Aaron McKinney and Russell Henderson

Victims
1 man murdered after a kidnapping in Laramie, 1998. Henderson pleaded guilty to felony murder; a jury convicted McKinney of felony murder and acquitted him of premeditated murder, 1999
Years active
October 6, 1998 (offenses); October 12, 1998 (death)
Location
Laramie, Wyoming; Fort Collins, Colorado
Method
Felony murder in the course of kidnapping and aggravated robbery
Status
Henderson: two consecutive life terms (April 5, 1999); McKinney: two consecutive life terms without parole, appeals waived (November 4, 1999); Henderson's 2024 commutation petition declined

On the night of October 6, 1998, two young men from Laramie, Wyoming, Aaron McKinney and Russell Henderson, kidnapped and robbed Matthew Shepard. He died on October 12 in Fort Collins, Colorado. Within a year both men had been convicted of felony murder in the district court for Albany County. Henderson pleaded guilty to felony murder and kidnapping in April 1999 and received two consecutive life terms. McKinney went to trial that fall, where a jury found him guilty of felony murder, second-degree murder, kidnapping and aggravated robbery and acquitted him of premeditated first-degree murder. Facing a jury that could have sentenced him to death, he accepted two consecutive life terms without parole and gave up every right of appeal.

The case became a national one almost at once. The state said the young man had been singled out at least in part because of his sexual orientation, but Wyoming had no hate-crime statute, so no such charge was ever filed and no jury was ever asked to decide motive. The men were convicted of murder, kidnapping and robbery. In October 2009 the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act became federal law.

McKinney and Henderson were close to the age of the man they killed: each was about 21 in the fall of 1998. Both had grown up in Laramie, and both had left high school without finishing. They worked together on roofing jobs around the town.

The young man was born in Casper, Wyoming, and grew up there. Born prematurely, he was always the shortest child in his class. He played Little League baseball, served as an altar boy at an Episcopal church in the town and performed in school and community plays, including with a Casper acting troupe. He finished his schooling at a boarding school in Switzerland and graduated in 1995.

People who knew him, in Casper and in Switzerland, described him the same way: easy to talk to, kind, quick to smile, with a bounce in his step. He liked to travel and made friends in a good many countries. He had a weakness for cherry pie. Friends and family called him Matt. In October 1998 he had been living in Laramie for only a few months.

The crimes took place on the evening of October 6, 1998, in Laramie, and he died on October 12. The investigation moved quickly. Investigators had both men in custody by October 8, and McKinney gave them a recorded statement. Two women close to the defendants were also questioned and later charged.

The first charges against McKinney and Henderson were kidnapping, aggravated robbery and attempted first-degree murder. After the death they were raised to first-degree murder, and the case became a capital prosecution: under Wyoming law, a murder committed in the course of a kidnapping or an aggravated robbery could be punished by death. The two cases were set for separate trials in the district court in Laramie, Henderson's first, and the state said it would seek the death penalty.

Henderson never went to trial. On April 5, 1999, he appeared in the Albany County district court and pleaded guilty to two counts: kidnapping, and felony murder with robbery as the underlying crime. In exchange the state dropped the charge of premeditated first-degree murder and withdrew the threat of a death sentence.

Before sentence was passed, Henderson apologized in open court and said he knew what he had done was wrong. The judge then imposed two life sentences, one on each count, and ordered that they run consecutively.

McKinney's case went to trial in the fall of 1999 before another district judge in Laramie. At the center of the prosecution's case was McKinney's own recorded statement to investigators. His defense did not dispute the facts of the crimes. Its aim was to win a conviction on a lesser charge and keep McKinney off death row, and it leaned on his intoxication.

On November 3, 1999, the jury returned its verdicts. It found McKinney guilty of two counts of felony murder, one resting on the kidnapping and one on the aggravated robbery; of second-degree murder, which meant he had killed maliciously but without premeditation; of kidnapping; and of aggravated robbery. On the count of premeditated first-degree murder it found him not guilty.

The acquittal on premeditation did not take death off the table. Each felony-murder count was a capital offense, and the same jury was to hear a penalty phase beginning the next day.

The penalty phase never began. That evening the defense put an offer to the young man's family: McKinney would accept two consecutive life terms without parole and give up all his rights of appeal, and in return the state would not ask the jury for death. The family accepted, and the county attorney agreed.

On November 4, 1999, the trial judge approved the agreement in open court. McKinney was sentenced to two consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole. He waived any appeal of his convictions and his sentence, and the agreement also barred him from speaking to the press about the case. He was 22.

The two women charged in the case pleaded guilty to lesser charges in the same court; one received a prison term of 15 to 24 months and the other a jail sentence of 180 days.

McKinney's waiver closed every door to appellate review of his case. Henderson had made no such promise but filed no appeal after his plea. In April 2004 a new lawyer filed a postconviction petition for him in the district court in Laramie, claiming he had been denied effective assistance of counsel after the plea. The district judge rejected it, and in July 2004 the Wyoming Supreme Court refused to review that ruling.

He then carried the same claim into federal court. In February 2006 a federal district judge in Wyoming rejected his motion for a writ of habeas corpus, making it the third court to turn the claim away. His two consecutive life terms stood.

Overcrowding in Wyoming's prisons meant that both men spent long stretches of their sentences in prisons outside the state, under contracts held by the Wyoming Department of Corrections. In 2018 the department was holding McKinney in a prison in Mississippi, and he was declining requests for interviews. Henderson, then 41, was in a medium-security prison in Wyoming. He worked with prisoners in hospice care and trained shelter dogs for adoption, and that year he gave a prison interview to a news agency. He told it that he thought about the young man every day of his life and was deeply ashamed to have been part of the crime.

In June 2024 Henderson asked the governor to commute his sentence. On September 9, 2024, the Wyoming Board of Parole voted not to forward the petition to the governor; he could submit another in five years. He was 46 and had served about 25 years.

Motive is the one part of the case that was never settled in court. From the first days the police described a crime driven both by robbery and by the victim's sexual orientation, while Henderson's defense said the men had been after money. McKinney's defense offered a so-called "gay panic" theory, which the trial judge kept from the jury. Because Wyoming had no hate-crime charge, the verdicts say nothing either way about motive, and McKinney's appeal waiver meant no higher court ever considered the question.

In November 2004, in their first television interview, both men told a national news program that the crimes had been driven by money and drugs rather than by the victim's sexual orientation. McKinney gave the interview despite the agreement that bound him not to speak to the press. Henderson used the same program to accept responsibility and to apologize to the young man's family. In his 2018 prison interview he held to that account, saying the two men had set out to rob, not out of hatred.

Later reports differ on whether Henderson's terms were simple life terms or life without parole, a point that bears on whether a commutation petition was open to him; the Board of Parole accepted and heard his petition in 2024.

Timeline

October 6, 1998: Kidnapping and robbery in Laramie, Wyoming.

October 8, 1998: Both men in custody in Laramie.

October 9, 1998: First court appearance; charged with kidnapping, aggravated robbery and attempted first-degree murder.

October 12, 1998: The victim dies in Fort Collins, Colorado; charges raised to first-degree murder.

April 5, 1999: Henderson pleads guilty in Albany County district court to felony murder and kidnapping; two consecutive life terms.

November 3, 1999: Jury convicts McKinney of felony murder, second-degree murder, kidnapping and aggravated robbery; acquits him of premeditated first-degree murder.

November 4, 1999: McKinney sentenced by agreement to two consecutive life terms without parole; appeals waived.

April 2004: Henderson files a postconviction petition in the district court.

July 2004: Wyoming Supreme Court refuses to review the district court's rejection of the petition.

November 2004: Both men give a television interview disputing the anti-gay motive.

February 2006: A federal district judge in Wyoming rejects Henderson's motion for a writ of habeas corpus.

2018: McKinney held in Mississippi under a Wyoming contract; Henderson, in a Wyoming prison, gives a prison interview to the Associated Press.

June 2024: Henderson petitions for commutation.

September 9, 2024: Wyoming Board of Parole declines to forward the petition to the governor.