ASSATA SHAKUR AND THE TURNPIKE SHOOTOUT

Shortly before one o’clock on the morning of May 2, 1973, a New Jersey state trooper named James Harper pulled a white Pontiac over on the New Jersey Turnpike near New Brunswick. The car had a broken taillight and Vermont plates. A second trooper, Werner Foerster, pulled in behind him as backup. When the shooting stopped, Foerster was dead, Harper was wounded, one of the car’s passengers was dead, and the woman in the car, a New Yorker the police knew as Joanne Chesimard, had been shot and was soon in custody.

Four years later a jury convicted her of Foerster’s murder. Two years after that she walked out of a New Jersey prison with the help of armed confederates, and in 1984 she reappeared in Havana as Assata Shakur, a political exile under Fidel Castro’s protection. She stayed there for the rest of her life. To the New Jersey State Police she remained a fugitive who had killed one of their own. To her supporters she was a revolutionary who had been shot with her hands raised and convicted by a hostile jury. She died in Havana on September 25, 2025, at the age of 78, and neither side had given any ground.

JoAnne Byron

She was born JoAnne Deborah Byron in New York City on July 16, 1947. The New York Amsterdam News placed her birth in Queens. Her childhood was divided between New York and Wilmington, North Carolina, where she lived for long stretches with her maternal grandparents and met the segregation of the Jim Crow South at first hand. By middle school she was back in New York, where she ran away from home more than once. An aunt, Evelyn Williams, took her in, and Williams, a lawyer, later became one of the central figures in her life and her defense.

She studied at the Borough of Manhattan Community College and then at City College of New York, where her politics took shape. In 1967 she married Louis Chesimard; they divorced in 1970, but his surname stayed with her in every indictment, wanted poster and court caption that followed. She worked with the Black Panther Party in Harlem, where she helped run its free breakfast program. At a memorial for her at Riverside Church in Harlem, the former Panther Jamal Joseph recalled that she had begun as an unreliable recruit who overslept and lost papers, and had ended as the program’s coordinator and a teacher of self-defense classes. In 1971 she took the name Assata Olugbala Shakur.

The Black Liberation Army

From the Panthers she moved to the Black Liberation Army, an underground group that advocated armed struggle against the police and the state. Officials described it in 2013 as one of the most violent militant groups of the 1970s. At the press conference that placed her on the FBI’s terrorist list, Aaron Ford of the bureau’s Newark office said the group had killed more than a dozen police officers in the 1970s and 1980s. John Miller, a former FBI assistant director, told CBS News that year that she had been the soul of the organization and one of its leaders.

By early 1973 she was the subject of a multistate manhunt. She faced several sets of New York charges, among them bank robbery, and she was a wanted woman when the Pontiac was stopped. In the years after her arrest she was tried again and again in New York. The Amsterdam News reported that Evelyn Williams defended her in seven separate bank robbery and kidnapping cases and won each of them. Shakur herself, in an open letter read on Democracy Now! in 1998, said that the charges brought against her in those years had been dropped or had ended in acquittal. None of the New York cases produced a conviction.

May 2, 1973

The Pontiac carried three people. Clark Edward Squire, who called himself Sundiata Acoli, was at the wheel. In the car with him were James Costan, known as Zayd Malik Shakur, and Joanne Chesimard. All three were armed. New Jersey State Police records say Harper made the stop at about 12:45 a.m. near the Turnpike’s New Brunswick station and that a discrepancy over the car’s registration led the troopers to take the driver out. Foerster frisked Acoli and found ammunition and a gun on him.

What happened next is the part of the case that has never been settled. In its 2022 ruling on Acoli’s parole, the New Jersey Supreme Court summarized the facts this way: Chesimard shot Harper in the shoulder, and a gunfight followed between Harper and the two passengers. Acoli’s account, which the court also recorded, was that he wrestled with Foerster for the trooper’s gun, was grazed by Harper’s fire and lost consciousness. Foerster was shot and killed. The court stated plainly that who fired the fatal shots remains a disputed issue.

Shakur’s account never varied. She said she had raised her hands when Harper ordered them up, that he shot her anyway, and that a second shot struck her from behind as she fell. At her trial she testified that her wounds had left her arms paralyzed, so that she could not have fired at anyone, and The Intercept later wrote that the medical evidence indicated her arms had been raised. The prosecution’s position was that it did not need to prove she fired the fatal shot: under New Jersey law an accomplice in a killing faces the same sentence as the person who pulls the trigger.

Zayd Malik Shakur died of his wounds that night. Acoli drove away in the Pontiac and fled into the woods; he was captured after a manhunt of about a day and a half. Chesimard was taken into custody along the Turnpike, bleeding and with her arms raised, according to the trooper who arrested her, and was treated at Middlesex General Hospital in New Brunswick, where she was also arraigned. The State Police memorial record says Foerster died of multiple gunshot wounds.

Werner Foerster

Werner Foerster was 34. He was born on August 19, 1938, in Leipzig, Germany. He served in the U.S. Army from December 1963 to December 1965, and the State Police remember him as a Vietnam War veteran. He joined the force with the 82nd State Police Class on July 24, 1970, and served at Toms River, Colts Neck, Fort Dix and Keyport before his posting to Troop D headquarters in New Brunswick in November 1972. He lived in Old Bridge with his wife and their son, who was 3 when his father was killed. He is buried in Washington Monumental Cemetery in South River.

In the decades that followed, the State Police marked each anniversary of his death and used the case to teach recruits. Colonel Rick Fuentes, the superintendent, said in 2013 that the lesson drawn from the Turnpike shooting was that there is no such thing as a routine motor vehicle stop.

Two trials

The defendants were indicted together in 1973 and tried apart. Acoli went first. In 1974 a jury convicted him on every count, including the murder of Foerster, assault with intent to kill Harper, armed robbery and weapons offenses, and he was sentenced to life plus 24 to 30 years.

Her own case took longer to reach a New Jersey jury. In 1974, while she was in custody, she gave birth to a daughter, Kakuya, in a hospital under guard. She later said she spent more than two years in solitary confinement, much of it in men’s prisons.

Her New Jersey trial began in 1977 at the Middlesex County Courthouse in downtown New Brunswick. Finding an impartial panel in Middlesex County had proved difficult; New Brunswick Today later reported a 1973 poll in which 83 percent of county residents knew who she was and 70 percent believed she was guilty. The jury was drawn instead from Morris County. It was all white, and five of its members had personal ties to state troopers. Among the lawyers who represented her over the years was Lennox Hinds, a Rutgers professor.

Harper was the state’s central witness, as he had been at Acoli’s trial. Under cross-examination, according to accounts published by New Brunswick Today and The Intercept, he acknowledged that his first reports of the shooting had not been accurate. A motorist testified to seeing a Black man and a trooper struggling between the Pontiac and a patrol car. Shakur testified in her own defense and repeated that her arms had been raised and then disabled by her wounds.

The jury deliberated for about 24 hours. In 1977 it found her guilty on eight counts: first-degree and second-degree murder, assault on an officer on duty, assault with intent to kill, assault with a dangerous weapon, atrocious assault and battery, illegal possession of a weapon, and armed robbery. She received the mandatory life sentence for the murder and 26 to 33 years on the other charges. When she refused to rise as the judge entered, he added 30 days in the county workhouse for contempt. The prosecutor called the verdict a decision made entirely on the facts. Shakur and her lawyers called it the work of a racist jury, and in her 1998 letter she described the trial as a legal lynching.

Clinton

After the verdict she was moved through several institutions before being returned to New Jersey and the Clinton Correctional Facility for Women in Hunterdon County. In November 1979, members of the Black Liberation Army who had come in as visitors took two guards hostage, commandeered a prison van and drove her out. John Miller, the former FBI official, later called the escape incredibly daring. New Brunswick Today reported that her brother was among the three people who freed her.

She spent the next five years underground in the United States. According to Miller, she was smuggled into Mexico in 1984 and taken from there to Cuba, where Fidel Castro’s government granted her political asylum. The United States and Cuba had no extradition treaty in force, and Havana treated her as a refugee from political persecution.

Havana

She lived openly in Cuba for four decades. Her book, Assata: An Autobiography, was published in the late 1980s and climbed the Amazon rankings again after her death. Miller said she taught at Cuban universities. She was close to the family of the rapper Tupac Shakur, who regarded her as his godmother. Public Enemy invoked her on "Rebel Without a Pause" in 1988, and Common recorded "A Song for Assata" in 2000. During the Black Lives Matter era her writings became a touchstone for the movement, and critics pointed to their Marxist and communist roots.

In 1998, when Pope John Paul II visited Cuba, New Jersey state troopers asked him to press for her return. She answered with an open letter to the pope, describing herself as a political refugee and asking for nothing for herself.

The pressure from New Jersey never let up. On May 2, 2005, the FBI designated her a domestic terrorist and offered $1 million for her capture; the New Jersey attorney general matched it. On May 2, 2013, the 40th anniversary of the shooting, the bureau added her to its list of Most Wanted Terrorists, the first woman ever placed on it, and the combined reward rose to $2 million. "Justice has no expiration date," said Jeffrey Chiesa, the state attorney general. She was 65.

When President Barack Obama announced in December 2014 that the United States would restore diplomatic relations with Cuba, Governor Chris Christie wrote to him demanding her return before any further step, and called her a "cold-blooded cop-killer." Josefina Vidal, who led North American affairs at Cuba’s foreign ministry, replied through the Associated Press that there was no extradition treaty in effect between the two countries, and Cuba maintained that she had legitimately received asylum. In June 2017, announcing a rollback of the Obama policy in Miami, President Donald Trump demanded the return of fugitives from American justice and named her among them. Christie praised the demand; Fuentes said he had never been more hopeful. Nothing changed.

Sundiata Acoli

The other survivor of the Pontiac stayed in prison. Under the law that applied to a 1973 killing, Acoli first became eligible for parole in 1993, and the New Jersey State Parole Board turned him down every time. In 2014 an appellate panel ordered his release, but the state Supreme Court reversed that order on procedural grounds in 2016. Later that year the full board denied him again and set a 15-year wait before his next eligibility.

On May 10, 2022, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled 3 to 2 that the board’s denial was not supported by the record and ordered him paroled. Justice Albin wrote for the majority; Justice Solomon wrote the dissent. Acoli was 85, had served 49 years and, his lawyers said, was living with dementia. He planned to live in New York with his daughter and grandchildren. Governor Phil Murphy said that anyone who takes the life of an officer on duty should stay behind bars for life. Wayne Blanchard, president of the State Troopers Fraternal Association, said the ruling had trampled on the dignity of Foerster and his family. A 1996 New Jersey law now requires life without parole for the killing of an on-duty officer, but it did not apply to a sentence imposed in 1974.

Death in Havana

Assata Shakur died in Havana on Thursday, September 25, 2025, at the age of 78. Cuba’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced the death the next day and attributed it to health conditions and advanced age; her daughter, Kakuya Shakur, confirmed it. Governor Murphy and Colonel Patrick Callahan, the State Police superintendent, said in a joint statement that she had died without being held fully accountable, that Foerster had never had the chance to live out his days in peace, and that they would vigorously oppose any attempt to return her remains to the United States. Blanchard called her one of the first domestic terrorists in the nation’s history and said her death brought Foerster’s family no closure. A state legislator who had sponsored a resolution urging Cuba to extradite her said justice had never been served. Black Lives Matter Grassroots paid tribute to her courage and wisdom. In the 2026 session, two Monmouth County Assembly members pre-filed a resolution to designate August 19, Foerster’s birthday, as Trooper Werner Foerster Remembrance Day.

On May 30, 2026, a celebration of her life titled "Carry It On" filled Riverside Church. Angela Davis and Marc Lamont Hill spoke, and so did her daughter, Kakuya. Common performed a few bars, and Sweet Honey in the Rock sang. Across the Hudson, the official verdict had not changed: a convicted murderer had died a fugitive. The two accounts had run side by side for half a century, and her death in Havana settled neither.

Timeline

• August 19, 1938: Werner Foerster born in Leipzig, Germany.

• July 16, 1947: Born JoAnne Deborah Byron in New York City.

• 1967: Marries Louis Chesimard; they divorce in 1970.

• July 24, 1970: Foerster joins the New Jersey State Police.

• 1971: She takes the name Assata Olugbala Shakur and moves from the Black Panther Party to the Black Liberation Army.

• May 2, 1973: Turnpike shooting near New Brunswick; Trooper Werner Foerster and Zayd Malik Shakur killed, Trooper James Harper wounded; Chesimard wounded and arrested; Acoli captured after a manhunt.

• 1974: Acoli convicted of murder and other charges; Chesimard gives birth to her daughter in custody.

• Mid-1970s: New York trials on bank robbery and kidnapping charges end without a conviction.

• 1977: Convicted in New Brunswick of first-degree murder and seven other felonies; life plus 26 to 33 years.

• November 1979: Freed from the Clinton Correctional Facility for Women.

• 1984: Reappears in Cuba and receives political asylum.

• 1998: Open letter to Pope John Paul II.

• May 2, 2005: FBI designates her a domestic terrorist; $1 million reward.

• May 2, 2013: Added to the FBI’s Most Wanted Terrorists list; reward raised to $2 million.

• December 2014: Christie demands her return as the United States and Cuba move to restore relations; Cuba declines.

• June 16, 2017: Trump demands her return in a Miami speech.

• May 10, 2022: New Jersey Supreme Court orders Acoli paroled.

• September 25, 2025: Dies in Havana, aged 78.

• May 30, 2026: Celebration of her life at Riverside Church, New York.