On the night of October 12, 2002, two crowded nightspots in Kuta, the busiest tourist district on the Indonesian island of Bali, were destroyed within moments of each other. Two hundred and two people died, most of them foreign visitors: 88 were Australians, the largest loss of Australian life to a single act of terror, and 38 were Indonesians. More than 200 others were injured. Within a year more than 30 people had been brought to trial over the attacks, and three men had been sentenced to death.
Those three were Amrozi bin Haji Nurhasyim, a mechanic from the village of Tenggulun in the Lamongan district of East Java; his older brother Ali Ghufron, who went by the name Mukhlas; and Abdul Aziz, known as Imam Samudra, from Banten province in western Java. Police and prosecutors linked all three to the Southeast Asian militant network Jemaah Islamiyah.
Their convictions rested on a terrorism law written after the attacks and applied to them backward in time. For five years their lawyers fought it in every court open to them, and every challenge failed. On November 9, 2008, the three men were executed together on Nusakambangan, a prison island off the southern coast of Central Java.
The inquiry began the next day. Indonesia's National Police asked for help, and on October 13, 2002, a team from the Australian Federal Police arrived in Bali. The two forces ran the investigation together as Operation Alliance, with the Indonesian police in the lead and the suspects bound for Indonesian courts. The first arrest came three weeks later, on November 5, when police detained Amrozi in Tenggulun. Imam Samudra was arrested at the port of Merak, in Banten, on November 21, and Mukhlas in Klaten, Central Java, on December 3. By the end of the year the police held the three men prosecutors would present as the core of the operation.
What they could be charged with was not simple. Indonesia had no terrorism law when the attacks took place. Emergency regulations issued days afterward were enacted in 2003 as Law No. 15 of 2003, the Law on Combating Criminal Acts of Terrorism, and a companion measure, Law No. 16 of 2003, applied them retroactively to the attacks in Bali. Under that framework prosecutors charged all three men with plotting, organizing and carrying out terror crimes.
They were tried separately before the Denpasar District Court in Bali. Amrozi's trial opened on May 12, 2003, Imam Samudra's on June 2 and Mukhlas's on June 16. On August 7, 2003, the court found Amrozi "legally and convincingly proven guilty of terrorism" and sentenced him to death, the first of the defendants to receive a sentence. On September 10 it found Imam Samudra guilty of terrorism offenses and sentenced him to death, holding that he had played the dominant role in the operation. On October 2 it found Mukhlas guilty of plotting crimes of terrorism and of possessing firearms without permission, held him responsible for the attacks as a whole, and sentenced him to death.
More than 30 people were eventually convicted over the attacks. Among them was Ali Imron, a younger brother of Amrozi and Mukhlas, who was sentenced to life imprisonment.
The appeals ran for five years. The Bali High Court rejected Amrozi's appeal in September 2003 and Imam Samudra's in November. On July 23, 2004, the Constitutional Court ruled, by five votes to four, that applying Law No. 16 of 2003 to the attacks in Bali contradicted the 1945 constitution. Executions planned for 2006 were delayed on August 21 of that year while the defense sought judicial review in the Supreme Court, which rejected the reviews of Mukhlas on August 23, 2007, Amrozi on August 30 and Imam Samudra on September 19, finding that the defense had produced no new evidence. A second request for review was turned down in January 2008, and on July 17, 2008, the Supreme Court declared the men's right of appeal exhausted, because only one judicial review is permitted. A last petition to the Constitutional Court, against the manner of execution, was rejected on October 21, 2008. None of the three asked the president for clemency.
The question behind every appeal, whether a law written after October 12, 2002, could lawfully reach what happened that night, was decided in the men's favor by the Constitutional Court in 2004. It did not save them. The ruling did not annul verdicts already given, no later court found new evidence to reopen them, and the convictions were never set aside.
The lawfulness of convicting the three men under a retroactive statute remained in dispute to the end. The Constitutional Court found retroactive use of the law unconstitutional in 2004; the government and the Supreme Court treated the verdicts as valid, and they stood.
During his trial Mukhlas retracted the statements he had given police, alleging that they had been obtained by torture. No ruling upheld the claim.
Imam Samudra disputed that he had led the operation, and Amrozi's lawyers argued that he had not carried out the attacks himself. The court rejected both arguments and convicted each man as set out above.
October 12, 2002: Attacks on two nightspots in Kuta, Bali.
October 13, 2002: An Australian Federal Police team arrives in Bali and the joint investigation with the Indonesian National Police begins.
November 5, 2002: Amrozi is arrested in Tenggulun, East Java, the first arrest in the case.
November 21, 2002: Imam Samudra is arrested at Merak, Banten.
December 3, 2002: Mukhlas is arrested in Klaten, Central Java.
May 12, 2003: Amrozi's trial opens before the Denpasar District Court.
June 2, 2003: Imam Samudra's trial opens.
June 16, 2003: Mukhlas's trial opens.
August 7, 2003: Amrozi is found guilty of terrorism and sentenced to death.
September 10, 2003: Imam Samudra is found guilty of terrorism offenses and sentenced to death.
September 2003: The Bali High Court rejects Amrozi's appeal.
October 2, 2003: Mukhlas is found guilty of plotting crimes of terrorism and possessing firearms without permission and sentenced to death.
November 2003: The Bali High Court rejects Imam Samudra's appeal.
July 23, 2004: The Constitutional Court rules, five votes to four, that retroactive use of Law No. 16 of 2003 is unconstitutional.
August 21, 2006: Planned executions are delayed while the defense seeks judicial review.
August 23 to September 19, 2007: The Supreme Court rejects the judicial reviews of all three men.
July 17, 2008: The Supreme Court declares the right of appeal exhausted.
October 21, 2008: The Constitutional Court rejects the last petition.
November 9, 2008: All three men are executed.