Aaron Ybarra

Victims
1 murder: Paul Lee, Seattle, June 5, 2014; also convicted of three attempted first-degree murders and one second-degree assault (jury verdict, November 16, 2016).
Years active
June 5, 2014
Location
Seattle, Washington (killing); Mountlake Terrace, Washington (residence); Seattle, Washington (trial, King County Superior Court); Washington (prison)
Method
Shot (Court of Appeals findings, 2019).
Status
Jury rejected his insanity defense; sentenced February 17, 2017, to 1,343 months (about 112 years); affirmed August 19, 2019. Held in a Washington state prison as of September 2019.

Aaron Ybarra was 26 years old and lived in Mountlake Terrace, a suburb north of Seattle, when, on June 5, 2014, he carried out an attack he had planned for weeks at Seattle Pacific University, a small university in the city. A young man from Portland, Oregon, died. Two other young people were wounded, a third escaped harm, and a fourth man was threatened. Ybarra was stopped within minutes and held until police arrived.

He never denied what he had done. His defense at trial was legal insanity: that a severe mental illness had left him unable to tell right from wrong. On November 16, 2016, a King County Superior Court jury rejected that defense and found him guilty as charged of premeditated first-degree murder, three counts of attempted first-degree murder and one count of second-degree assault. On February 17, 2017, he was sentenced to 1,343 months in prison, a little under 112 years. The Washington Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions and the sentence on August 19, 2019.

Ybarra grew up in Mountlake Terrace, in Snohomish County. He was enrolled at Edmonds Community College from the fall of 2005 through the spring of 2010 and again in 2012, and he earned an online certificate in aerospace manufacturing. In 2006 he was in a program run by the Edmonds School District, which he left without a diploma. In 2010 he listed his employer as a business in Kenmore.

He told police after his arrest that he had been diagnosed with obsessive-compulsive disorder at the age of 13. At trial, relatives testified that he had developmental problems as a child, and a defense psychologist described limited intellectual abilities and social difficulties consistent with the autism spectrum, alongside a diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder.

In the years before 2014 his troubles brought him repeatedly to the attention of police and of the mental health system. In October 2010 he called 911 while intoxicated, said he was suicidal and was taken to a hospital for an evaluation. In both 2010 and 2012 police took him to a hospital and recommended involuntary commitment because of suicidal behavior. In July 2012 he was arrested for drunken driving; he later completed alcohol treatment, and that case was still open in June 2014. In October 2012 police found him intoxicated in public and took him into custody for another mental health evaluation. He later told detectives that he had stopped taking his prescribed medication and stopped going to therapy about six months before June 2014.

The Court of Appeals, summarizing the trial evidence in 2019, found that he had planned the attack over several weeks. His own journal, his interview with detectives after the arrest and his testimony at trial were the three main sources of that evidence. He meant, by his own account, to die himself at the end.

Paul Lee was the person who died. He had graduated in 2013 from Westview High School in the Portland area and had come north to Seattle Pacific for college. Friends and teachers remembered him as fun and easy company, a young man with a contagious laugh and smile; he loved break dancing and spent lunch breaks and afternoons practicing moves with friends. Classmates called him Uncle Paul because he was always the one ready to help. He was a young man of deep faith, and he hoped to become a counselor. He did not know Ybarra, and Seattle police found no connection between Ybarra and any of the people he harmed.

Two other young people were wounded, one of them critically. A third escaped unhurt from an attempt on her life. A fourth man, threatened, also escaped unhurt; that threat became the count of second-degree assault. Ybarra was stopped by a building monitor who was himself a student at the university. With help from another man, the monitor subdued him and held him until campus security and Seattle Police arrived. Ybarra told the men who held him that he had meant to end his own life.

Seattle Police took Ybarra into custody that afternoon. Detectives interviewed him at the police station, and he cooperated, describing his plan and his reasons in the account the Court of Appeals later set out in detail. On June 6 he appeared before a judge in King County and was ordered held without bail at the King County Jail, where he was placed on suicide watch.

On June 10, 2014, the King County Prosecuting Attorney filed charges in King County Superior Court: one count of premeditated first-degree murder, two counts of attempted first-degree murder and one count of second-degree assault. The state gave notice that it would ask a jury to find an aggravating factor, that the crime had a destructive and foreseeable impact on people other than its direct victims, one of the statutory grounds on which a Washington court may sentence above the standard range.

By the time of trial the charges had grown to three counts of attempted first-degree murder, one for each of the three people he had tried to kill, alongside the murder count and the assault count. Each count carried a sentencing enhancement and the aggravating allegation. Ybarra pleaded not guilty and gave notice that he would rely on a defense of not guilty by reason of insanity.

The case came to trial in King County Superior Court in Seattle in the fall of 2016, and more than 40 witnesses testified over several weeks. Guilt was not contested in the ordinary sense. Ybarra admitted that he was the man who had done it, and the question for the jury was his state of mind. Under Washington's insanity statute the burden was his, by a preponderance of the evidence, to show that a mental disease or defect had left him unable to perceive the nature and quality of the act, or unable to tell right from wrong with reference to it. The defense case rested on his illness, his limited intellectual function and his belief that God was directing him. The prosecution accepted that he was mentally ill but contended that the crimes were premeditated and that he knew they were wrong.

Ybarra testified in his own defense. He told the jury that he had heard voices for years and that he had been carrying out what he believed was a plan from God. He said he had kept that plan secret, which was why it appeared nowhere in his journal or in what he told detectives, his therapists and, at first, the experts, and that what he had earlier written and told police had been a cover-up. Under cross-examination he admitted that he had known it was legally and morally wrong to kill. The Court of Appeals later noted that parts of his testimony contradicted one another.

The jury also heard from his therapist, his psychiatrist, the pediatric neurologist who had treated him as a child, the jail chaplain, a chemical dependency counselor and members of his family. The two central witnesses were psychologists who had each examined him in jail. The defense expert concluded that his illness impaired his ability to understand the moral wrongness of his actions, though he knew they were illegal. The state's expert, the last witness of the trial, concluded that he understood the acts were both legally and morally wrong and could not find that he was legally insane.

Before the case went to the jury, the defense asked the judge to instruct the jury on second-degree murder and attempted second-degree murder, crimes that require intent to kill but not premeditation. The judge refused. He did instruct on first-degree manslaughter, which fit Ybarra's testimony that he had not meant to kill anyone, but he found no evidence of intent to kill without premeditation.

On November 16, 2016, the jury rejected the insanity defense and found Ybarra guilty as charged: first-degree murder, three counts of attempted first-degree murder and second-degree assault, with every enhancement and the aggravating factor. As he was led out, he said that he wished it had never happened.

Sentencing took place on February 17, 2017, before the same judge. After the verdicts the reported exposure was 88 to 111 years. The prosecution asked for 111 years and the defense for about 90. The judge imposed a total of 1,343 months, a little under 112 years. Before sentence was passed, Ybarra apologized. He said he wished he could take back what he had done, that he wished the young man he had killed were still alive, and that the young woman he had critically wounded had not deserved what happened to her.

At a restitution hearing on August 9, 2017, a different King County judge ordered him to pay $13,119.90, most of it to the state's Crime Victims' Compensation Fund, including $86.04 for the medical expenses of a bystander who had given aid to one of the wounded.

Ybarra appealed to the Washington Court of Appeals, Division One, which heard the appeal from the judgment together with the appeal from the restitution order. He raised three issues. He argued that the trial judge had improperly commented on the evidence, which the state constitution forbids, in remarks describing the defense psychologist as an important witness and telling jurors that the experts' testimony, not their reports, was the evidence; taken together, he argued, those remarks told the jury the only real question was insanity, when premeditation was still in dispute. He argued that the judge had been wrong to refuse the second-degree murder instructions, because the acts he did commit were spur-of-the-moment reactions rather than the plan he had made. And he argued that his lawyer at the restitution hearing had been ineffective for not contesting the $86.04 award.

On August 19, 2019, the court rejected all three arguments and affirmed. It held that the remarks were about managing the schedule of a multi-week trial with more than 40 witnesses, not about the worth of any testimony, and that none suggested the judge thought the state had met its burden. It held that there was ample evidence that Ybarra had planned over several weeks to kill students at the university and no evidence that he intended to kill without premeditation; his testimony that he had only meant to wound supported the manslaughter instruction he received, not a second-degree murder instruction. And it held that conceding so small a sum, for a man facing more than a century in prison, was a legitimate strategic choice.

On September 18, 2019, his appellate lawyer filed a petition asking the Washington Supreme Court to review the decision on the judicial-comment and lesser-offense questions. The petition was served on him at a Washington state prison, where he was held as of September 2019.

The nature of the sentence is described two ways. Reports at the time called the 112 years an exceptional sentence, while the Court of Appeals twice described the 1,343 months as a standard range sentence; the opinion is the court's own account.

The account Ybarra gave at trial, that he was obeying a divine plan, differed from what he wrote in his journal and told detectives. The prosecution's position was that he first spoke of God directing him months after his arrest. The jury rejected the insanity defense, and the Court of Appeals noted the contradictions in his testimony.

Timeline

2005 to 2010, and 2012: Ybarra enrolled at Edmonds Community College.

October 2010: taken to a hospital for a mental health evaluation after calling 911.

2010 and 2012: police recommend his involuntary commitment after suicidal behavior.

July 2012: arrested for drunken driving.

Spring 2014: plans the attack over several weeks, as the Court of Appeals later found.

June 5, 2014: the murder in Seattle; two other young people wounded; Ybarra subdued by a building monitor and taken into custody by Seattle Police.

June 6, 2014: first court appearance in King County; held without bail.

June 10, 2014: charged in King County Superior Court with first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder and second-degree assault.

Fall 2016: trial in King County Superior Court.

November 16, 2016: jury rejects the insanity defense and convicts on all counts.

February 17, 2017: sentenced to 1,343 months in prison.

August 9, 2017: restitution of $13,119.90 ordered.

August 19, 2019: Washington Court of Appeals, Division One, affirms.

September 18, 2019: petition for review filed in the Washington Supreme Court.