 with belonging to al-Qaeda and with playing various parts in the attack. Al-Nashiri was tried in his absence, since he was in American hands.
On September 29, 2004, the court delivered its verdicts. Al-Nashiri, in absentia, and a Yemeni co-defendant were sentenced to death as the masterminds of the attack, for plotting, preparing and taking part in it. It was the first time anyone in Yemen had been sentenced to death for an act of terrorism. Four other men received prison terms of five to ten years. In February 2005 a Yemeni appeals court upheld the in-absentia death sentence against al-Nashiri and reduced the co-defendant's sentence to fifteen years in prison. Al-Nashiri has remained in American custody throughout.
The United States first moved to try al-Nashiri in June 2008, when the Pentagon's chief prosecutor swore charges against him before a military commission and recommended that the case be tried as a capital case. The case did not reach a courtroom. The charges were withdrawn on February 6, 2009.
New charges were sworn on April 20, 2011, under the Military Commissions Act of 2009. There were eleven counts, among them terrorism, using treachery or perfidy, and murder and attempted murder in violation of the law of war, and they covered the attempt on USS The Sullivans, the attack on the Cole and the attack on the Limburg. The case was referred to a military commission as a capital case, and al-Nashiri became the first man to face a possible death sentence in the military commission cases at Guantanamo Bay. He was arraigned there on November 9, 2011, and did not enter a plea.
What followed were years of pretrial litigation, much of it over the CIA period: what the government had to disclose about the secret sites, which of al-Nashiri's statements could be used, and whether his lawyers could meet him in confidence. Then it emerged that the presiding judge had been seeking a job as an immigration judge at the Justice Department and had kept ruling in the case without telling the parties. On April 16, 2019, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit unanimously held that he should have disqualified himself, and it vacated every order he had issued after November 2015. More than three years of pretrial rulings had to be revisited before a new judge.
The government's case had relied in part on a confession al-Nashiri later made to federal agents, after the CIA years. In August 2023 the military judge then presiding ruled that the statements could not be used as evidence, finding that the confession was derived from the torture he had suffered and was tainted by years of abuse at the hands of the CIA and the FBI. It was the first ruling of its kind at Guantanamo Bay, and it removed the key evidence prosecutors had hoped to use.
By 2026 the question was whether he could be tried at all. A defense psychiatrist who examined him in August 2026 concluded that he was not competent to stand trial. The military judge ordered a formal competency evaluation, and an Army psychiatrist found him fit. The judge adopted that finding. Al-Nashiri pleaded not guilty, and panel selection began on November 2, 2026, in the first death-penalty trial to be held by a military commission at Guantanamo Bay. He remains in U.S. military custody at the base while it proceeds.
No American court has found al-Nashiri guilty of anything. He has pleaded not guilty to every charge, and the government's account of his role in the attempt on USS The Sullivans, the attack on the Cole and the attack on the Limburg remains a set of allegations to be proved at trial beyond a reasonable doubt. The Yemeni death sentence, imposed in his absence while he was held by the CIA, was not a judgment he was able to contest in person.
His competence to stand trial was disputed until the military judge ruled. A defense psychiatrist found him not competent, an Army psychiatrist found him fit, and the judge adopted the Army finding.
January 3, 2000: An attempt is made on the destroyer USS The Sullivans at Aden, Yemen; al-Nashiri is later charged with planning it.
October 12, 2000: The attack on the USS Cole at Aden kills 17 U.S. sailors and wounds 39.
October 6, 2002: The attack on the French tanker Limburg in the Gulf of Aden kills one crew member.
October 2002: Al-Nashiri is seized in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, and handed to American custody.
2002 to 2006: He is held incommunicado by the CIA at secret sites, including sites in Poland and Romania.
July 2004: Six men, al-Nashiri among them in his absence, are charged in Yemen over the attack on the Cole.
September 29, 2004: A Yemeni court sentences him to death in absentia.
February 2005: A Yemeni appeals court upholds the in-absentia death sentence.
2006: He is transferred to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
February 2008: The director of the CIA publicly confirms that he was subjected to abusive interrogation.
June 2008: The first U.S. military commission charges are sworn, with a recommendation for a capital trial.
February 6, 2009: Those charges are withdrawn.
April 20, 2011: New charges are sworn under the Military Commissions Act of 2009.
2011: The charges are referred to a military commission as a capital case.
November 9, 2011: He is arraigned at Guantanamo Bay and does not enter a plea.
July 2014: The European Court of Human Rights rules against Poland over his secret detention and torture.
2014: A U.S. Senate report finds he was subjected to "enhanced interrogation techniques" on at least four occasions.
May 31, 2018: The European Court of Human Rights rules against Romania.
April 16, 2019: The D.C. Circuit vacates every order issued by the presiding judge after November 2015.
August 2023: A military judge rules that his statements to federal agents cannot be used because they were derived from torture.
August 2026: A defense psychiatrist finds him not competent; an Army psychiatrist later finds him fit.
November 2, 2026: Panel selection begins in the capital trial at Guantanamo Bay after he pleads not guilty.
November 2026: The trial continues with no verdict.